You casually slide in for a second year QB. You make it sound like he should get a participation award. So which is it.
My claims aren't false. It's you who chose to give him the benefit of the doubt. I am simply stating reality. It was in his college evaluation and I still heard it repeated this year in training camp.
Dont shot the messenger. I own a Dak Jersey. Go Cowboys. Great rookie record. Leader. Dez was a energy suffocating bully. Falcons game.
But he still has weaknesses. And just because every time I point them out as being a factor in any hypothetical discussion on this message board. You all get triggered and spew hateful insults. In some way to demonize me and discredit my opinion as invalid.
A lot of the arguments you use are a hopeful forecast.
You dismiss reality and jump to a natural progression argument. You take a "there's no way he can fail" aproach based on him being Dak. When in reality its him, Daks deficiencies which will hold him back.
I am hopeful for him this year. But in no way can he be considered great. The NFL has his number but I believe the Cowboys will reinvent themselves to suit Daks strengths.
(Which has nothning to do with Wr route Running or speed or hands) none of that BS they are spewing.
No its gonna be an offense that exploits the 20 yds off the line of scrimmage.
We are gonna be a methodical juggernaut
I’ve never thrown a personal insult at you. So blameshifting that onto me, isn’t really based in reality.
So don’t accuse me of not being realistic, while making false claims about my behavior.
I clearly stated the, for a second year QB, part for a reason. Nobody “slid” anything in. It was clearly written in my post. Saying I “slid” it in, makes a false assumption about my intentions for saying it. Which couldn’t be further from the truth.
1. It’s pertinent to any Dak discussion to mention he is a second year QB because the nature of the NFL is such that no second year QB excels at reading defenses and going through progressions. That is something that gets improved on over years of playing QB in the league.
2. You made a blanket statement that Dak can’t
Read defenses and doesn’t go through his professions. You did not provide any nuance to the claim, only stating that he cannot do either of those things. Except Dak can do those things, and Dak does do those things pretty well for a QB with his experience level. That is the reality. Saying he absolutely cannot and does not is not reality at all. So again, you preaching to me about reality based arguments is kind of rediculous when I was responding to your post that was false.
If you want to actually break down Dak’s ability to read defense and go through progressions that’s fine. But just outright saying he can’t and doesn’t is false and anybody who watches QB play knows it.
Does he need to improve on those? Of course. But Dak doesn’t play QB in a vacuum. Some of us chooose to judge his performance knowing he is a second year player, playing the toughest position in the league and one that typically takes even the best quarterbacks years to grow and improve into the players they become.
