The value of the rank is based off what I would do and what I look for in a prospect. I'm not in NFL War Rooms, so I can't play the speculation game that many play. The "He should be drafted here" game is futile in my opinion. People read, listen and watch you for your take on something, not just for 'what you heard' or 'here's what they might do'. For instance, I've been contacted by a few teams that have seen some of these Film Sessions (both past and this year) and said that they've brought in a player based off my breakdown. Now...how true that is, I can't call it; nice ego boost tho
Firstly, thanks for taking the time to respond. But I would contend that if you're not ranking them in terms of being drafted in the first round, you should be using a different term. If they're 'two different things', they shouldn't be referred to in the same manner.
However, to address your 2nd point. If a player is talented, but doesn't get the opportunity, is he not still talented? Prime example. I graded Jeff Mathews (Cornell) as a 2nd round QB last year. He was cut in camp w/the Falcons, bounced around practice squads last year and just got signed by the Hamilton Tiger Cats where he may be the starter this year! He only threw 1 pass for ATL in the preseason but never really got the opportunity in practice or in games. The talent was still there and he'll get that opportunity north of the border. So, It's just about opportunity for a lot of these guys. Another example would be how Terrelle Pryor keeps getting bounced around, yet Ryan Fitzpatrick & Matt Cassel keep getting contracts. You can't tell me that they are better QBs than Pryor.
In my opinion, talent
finds opportunity, talent
makes opportunity. Plenty of undrafted players make NFL rosters every year, so the process is far from perfect. But, other than extenuating circumstances like La'el Collins, 1st round talents do not go undrafted.
There's got to be something about Pryor that keeps him bouncing from team to team, and it's very likely a cerebral thing.
I very much hope that your assessment of Fields turns out to be the correct one and that the Cowboys are the beneficiaries of everyone else missing 'the next Richard Sherman'. As a fan, it would be a great 'make up call' for passing on Sherman the first time. And Dallas certainly can use some help at cornerback, no matter
where it comes from.
Again, thanks for taking the time to respond, I very much respect your ambition and determination and wish you great success in your endeavors.