This is why it's hard to blame the D for Sunday's loss

I believe not running the football is extremely problematic, not just for the offense.

Just passing the ball let's the clock roll on out, while the defense can't get long breathers. Even if you do score, it's probably pretty quick.

I'm not saying we have to be a running jugernaut. But...Running the ball let's the offense pace itself, keeps the D honest, control the tempo of the game and the clock. Passing all the time can get a little frenzied. Can also lead to quick 3 and outs/punts. And there goes the defense, back on the field.
That’s where elite play calling comes in. Not Schottenheinous, ‘elite’ play calling, but truly elite play calling.

Calling a running play should be to set the tone, a set up to open up a bigger play, something to serve as a counter, if your best suit is throwing the football.

It’s not, ‘let us run the football just for the sake of it’.

Brian definitely needs to hand the reins to Klayton and just act as a ‘walk around’ head coach.

He can overwhelm a defense if he has the talent, but he has no feel for when a defense adds nuance to their play calls.
 
Last edited:
That’s where elite play calling comes in. Not Schottenheinous, ‘elite’ play calling, but truly elite play calling.

Calling a running play should be to set the tone, a set up to open up a bigger play, something to serve as a counter, if your best suit is throwing the football.

It’s not, ‘let us run the football just for the sake of it’.

Brian definitely needs to hand the reins to Klayton and just act as a ‘walk around’ head coach.

He can overwhelm a defense if he has the talent, but he has no feel for when a defense adds nuance to their play calls.
Right. It's like they say "we said we'd run the ball at the meeting this morning...so run it is".

Instead of looking at the field and what the defense presents.

I would expect 11 year vet Dak to assume command over that. He's totally immune to benchings or dismisal. he SHOULD know better.

But he's a company stooge...a coward. With declining physical and cognitive skills. The paychecks are more important.....as if there's not enough now.

we're screwed.
 
How about a 1st down to end the game? How about crossing mid field so our kicker can go out there and possibly win the game for us? I know, that's asking for too much. You claim thats wanting to score on every possession, which is a straw man.
You’re right. That was a straw man. What is NOT is that our OFFENSE scored 30 points, and not Sunday now at any point this year has Dallas won a game without scoring 34 or more, and Dallas was up by TWO TD’s In the fourth quarter, and still lost.

Go read all the sports sites. Show me one…ONE…who says with a straight face that this is even a MEDIOCRE defense.

We spotted them 14 points in the fourth quarter and still lost. No one argues it wouldn’t have been SUPER helpful for our offense to NOT pick that time to wet the bed, but they passed and ran on Dalas AT WILL.

How do you people just not get that there is a group on the field on OFFENSIVE plays that is DIFFERENT from those players on the field during DEFENSIVE plays? If the Dallas defense just does what the Cardinals did (make some stops), then Dallas wins. They couldn’t stop ANYTHING in the fourth quarter.

And we spotted them 14 and STILL lost.

And we scored 30.

But the problem is NOT the defense?
 
Before Sunday's games the Bills were giving up 30 pts/gm. Take Allen out and they would be lucky to have the record we do. The QB can make that much of a difference. And yes, they have a great running game. But they don't have the receivers we do.
I am not denying that a QB can make a difference. Allen, Mahomes and Burrows are elite. I would not compare dak to elite QBs.

I am sure your next response is but 60M....

still 30 should be enough. 3 years now this defense has been bottom feeding. no progress. could we have, should we have expectations to win on Sunday in over time? yes.
but I had expectations not to give up 4 straight TD drives to a bunch of back up preseason players. you get a 14 point lead with half a quarter to go. you win the game. but with these cowboys no lead is safe. I mean, they drove 80 yards and scored a TD in one minute and we got lucky to get into overtime.
 
You’re right. That was a straw man. What is NOT is that our OFFENSE scored 30 points, and not Sunday now at any point this year has Dallas won a game without scoring 34 or more, and Dallas was up by TWO TD’s In the fourth quarter, and still lost.

Go read all the sports sites. Show me one…ONE…who says with a straight face that this is even a MEDIOCRE defense.

We spotted them 14 points in the fourth quarter and still lost. No one argues it wouldn’t have been SUPER helpful for our offense to NOT pick that time to wet the bed, but they passed and ran on Dalas AT WILL.

How do you people just not get that there is a group on the field on OFFENSIVE plays that is DIFFERENT from those players on the field during DEFENSIVE plays? If the Dallas defense just does what the Cardinals did (make some stops), then Dallas wins. They couldn’t stop ANYTHING in the fourth quarter.

And we spotted them 14 and STILL lost.

And we scored 30.

But the problem is NOT the defense?
Find me one post I made where I called the defense anything but bad. But that doesn't let the offense off the hook. They had multiple chances to win the game and failed. The D at least went out there in OT did what they had to and got a stop. Any pints scored would have won the game, FG... TD... ANYTHING. They went 3 and out. That's isn't the defense's fault.
 
I am not denying that a QB can make a difference. Allen, Mahomes and Burrows are elite. I would not compare dak to elite QBs.

I am sure your next response is but 60M....

still 30 should be enough. 3 years now this defense has been bottom feeding. no progress. could we have, should we have expectations to win on Sunday in over time? yes.
but I had expectations not to give up 4 straight TD drives to a bunch of back up preseason players. you get a 14 point lead with half a quarter to go. you win the game. but with these cowboys no lead is safe. I mean, they drove 80 yards and scored a TD in one minute and we got lucky to get into overtime.
Don't take the money if you aren't going to deliver. Don't take the money and then expect the team to find some other way besides you coming through when you have the chance.
 
Don't take the money if you aren't going to deliver. Don't take the money and then expect the team to find some other way besides you coming through when you have the chance.
seriously? you said that? who would do that. so you think you are qualified for a job you applied for. and they offer you more than you asked, you are going to say, well, I am qualified but not that qualified so please lower the salary?

and how much less should he have taken? you know the top 12 QBs in the league make 53M and more. you want to tell me all 12 are delivering?
 
seriously? you said that? who would do that. so you think you are qualified for a job you applied for. and they offer you more than you asked, you are going to say, well, I am qualified but not that qualified so please lower the salary?

and how much less should he have taken? you know the top 12 QBs in the league make 53M and more. you want to tell me all 12 are delivering?
Who offered him more than he asked? And it's not like other players haven't understood their actual worth and worked with the team. Still waiting for Dak's deal to be passed.
 
You’re right. That was a straw man. What is NOT is that our OFFENSE scored 30 points, and not Sunday now at any point this year has Dallas won a game without scoring 34 or more, and Dallas was up by TWO TD’s In the fourth quarter, and still lost.

Go read all the sports sites. Show me one…ONE…who says with a straight face that this is even a MEDIOCRE defense.

We spotted them 14 points in the fourth quarter and still lost. No one argues it wouldn’t have been SUPER helpful for our offense to NOT pick that time to wet the bed, but they passed and ran on Dalas AT WILL.

How do you people just not get that there is a group on the field on OFFENSIVE plays that is DIFFERENT from those players on the field during DEFENSIVE plays? If the Dallas defense just does what the Cardinals did (make some stops), then Dallas wins. They couldn’t stop ANYTHING in the fourth quarter.

And we spotted them 14 and STILL lost.

And we scored 30.

But the problem is NOT the defense?
Our O scored 20. Keep the facts straight!!!
 
Who offered him more than he asked? And it's not like other players haven't understood their actual worth and worked with the team. Still waiting for Dak's deal to be passed.
Jerry offered 60M. I can ask for 2M a year salary for my job. doesn't mean the employer is going to hire me. but if employer needs my skills and has nobody on staff that can do that and they have no other candidates, and there is a deadline and the deadline is NOW, guess who holds the cards.

that was essentially what Jerry the moron did. didn't have a single QB on the team. didn't have any other candidates he spoke to, waited until literally an hour before the game to resign him...Jerry is the idiot.

like I said, Dak could have asked for 70M, 80M, doesn't mean he should get it, nor should jones pay it.....Jones folded.
 
Find me one post I made where I called the defense anything but bad. But that doesn't let the offense off the hook. They had multiple chances to win the game and failed. The D at least went out there in OT did what they had to and got a stop. Any pints scored would have won the game, FG... TD... ANYTHING. They went 3 and out. That's isn't the defense's fault.
The offense you say is so terrible spotted the defense two TD’s. Kurt Warner just did a breakdown and said the defense “makes no sense”.

I trust a two-TD spot and Kurt Warner more than I do you.
 
Our O scored 20. Keep the facts straight!!!
Did Dallas or did Dallas NOT have a 14 point lead in the fourth quarter?

Now look, throughout the HISTORY of the NFL, at how many teams LOSE after being up by 14 in the fourth quarter.

You’re welcome.
 
Why single out the defense? Can you blame the offense? Yes! The team, as whole is not good. The offense scores, the defense gives up a TD. The defense holds, the offense spits the bit. If both offense and defense are good, the special teams is trash. Any given game has fans in awe of the ineptitude on our screens.
 
Wrong again!!!

75% on the d . It's very easy for me to blame the defense for giving up 23 points in the 4th quarter. I think they allowed 27 total points in the second half&OT, though I can't remember exactly. That's all on the defense. Let's stop debating this. They may have played better at times, but they didn't close out the game. You can try to feel better by saying they've improved or by blaming Schottenheimer for play calling, but he scored 30 points, that's enough to win most NFL games. He should have had at least two winning seasons. If not for the bad defense, the offense did its job. I'm only giving 75% blame to the defense because other factors, like special teams, also play a role.


I'll give the offense some credit, mainly for the struggles of the offensive line. There were issues with blocking, and receivers not consistently getting open when the quarterback was under pressure. The run game was virtually nonexistent, making the offense one-dimensional. Yes, he kept running the ball when asked, but it wasn’t effective. Even so, they still managed to score 30 points.

The defense had a double-digit lead in the second half and only needed to make one or two more stops, they failed to do so.

While the offense shares some blame, especially for not moving the ball effectively in the 4th quarter or overtime, that falls largely on the offensive line, not the play caller.

That's on the offensive line though. That's not the play caller. That is not Schottenheimers. Bad decisions or not being aggressive enough. The offensive line has been pretty bad since the Tampa Bay game. It stepped up in one game. In the run game. So they had a solid game, but what happened to all that? Just like in Tampa Bay and Green Bay, there were free runners Coming at Prescott at the snap, nobody even put a finger on some of these guys.

I mean, they look like the best defense in football. Against that offensive line.

So yes, there is some blame to go around, about 25%. That's it. That's all I'm giving. I'm sick of this. It's the defense and special teams in the Ravens game. And the Green Bay game? Sure, the offense had turnovers in the Tampa Bay game, and I'll give you that. Still, the defense cannot be excused. It's easy to blame the defense because, for four years now, since 2016, we've had a strong offense paired with a historically bad defense. Yes, there has been some improvement, but it's not enough. They choke in the 4th quarter, and that's when the game was lost. Period. End of story. That PAT should never have been missed, and that's on the defense.
:facepalm:
:facepalm::rolleyes:
 
Did Dallas or did Dallas NOT have a 14 point lead in the fourth quarter?

Now look, throughout the HISTORY of the NFL, at how many teams LOSE after being up by 14 in the fourth quarter.

You’re welcome.
Did Dallas or did Dall NOT get the ball at the 5 on a pick and get a FG when STs had a great return?

Guess I shouldn't be shocked that you didn't even understand this. It's really obvious.
 
Why can’t we blame both? They both sucked. The offense was inconsistent and bad across the game while the defense was good one half and heinously historically awful in the other half and thus overall weighs out to being inconsistent and bad.
Nd also the defense did well in OT. We had a chance, only needed 20 yards for our best player to put it away (Aubrey) after a defensive 3 and out stop and couldn't do it.
 

Cowboys Pick'em

DAL @ IND
Nov 8, 2026 at 12:00 PM
Make your pick
49 member(s) have picked so far. Picks are revealed at kickoff.
+ 13 more games to pick this week
Season leaders
🥇 12+88=7 12+88=7 325
🥈 Hagman Hagman 305
🥉 Kwyn Kwyn 295
🥉 SlammedZero SlammedZero 295

Survivor Pool

23 of 87 still standing
Week 9 · last kickoff Nov 9, 2026 at 7:15 PM
Most picked (locked games)
JAX @BAL 6%

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
477,226
Messages
14,756,322
Members
24,247
Latest member
mecs
Back
Top