The Tony Romo era is not over

Status
Not open for further replies.

BrassCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,808
Reaction score
3,401
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I don't mind signing a decent backup (if Cassel proves unworthy), but I don't want to spend a first-round or second-round pick on a player who will be a backup, and not necessarily a capable backup, especially if forced into action as a rookie.

We could have planned ahead for this Romo injury, we could have used our first-round pick in 2012 and drafted a capable backup, Brandon Weeden... Instead we wasted that pick on a Pro Bowl Center named Travis Fredrick...

the problem with your theory of drafting a future qb in lower than third round is that those QBs wont be good enough. I know a number of #1s fail too, but generally your starter is found early.

Now you say it would be backup we would be drafting, but Romo is not getting any younger. Injuries even like this clavicle may of been avoided if he was 7-8 years younger due to the speed and agility at moving your body naturally in order to protect it as well as bones that are even just a little more pliable. I am not saying he cant play a couple more years, but with his current chronic back problem, which he did already complain about before the Philadelphia game (due to a good hit against Giants), I would not being putting a whole lot of marbles in his basket. We need a backup plan.

Unfortunately, this team may have took too long to catch up to Romo, but I hope you are right in saying he has 3-4 more years, but everything in nature says that is not the case.
 

ologan

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,189
Reaction score
616
The season is over. I won't be one of those guys that comes back and say "I told you so", but there's no way we make the playoffs. Prepare yourself.

It'll be a waste of your time to hang around then. Time for you to start following basketball....come on back around draft time, next year.
 

Dodger12

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,142
Reaction score
3,532
Aaron Rodgers was a bit of a lucky break for the Packers in the sense that they didn't know when Favre was going to retire (he flirted with retirement for roughly his last 37 seasons with Green Bay). If they knew Favre was going to play for 3+ more seasons, I doubt they end up drafting Rodgers.

I don't think Favre flirted with retirement in 2004/2005 but he was 36 years old. He was coming off a 4,000 yard and 30 TD season. GB knew he was closer to the end and was in a similar situation we currently are with Romo. His value at #24 was too good for GB to pass up. It's lucky that Rodgers turned out to be as great as he is but their decision to pick Rodgers who some thought would go #1 overall with the 24th pick was a good move.

I think GB knew Favre had a few years left in him and weren't looking for Rodgers to start immediately. It was a good move.
 

perrykemp

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,503
Reaction score
9,274
I don't think Favre flirted with retirement in 2004/2005 but he was 36 years old. He was coming off a 4,000 yard and 30 TD season. GB knew he was closer to the end and was in a similar situation we currently are with Romo. His value at #24 was too good for GB to pass up. It's lucky that Rodgers turned out to be as great as he is but their decision to pick Rodgers who some thought would go #1 overall with the 24th pick was a good move.

I think GB knew Favre had a few years left in him and weren't looking for Rodgers to start immediately. It was a good move.

The guy the Packers <really> wanted at 24 was none other than Marcus Spears.

Oh the irony.
 

Eddie

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,092
Reaction score
5,862
Hold on there, I don't mind you being part of the Super Bowl win this year with the Cowboys, but that Mega Millions jackpot is all mine !!!! :laugh::yourock::oldcouple:

If you live in Illinois, they're with-holding $288 million worth of lotto winnings. Money is mine.

But we'll be flirting with 2-7 by the time Romo gets back. Super Bowl victory is just a nice dream for a team playing towards a top 5 pick.
 

8FOR!3

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,310
Reaction score
1,810
I agree, but injuries happen, it's not like he's Sam Bradford...

I get it, but he's not your typical athlete. He's not brittle by any means, but he's 35 and his body has been breaking down on him a little the past few years. It absolutely has not affected his play, he's just as much of a gamer as he's always been. But it means I have to cringe every time he takes a hit because I know his body can no longer take those very well. I don't think it means we need to look to replace him, but we need to start looking for the guy we can groom to take over when his body finally tells him he has to give it up.

Johnny Manziel makes sense if he's available for a mid to late round pick. Because one, he holds value when you consider what quarterbacks are typically available in those rounds...And two because even if you don't like him you've got to admit he's probably a little more gifted than Jameill Showers (beat him out at A&M didn't he? and sent him packing to UTEP) and he's a better experiment than Weeden, Stephen McGee, I'D consider him much more talent than Dustin Vaughn, etc.

I know ya'll are gonna try and eat me alive for the Manziel comments but it has a little more sense to it now than it ever has. His stock is a little low and his play on the field has been pretty par from what we've seen this year. I'd as soon have him out there than B-Weeden and at least Johnny still has upside.
 

8FOR!3

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,310
Reaction score
1,810
If you live in Illinois, they're with-holding $288 million worth of lotto winnings. Money is mine.

But we'll be flirting with 2-7 by the time Romo gets back. Super Bowl victory is just a nice dream for a team playing towards a top 5 pick.

I honest to God think we'll get at least one W until he gets back, maybe two if we can somehow sneak by the Giants. I think we're a better team than the Bucs.
 

Eddie

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,092
Reaction score
5,862
I honest to God think we'll get at least one W until he gets back, maybe two if we can somehow sneak by the Giants. I think we're a better team than the Bucs.

Lemme rub my crystall balls and predict the future.
 

lwehlers

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,631
Reaction score
2,738
The season is over. I won't be one of those guys that comes back and say "I told you so", but there's no way we make the playoffs. Prepare yourself.

If we win two of the next four games we still have a chance that's if the giants do not run away with the division in the next four weeks. if we go 1-3 and the giants go 3-1 it will tough even when romo and dez are back playing.
 

TwoDeep3

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,506
Reaction score
17,339
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
What is it with this sudden infatuation with so many Dallas fans acting like the season is over, the draft is practically tomorrow, and that we desperately need to draft a QB with our top pick...?...

Last I checked, we still have a MVP-caliber QB, who indicated earlier this year that he wants to play for at least another 3-4 seasons beyond 2015... And it's not like Romo has shown decline, on the contrary, he has actually gotten better with age.

The Cowboys are pretty good right now, and our focus should be drafting other impact players to surround Romo with so we can win now. It's not time to worry about winning 5 years from now...

Why are so many zoners rushing to put in fork in the Tony Romo era? He's not done, not even close, but we are close to contending for a Super Bowl, and now is the time to go all-in with Romo. You can draft 200 QB's before you find another one as good as Romo, so you don't waste his best years by throwing away a 1st-round pick on a QB who's destined to ride the bench and will probably be a bust anyway.

Furthermore, Tony's not dead, he will return soon, and he will save our season. All this talk of QB will look even more silly if we're picking last in the first-round, which is exactly what Romo says will happen, just ask Tom Brady...

The season is not over, and Romo's era is about as over as John Elway's era was over in 1994...

It is pretty simple.

Romo is 35 about to be 36. When you build a team, you do so with a contingency plan.

Back in 1991 Dallas had Beuerlein as the back-up. Aikman went down and Beuerlein stepped up and won games. And Aikman was about 24 or so at the time, not 35/36.

This is a physical game where the quarterback is essentially standing still and being rush by big people at nearly full speed that outweigh him by 75 pounds or more.

You don't go off-roading in your 4x4 without a spare tire.

This organization has played the lottery on the back-up for a number of years, counting on Romo's health. Football is a game built on youth. Romo is close to the end. Not because of his skill set, - however one might make the case of no one knows when his throwing arm will begin the inevitable decline into something not considered a pro throwing arm - but because of the beating he takes year in and year out. To ignore this is Jerry being frugal to the point he risks diminishing what he and his staff have built. Which is a team, when functioning with all pieces, has a shot at being the best in the league.

But Jerry, in his history has poor-boyed his quest for a title without Jimmy's fingerprints as the architect. And this is another indication he will cut corners.

There is also the notion that with the youth on this team, if and when Romo retires, transitioning to the next quarterback would be far more seamless if Jones looked to Green Bay and emulated their choosing Rogers when they had Favre. The idea of still having a winning core with the likes of Quincy Carter, or a dried up has-been taking over is about as appealing as a colonoscopy.

It's making business decisions wherein you play for today, with a plan for the unexpected, and an eye on tomorrow.

But unless you have a crystal ball about Romo's future health, or are blithely ignorant on the reason this season has gone to the dung heap with a broken clavicle , I don't truly understand the reasoning behind this position.
 

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru
Messages
33,541
Reaction score
38,181
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
They had interest in every QB that went day 2 last year as well as Hundley who was considered a day 2 talent by many.

Like it or not the Cowboys have started preparing for the future at QB. The Weeden debacle will only hasten that
 

Eddie

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,092
Reaction score
5,862
Flirting with 2-7 is essentially predicting we'll go 2-7 is it not? I think we have a chance to win a couple of games.

That's what I said. Lemme rub my crystal balls and predict 2-7.
 

Eddie

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,092
Reaction score
5,862
Hey, Matthew Stafford will be available soon for cheap. Jerry Jones loves to turn-over first round busts ...
 

SultanOfSix

Star Power
Messages
12,957
Reaction score
8,174
Romo is still playing great, but his age has obviously made health a concern. I think he needs to get rid of the ball a tad bit faster now instead of trying to make something happen that could be there when it's not there. Yeah, it's hard to take that portion of the Tony Romo completely out of Tony Romo - I'm not sure you'd really want to - and he could get injured in other ways, but you want to minimize the opportunities for injury. This also means kicking the offensive line into gear to better protect and the coaching staff to scheme better and call plays where the ball can be gotten rid of quicker.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top