DFWJC;5065836 said:
Really?
I don't see it and I'm a glass half full type
Freddy at 31
Escobar at 47
we are talking two full round reaches right there
Passed on Terron Armstead in the mid 3rd round?
Passed on Demontro Moore and John Jenkin for Wilcox in the 3rd ...and Phillip Thomas is till out there too?
None of these are bad players. I think most can contiribute eventually-and for top 3 round that is for sure expected.
I just think it has be a C- or D+ effort when we had B+ to A- staring us in the face.
Gotta disagree with both of you.
I think the trade down in r1 got us off to a bad start and thus makes this at best an OK draft. We lost value and then didn't recover it with the pick at 31. I wish we would have taken Geno Smith at 31 then dangled him for the Jets and others over night.
Frederick was a reach by about 15 picks. ( at 47 we'd have all been happy with him as highest rated ol around) After him no OL was taken for a long time. And at least some scouts like our own loved him. He wasn't gonna make to r3 for sure. the ol before frederick were pugh and long which were both reaches imho. interior ol had about 5 guy then thinned out mightily.
Escobar wasn't a big reach. Crazy odd pick for a team with Witten and Hanna yes, but big reach, no. Seen him between 50-90 consistently. The Boys rated him their 2nd best TE. I still don't know what to make of this pick but it could be a DeMarco Murray type selection where the Dallas scouts are right and just go get value. He clearly has very real receiving skills. In fact at SDST he was really just a big WR. Could be intriguing in that Aaron Hernandez way here. But I'd have never taken him in round 2. I got other holes to fill and would have taken a spare blocking TE later on. Am impressed by his agility numbers even as his 40 time had me laughing and shaking my head.
Terrence Williams is real value. He is pretty consistently a top 60 player and only a glut of quality WRs pushes him down even that far. Guy had almost 2k yards receiving with a 1 year starter at QB. That's impressive period. Right after we took him a big run began on WRs.
JJ Wilcox was a guy our scouts loved. They targeted him heavily and after we took him there was a pretty big run on DBs.
So I think we did well in round 3. Maybe even an A for round 3.
But r1 was a C- and r2 no more than a C.
Dallas scouts clearly key agility drills over 40 times. Frederick and Escobar were excellent in agility drills but slow as molasses in the 40. Guess we won't ask either to run far in straight lines.