Oh but Romo was better than Aikman right??? Sorry to start that up again. But the league was differen
Loved Aikman. Can't take away his SB victories. I would still take Aikman over Romo and Dak.
I'm I'm going to be honest here. Aikman had the best pedigree of the 3 and the best teams. One thing that Aikman didn't excel at in the second half of his career was dealing with change. I think Jimmy leaving really hurt this team. They were not prepared to be coached by a clown. I remember Aikman just becoming a tree in the pocket, refusing to roll out, adapting late to the headphone in the helmet. Remember he preferred the hand signals? He also refused the shotgun as he preferred to be under center. He had his warts no doubt. And frankly he was his best in the first SB, where he won MVP. The second SB he had the concussion and the third against the Steelers I was more relieved we won as the longer the game went, the better the Steelers looked.
He will be elevated no matter what with the SB wins, and I would take young Aikman over Romo and Dak... Is that even a question. BTW, this is the first time I have been critical of Aikman on this board.
I don't understand why Romo puts fans in Stockholm syndrome? He was great statistically but never elite in his era. A lot of passing td's but everyone throws a lot of TD's since he played. He had more than good enough talent around him.
Romo made amazing plays, and was dynamic no doubt. But I was always waiting for the boneheaded play and he always delivered. If you are going to be a great player you have to eventually deliver and win the big game. You have to have a signature moment. I'm not even saying win the SB. I remember a lot of us mocking McNabb when he recently stated he is a HOF'er, and I agree. No matter how his career ended with the Skins, McNabb was really good for the Eagles, 4 straight championship games is no joke. He made a SB.. yeah he threw up during the game..
Circling back to Prescott. He may not have the skills of Aikman or Romo, but so far he outplays what I expect from him. His first year, when it took him 5 games to throw his first TD, and he was truly Dinky & Dunking... I wasn't buying it. As I have stated multiple times.. He is the middle of the pack in terms of QB's in the league. 13-16 range.