1. Read the latest Dallas Cowboys news ..

The State of Texas today had to remove 3,484 cases from its Covid-19 positive case count

Discussion in 'Coronavirus Zone' started by iceberg, Jul 16, 2020.

  1. iceberg

    iceberg rock music matters Zone Supporter

    33,852 Messages
    7,073 Likes Received


    this is why it gets so frustrating. no one believes the #'s and the #'s drive everything we do.
     
  2. Trendnet

    Trendnet Well-Known Member

    1,017 Messages
    354 Likes Received
    It's frustrating because people don't understand what was done and post nonsense like what Eagar posted without clarification. And then people get riled up and start sprouting conspiracy theories.
     
    NumOneQB and Rustinpeace21 like this.
  3. Rustinpeace21

    Rustinpeace21 Well-Known Member

    946 Messages
    451 Likes Received
    Nevermind that fact that 3400 cases, is maybe 3-4% of all the cases diagnosed cases in the last 14 days. Hardly a dent.
     
    Red Dragon and MichaelWinicki like this.
  4. iceberg

    iceberg rock music matters Zone Supporter

    33,852 Messages
    7,073 Likes Received
    it's frustrating because we've NEVER had issues before counting infections. yet for this one, no one can simply say:

    Infected: Yes | NO

    and leave it at that.
     
    cml750 likes this.
  5. EPL0c0

    EPL0c0 The Funcooker

    6,304 Messages
    1,768 Likes Received
    I guess Texas was counting positive antigen tests as "probable" positive COVID-19 tests (makes sense since antigen tests check if a person has had the virus).

    If I'm reading this right:
    - nucleic acid based tests, like PCR tests look for genetic material of the virus.
    - antigen tests look proteins or glycans like those on the surface of the virus.

    If it detects the presence of virus antibodies then I can see why it's considered a "probable" and really could be categorized as "recovered"

    I dunno, I'm just a meathead English major though. Please, smarter folks, can you make better sense of this?

    [​IMG]
     
    MichaelWinicki likes this.
  6. Hoofbite

    Hoofbite Well-Known Member

    37,274 Messages
    7,030 Likes Received
    My state lists both and will retroactively change the classification if laboratory testing is performed. I imagine this is the same for most states .

    [​IMG]
     
    csirl and EPL0c0 like this.
  7. Rustinpeace21

    Rustinpeace21 Well-Known Member

    946 Messages
    451 Likes Received
    Hopefully most states do this. This is from “worldometer” today, who publishes cases, and deaths per day charts, this is from their national chart today.

    “NOTE: Texas: Bexar County reported 5,501 cases today, 691 of which represent new cases, while 4,810 were backlogged, the result of "kinks in the communication process with the state, and that cases have been underreported in the past two weeks" according to reports citing San Antonio Mayor Ron Nirenberg. Some of the 21 reported deaths were also backlogged [source] Worldometer has redistributed the 4,810 backlogged cases over the previous 14 days based on the existing pattern of Bexar County”

    The point is they don’t just add or subtract all backlogged cases or deaths to a single day.
     
    EPL0c0 likes this.
  8. NumOneQB

    NumOneQB Well-Known Member

    2,324 Messages
    1,933 Likes Received
    This is a huge issue. Giving idiots a platform to spout off nonsense that encourages more idiots to spout off a derivative of the nonsense spouted off, in turn causing a movement of idiots to spout off wild conspiracy theory.
     
  9. DanteEXT

    DanteEXT Well-Known Member

    3,108 Messages
    1,384 Likes Received
    My understanding of antigen tests is they detect an active infection not a recovered. The benefits are they are usually cheaper and provide faster results. The downside is they are not as reliable as the PCR test.
     
    EPL0c0 and iceberg like this.
  10. iceberg

    iceberg rock music matters Zone Supporter

    33,852 Messages
    7,073 Likes Received
    what is even more frustrating and a *huge issue* to me is that we can't talk about the issues we all in fact are facing TOGETHER, whether we like it or not. we attack other mindsets without cause nor concern - we just disagree so they must be idiots.

    the fact remains that the counts are a huge issue and never in our history before have they been. you either test positive or you don't. this "probable" is NOT a YES and if you wish to create a PROBABLY category then do so and count them separately and figure out what to do with them later.

    counting the way they have been and changing how they decide to count so many times brings the doubt upon themselves.
     
    Vtwin and NumOneQB like this.
  11. DanteEXT

    DanteEXT Well-Known Member

    3,108 Messages
    1,384 Likes Received
    I can't speak for Texas (or even my state as I don't know if they even are using antigen testing) as to why they do not include them. They do get reported to the CDC and are included in those numbers from what I read.
     
  12. iceberg

    iceberg rock music matters Zone Supporter

    33,852 Messages
    7,073 Likes Received
    what i don't think i will ever understand at a logical (political and emotional, sure) level is it's simple.

    Positive Test = YES | NO

    count the YES's and NO's and we're done.

    if you MUST count "probable" fine - but do NOT include them in YES because that is wrong and taints the data.

    So if we had 60000 = yes and 80000 = probably then we can say we have 140k probable to yes and know what we're talking about. but when they don't test people and use vague symptoms to say YES - that is wrong.

    and that will cause people to question your methodology every time. after that they question motives and this is where things get "fun".
     
  13. iceberg

    iceberg rock music matters Zone Supporter

    33,852 Messages
    7,073 Likes Received
    then again - create another category for which to put these results and we figure out how to count them all later when we know more.

    but that isn't what we are doing.
     
  14. DanteEXT

    DanteEXT Well-Known Member

    3,108 Messages
    1,384 Likes Received
    I agree. A positive test should be counted as a yes. What I have read is the antigen test is less reliable in that it may produce more false negatives. But that just confuses the situation as to why you would not include the positive results from those tests.
     
  15. ABQCOWBOY

    ABQCOWBOY Regular Joe....

    54,799 Messages
    22,825 Likes Received
    The issue here is the practice of creating uncertainty through misreporting. This is very simple. If you want people to trust what you are telling them, you want them to have confidence in policy, things like wearing masks etc., then stop screwing things like this up and stop using it to create hyperbole.

    Or don't and understand that you are never going to get those folks on board with how you want them to behave in this pandemic.

    Simple..........
     
    zrinkill, cml750 and iceberg like this.
  16. iceberg

    iceberg rock music matters Zone Supporter

    33,852 Messages
    7,073 Likes Received
    then classify them separately and note the inconclusive nature. to simply say COUNT THEM is either a panic move, just stupid and not thinking (not uncommon these days) or then yes, trying to "cook the books". so even if they are doing it for "good" reasons, it's still being done and that gives way to all the drama around it.

    given how much "intentional damage" groups out there seem hellbent on causing, yes. i have to wonder if some groups are doing it on purpose for the fear factor. collin county had a public city council meeting where they said if you came in contact with someone who had tested positive, you now count as positive. What i have no idea on this one is how they KNOW someone got close enough to simply slide over.

    but the fact they stated this is, in my mind, a huge cause for concern and valid reason to doubt the numbers.
     
    Vtwin likes this.
  17. iceberg

    iceberg rock music matters Zone Supporter

    33,852 Messages
    7,073 Likes Received
    ba-bamb. the cliff note version. >g<
     
    cml750 likes this.
  18. Bizwah

    Bizwah Well-Known Member

    7,488 Messages
    2,597 Likes Received
    Great post.
     
  19. Oz-of-Cowboy-Country

    Oz-of-Cowboy-Country Well-Known Member

    4,691 Messages
    5,631 Likes Received
    All we are ever going to have is estimates. Even after all is said and done...we'll still be left with estimates.

    I'm just doing my part to slow the spread...washing my hands often, stay six feet where possible and wearing a mask. We just have to slow the spread and wait more a vaccine. So the numbers being wrong or right changes nothing.
     
    EPL0c0 likes this.
  20. csirl

    csirl Well-Known Member

    2,499 Messages
    2,595 Likes Received
    How are things on the ground in Texas? I live in Europe and we're getting news reports similar to what we saw earlier in NY and northern Italy.
     

Share This Page