Thursday night game thread

[DandyDon52]

I can't tell if this is a serious question or not.

Scoring O:

GB - 13th
DC - 24th

Scoring D:

GB - 17th
DC - 3rd

That kind of tells the story. You flip QBs and the Cowboys are probably one of the favorites in the NFC.

Well Sydia, you missed my point
I will try to be more clear.
Both teams have losing records, so if it is Dak's fault for Dallas record, then it has to be Rodgers fault for GB's record.
They both are losers right now lol.
I am not saying Dak is better QB or the same as Rodgers.

However I would like to put Dak on GB team for 3-5 games, and Rodgers on Cowboys for same # of games, and see how each fares.
That would be interesting.
I think Dak could easily flourish in GB, but I dont know if Rodgers would do better here than he does in GB.
He would probably be arguing with coaches a lot here lol.

 

[DandyDon52]

Seriously. You put Rogers on the Cowboys and they're a SB contender despite Garrett.

Well if you make Rodgers the OC or let him call his own plays sure, otherwise he might not do so good here.

 

[DandyDon52]

No buddy, they are just human. And little things like bad routes, miscommunication, pressure, injury actually really happen.

well people also forget things that made them successful in the past.

 

[Ddisco22]

I know it's early but I'm bored.

Go Seahawks. We won't make the playoffs as a wild card so I don't care that they beat us.

If we do somehow make the playoffs, I don't want to see Aaron Rodgers in the first round. It doesn't matter that he has struggled at times this year. He owns Marinelli. I'm all for the Packers being eliminated as soon as possible.

Seems they are having the same struggles we have had on the road, only difference is no one is bashing their QB (who is also having a not-so-good season).

 

[Sydla]

Well Sydia, you missed my point
I will try to be more clear.
Both teams have losing records, so if it is Dak's fault for Dallas record, then it has to be Rodgers fault for GB's record.
They both are losers right now lol.
I am not saying Dak is better QB or the same as Rodgers.

However I would like to put Dak on GB team for 3-5 games, and Rodgers on Cowboys for same # of games, and see how each fares.
That would be interesting.
I think Dak could easily flourish in GB, but I dont know if Rodgers would do better here than he does in GB.
He would probably be arguing with coaches a lot here lol.

I got your point. It doesn't make sense.

Teams struggle for a variety of reasons - the QB isn't very good, the offense isn't very good, the OL stinks, the DL stinks, the defense can't stop anyone, etc.

There isn't a shred of doubt this Cowboys team would be better with Rodgers at QB. It's almost insane to suggest otherwise.

 

[Sydla]

Well if you make Rodgers the OC or let him call his own plays sure, otherwise he might not do so good here.

He'd be better than Dak.

 

[jsb357]

He will throw every coach and teammate under the bus before ever holding himself accountable.

Sounds like Dallas HC material right there.

 

[Verdict]

I will say it.

I think Joe Buck lusts after Rodgers.

No question.

No. Joe Buck is too busy loving himself to even have man love. What a complete tool bag.

 

[CowboyRoy]

well people also forget things that made them successful in the past.

Oh yah. Wilson has gotten worse over time right? He has regressed right? LOL

If anything, he is getting older and doesn't run as much. I think he has an issue with a knee which has kept him in the pocket more.

 

[DandyDon52]

I got your point. It doesn't make sense.

Teams struggle for a variety of reasons - the QB isn't very good, the offense isn't very good, the OL stinks, the DL stinks, the defense can't stop anyone, etc.

There isn't a shred of doubt this Cowboys team would be better with Rodgers at QB. It's almost insane to suggest otherwise.

Teams struggle for a variety of reasons - I agree
this Cowboys team would be better with Rodgers at QB.- sure but it is never gonna happen and my point is he might not be as good
as he has been in GB.

 

[CowboyRoy]

Teams struggle for a variety of reasons - I agree
this Cowboys team would be better with Rodgers at QB.- sure but it is never gonna happen and my point is he might not be as good
as he has been in GB.

LOL....you gotta love the fans that try to make the point that Rogers is better than Dak.

 

[DandyDon52]

Oh yah. Wilson has gotten worse over time right? He has regressed right? LOL

If anything, he is getting older and doesn't run as much. I think he has an issue with a knee which has kept him in the pocket more.

Wilson has gotten worse over time right? He has regressed right? .... I never said that.
he is getting older and doesn't run as much. I think he has an issue with a knee which has kept him in the pocket more........ he isnt that old lol
and rodgers is running with his bad knee.
The key is to run safe dont take any hits. Some of these QB go head first or standing up trying for a first down which is stupid,
and a td which might be ok in some situations but not most.

Wilson is good, but he has never been a great pocket passer. He liked to roll out to see better, and at one point in time
teams worked to keep him in the pocket.

That game last nite is good example of wilson doesnt give up, it looked like gb was going to steamroll them
but seattle gradually got back in and took lead, and won 4th and the game.

 

[CowboyRoy]

Wilson has gotten worse over time right? He has regressed right? .... I never said that.
he is getting older and doesn't run as much. I think he has an issue with a knee which has kept him in the pocket more........ he isnt that old lol
and rodgers is running with his bad knee.
The key is to run safe dont take any hits. Some of these QB go head first or standing up trying for a first down which is stupid,
and a td which might be ok in some situations but not most.

Wilson is good, but he has never been a great pocket passer. He liked to roll out to see better, and at one point in time
teams worked to keep him in the pocket.

That game last nite is good example of wilson doesnt give up, it looked like gb was going to steamroll them
but seattle gradually got back in and took lead, and won 4th and the game.

Wilson is a great QB and has been for years now. Call him whatever you want. The guy can ball.

 

[DandyDon52]

Seems they are having the same struggles we have had on the road, only difference is no one is bashing their QB (who is also having a not-so-good season).

lol not only that they still talk about how great he is !!
Dak is 1-4 on the road, Rodgers is 0-5
Parcells said you are what your record says you are,

 

[DandyDon52]

Wilson is a great QB and has been for years now. Call him whatever you want. The guy can ball.

yeah he can ball and he better cause he needs to win the rest of his games to have good shot at wc spot.
At 5-5 he has the same # of losses as Dak lol 5-5 suggests mediocre, not great. The great days may be in the past.
Cowboys need to win out too for a shot at WC, and depending on what wash does, They may need to win out to take div.

 

[CowboyRoy]

yeah he can ball and he better cause he needs to win the rest of his games to have good shot at wc spot.
At 5-5 he has the same # of losses as Dak lol 5-5 suggests mediocre, not great. The great days may be in the past.
Cowboys need to win out too for a shot at WC, and depending on what wash does, They may need to win out to take div.

So are you the type of poster that thinks win loss record is how you grade QB's? You probably thought Romo was garbage then right?

So at 13-3 Dak is a great QB, now at 4-5 he is average?

 

[CowboyRoy]

Well Sydia, you missed my point
I will try to be more clear.
Both teams have losing records, so if it is Dak's fault for Dallas record, then it has to be Rodgers fault for GB's record.
They both are losers right now lol.
I am not saying Dak is better QB or the same as Rodgers.

However I would like to put Dak on GB team for 3-5 games, and Rodgers on Cowboys for same # of games, and see how each fares.
That would be interesting.
I think Dak could easily flourish in GB, but I dont know if Rodgers would do better here than he does in GB.
He would probably be arguing with coaches a lot here lol.

You are wasting your time talking to that guy. All he does is run around the forum yelling "Dak sucks" and that's it. Talking sense to a guy that isn't interested in making any is a big waste of time.

 

[CowboyRoy]

yeah he can ball and he better cause he needs to win the rest of his games to have good shot at wc spot.
At 5-5 he has the same # of losses as Dak lol 5-5 suggests mediocre, not great. The great days may be in the past.
Cowboys need to win out too for a shot at WC, and depending on what wash does, They may need to win out to take div.

The Cowboys winning out is never going to happen.

 

[Sydla]

Teams struggle for a variety of reasons - I agree
this Cowboys team would be better with Rodgers at QB.- sure but it is never gonna happen and my point is he might not be as good
as he has been in GB.

He would just need to be better than Dak.

And he would be. By a lot.

 

[Sydla]

You are wasting your time talking to that guy. All he does is run around the forum yelling "Dak sucks" and that's it. Talking sense to a guy that isn't interested in making any is a big waste of time.

Yes because what makes sense here is saying things like Rodgers is overrated, Rodgers wouldn't be much better than Dak, the Cowboys wouldn't be better with a Rodgers at QB, etc.