SI: Chris Cooley: The advent of Smart Football, 10 Things and the skinny on the 'Skin

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,281
Reaction score
45,652
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
With Peter King on his annual four-week summer vacation, Commanders tight end Chris Cooley graciously agreed to write today's Monday Morning Quarterback column.

I was very excited to be asked to fill in for Peter King this week, though I'm slightly disappointed to be the third person asked -- I mean, seriously, Trent Green? Still, this is a very cool opportunity, and I am happy to do it.

A couple of weeks ago, I squatted over my helmet next to Shaun Suisham on the practice sideline of Commanders Park. It was your every-day water-cooler dialogue, the kicker being the guy who has nothing to do, ever, and then lingering around, begging for someone to scheme with. Conversations with a kicker are typically nonsense-filled ideas ranging from Barack Obama staring down girls' backsides to Michael Jackson's death dragging his estate out of debt. Every so often, we even talk about football, but with a kicker it's usually something about how a holder's chubby, jittery hands can mess up an entire season or why adding two games to the regular season would be so much harder on a kicking leg.

Our recent talk actually led to a profound idea. The topic was actually brought up in a kicking state of mind, wondering why the goal posts don't continue upward for another 10 yards, thus eliminating any judgment call about whether a field-goal attempt is good when the ball is kicked above the end of the bar. Then the brilliance of Smart Football was born!

Many judgment calls should be taken out of human hands. Just ask anyone from Baltimore if Santonio Holmes crossed the goal line or any Chargers fan about the Ed Hochuli blunder that led to San Diego losing in Denver last season. Those two calls alone spurred enough controversy about the NFL's referees and replay system to demand some kind of change.

The correct call in every crucial situation would purge a lot of ugly emotion and relieve tension, but can the human eye be correct every time? Seriously, look at the Holmes catch again. Watch it from every possible camera angle, then try to decide for sure whether it's a touchdown. Smart Football eliminates the guesswork.

The system begins by placing sensors in both tips of the ball and then it works with a laser or GPS system. At that point, the possibilities are endless. Technology is so advanced that determining anything that happens on the field with the ball is possible. The sensors indicate the instant the ball crosses the goal line, or any line for that matter. This eliminates officials having to slog in from the sideline, peer over 22 enormous men and try to determine from memory where the ball may have reached.

It doesn't have to stop with the end zone, the league can sensor the first-down markers, as well. Furthermore, it wouldn't be so hard to tell when a ball started or stopped moving forward or backward, which would, accordingly, determine forward progress. I'd be willing to bet Al Davis would have paid Smart Football to give Oakland the opportunity to take Tom Brady's fumble and go on to the Super Bowl.

Yes, this great new method also applies to kickers and Suisham's short goal-post theory, though it can't make ex-punters any skinnier. Goal posts are simply extended by shooting a laser upward, easily determining whether ball went through.

Oh, and before complaining about how much this would cost, consider that I'm talking about the NFL. The league in which defensive tackles receive $100 million contracts. I think there would be a way to swing some GPS technology on the field. Just maybe.

Ten Things I Think I Think
1. I think the Washington Commanders are going to have an outstanding season and win a ton of games. We've done everything a team can do in the offseason to get better. Jason Campbell is so close to being one of the best QB's in the league; he will have a great year. Note: I have to say all this regardless, but it's nice to actually believe it.

2. I think all the talk about making young quarterbacks wait their turn and learn before they play is B.S. The best way to get better at something is by doing it, so if they're ready to play, let 'em play. I know teams are very considerate about a player's psyche, but if a quarterback can't handle the scrutiny of throwing a pick in his first season, how is he going to handle it throughout his career? Might as well find out.

3. I think the NFL uniform rule is much too stringent. Guys are now being fined in the third and fourth quarters for their jerseys being untucked. Assessing a $5,000 fine for a untucked jersey is ignorant. When the thing gets yanked out of the pants it just looks like the guy is playing harder. The NFL is also fining for other minuscule things, like socks not being pulled up enough and hand towels being two inches too long. Obviously, the NFL has to keep things within reason, but insignificant uniform infractions do not affect the integrity of the game.

4. I think, sticking with the game-integrity theme, I don't know why touchdown celebrations are being eliminated. I'm not a celebration guy myself, at all, but it's part of what makes our game exciting. A touchdown is a huge moment in a game and a huge accomplishment for a player, so take it easy on fining guys for having a little fun celebrating. Besides, the last time I checked the NFL was an entertainment business, and I love watching the creativity of guys like Chad Johnson.

5. I think adding two extra games to the regular season would be great if the league would shorten the preseason by two weeks. Also, the pay raise would have to fit accordingly. With all the offseason work players put into today's game, the six weeks of training camp and preseason are a burnout. Plus, what fan wouldn't rather watch real games?

6. I think I made the Pro Bowl the last two seasons. This offseason, Tony Gonzalez and Kellen Winslow were traded into the NFC, and with young guys like Greg Olsen becoming better players, it will be very competitive when it comes to filling the two NFC tight end spots in this year's Pro Bowl. Oh, I forgot to mention Jason Witten.

7. I think the Pro Bowl should never leave Hawaii. No questions asked, it is the best place for all the players to get together with their families and celebrate a great season. Miami, the site of the 2010 Pro Bowl and Super Bowl, will be too crazy the week before the Super Bowl for anyone to relax.

8. I think if athletes/celebs are out having a good time, fans should not try to take advantage of them by sneaking photos Online. Cell-phone cameras are out of control right now. Just shake hands and say hello. Oh, and I know that if someone tries to video me taking a piss again, I'm not going to hesitate to punch them square in the face.

9. I think putting peanut butter, mustard and ham on a sandwich is awesome. The three ingredients are magical when put together.

10. I think athletes are usually terrible writers. "Cough! Donovan McNabb!" To be honest, most of the time I can't stand to read anything football players write, sorry Matt Birk. Now after stopping for a minute, I'm pretty concerned about what I've put together. Oh well, one thing's for sure, I can take a hell of a lot of criticism.

E-mail comments or questions to siwriters@simail.com and check out Cooley's official blog.
 

DEZBRYANT x88x

Caps8Cowboys41
Messages
2,763
Reaction score
20
How do you forget the best TE in the league.

But yeah he deff. would be the 3rd TE on our depth chart, what dillinger said.
 

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
This passes for journalism these days.

YIPEE!

Who's next, Eli Manning's mom?



YAKUZA
 

Meat-O-Rama

Vegetarians are so stupid.
Messages
2,615
Reaction score
614
I knew when I read the article that there would be plenty of crying over here over the perceived slight...
 

cobra

Salty *******
Messages
3,134
Reaction score
0
firehawk350;2840808 said:
Are you guys really that dense?

Hey, which is greater?

(a) 5
(b) 3

Is your football team really that inferior?
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
Sensors in the football has been discussed before, but a GPS system is useless. Anyone who has ever been geo-caching can tell you that most of those things get you within 10 yards of the goal and then you have to find the geo cache. 10 yards off in football is hardly an improvement over the eyes.

I do think that lasers could be adapted and used though and far more accurate than the human eye. They use something like it in Tennis now for line calls and it seems to work. One question that would remain though. Does the knee hit the ground before the ball crosses the goal?

In other words, you still need the human element and human judgment to review the close plays.

So why spend hundreds of thousands of dollars for something that still will have to be reviewed by the same system already in place?
 

BrAinPaiNt

Mike Smith aka Backwoods Sexy
Staff member
Messages
78,654
Reaction score
42,998
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Kind of sad that someone like Cooley can write a better column that some of the journalist paid to do it. Not that this column is great by any stretch but better than some of the stuff actual journalist pass off these days.
 

firehawk350

Active Member
Messages
2,108
Reaction score
0
cobra;2840830 said:
Hey, which is greater?

(a) 5
(b) 3

Is your football team really that inferior?
Don't hate on me because your team can't win a playoff game in over a decade. But hey, have fun living in the past.
 

Rampage

Benched
Messages
24,117
Reaction score
2
firehawk350;2840854 said:
Don't hate on me because your team can't win a playoff game in over a decade. But hey, have fun living in the past.
and yet we're still better than your team when it comes to championships:laugh2:
 

ScipioCowboy

More than meets the eye.
Messages
25,266
Reaction score
17,597
firehawk350;2840854 said:
Don't hate on me because your team can't win a playoff game in over a decade. But hey, have fun living in the past.

And somehow, the Cowboys have managed to win three Super Bowls since the Skins last won one.

:laugh2:
 

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
21,555
Reaction score
22,657
firehawk350;2840808 said:
Are you guys really that dense?

un huh...

istockphoto_1778141-dunce-cap.jpg
 

Apollo Creed

Stackin and Processin, Well
Messages
9,027
Reaction score
1,223
Hopefully he was being smug about Witten - how can you forget a great TE you see twice a year?
 

firehawk350

Active Member
Messages
2,108
Reaction score
0
Hostile;2840844 said:
Sensors in the football has been discussed before, but a GPS system is useless. Anyone who has ever been geo-caching can tell you that most of those things get you within 10 yards of the goal and then you have to find the geo cache. 10 yards off in football is hardly an improvement over the eyes.

I do think that lasers could be adapted and used though and far more accurate than the human eye. They use something like it in Tennis now for line calls and it seems to work. One question that would remain though. Does the knee hit the ground before the ball crosses the goal?

In other words, you still need the human element and human judgment to review the close plays.

So why spend hundreds of thousands of dollars for something that still will have to be reviewed by the same system already in place?
You don't have to use GPS. Lasers absolutely would not work before I jump into this.

Put two small emitters into each end. Around the stadium, place 9 receivers (preferably equidistant from each other in a place not likely to get harmed like te support structure). Have the emitter emit a high frequency radio wave (higher frequencies are easier to triangulate accurately). Connect all the receivers to a central computer and plot out the azimuth and elevation of each emitter in relationship to the each receiver. Simple triangulation could give you a very exact positioning of the ball at any given time and making a simple 3D model based off the ends would be just a matter of computer modelling.
 

firehawk350

Active Member
Messages
2,108
Reaction score
0
Apollo Creed;2840871 said:
Hopefully he was being smug about Witten - how can you forget a great TE you see twice a year?
It's not a difficult literary concept honestly. It was said tongue in cheek. He's just saying the division is loaded with TE talent.
 
Top