Tony Romo & Tyron Smith on NFL TOP 100

[Bowdown27]

tony romo was 34
Tyron smith was 36
On NFL top 100 on NFL network

 

[jrumann59]

Why do I get the feeling there will be at least 5 players that are not in their league will be ranked above them.

 

[RS12]

How can Tyron Smith only be 36? Who would you rather have at LT than him? Not to mention he is a beast in the run game.

 

[dstovall5]

So I take it Luck, Brees, Wilson, Roethlisberger, Manning, Brady, and Rodgers are all ahead of Romo? If you're judging by last years play only, no one that watched Romo could logically put him behind all those guys. Sure, I'll give you Rodgers, and maybe Brady (completely disagree), but to put 4 other guys ahead of him as well is completely far fetched. Change his name to Peyton Manning / Tom Brady and keep the production the same last year and he wins MVP.

Nothing would be sweeter then to see Tony Romo and Jason Witten end their careers with a super bowl ring, especially with all the criticism the Cowboys(mainly Romo himself) have faced in the Romo era.

 

[sureletsrace]

What an absolute joke.

Guy who should've won MVP is 34th.

 

[Nova]

This year's list has been complete trash. Usually it's at least close, but a lot of thSe opinions are so outdated.

Pretty much guarantees that Frederick isn't on the list which is a joke.

Charles Woodson is on the list for crying out loud.

 

[dstovall5]

This year's list has been complete trash. Usually it's at least close, but a lot of thSe opinions are so outdated.

Pretty much guarantees that Frederick isn't on the list which is a joke.

Charles Woodson is on the list for crying out loud.

Not to mention Adrian Peterson made the list, I guess he must have been really good with that switch. I

 

[big dog cowboy]

Not just this year, not just last year, every year this list has been trash.

 

[AzorAhai]

Give the All-Pro voters the list to vote on. They usually do well with that. That way, it's a legitimate list. While the players are voting on this, it will be consistently bad.

 

[Rack]

Where was Dez on the list?

 

[unionjack8]

Where was Dez on the list?

dz not been on it yet

 

[DFWJC]

Where was Dez on the list?

He....and Murray too...will be higher.

 

[darthseinfeld]

How can Tyron Smith only be 36? Who would you rather have at LT than him? Not to mention he is a beast in the run game.

Joe Thomas IMO is his only real competition at LT

 

[Manwiththeplan]

Give the All-Pro voters the list to vote on. They usually do well with that. That way, it's a legitimate list. While the players are voting on this, it will be consistently bad.

Well that's the thing, the appeal of this show, of this list, is it is the only thing done 100% by the players. If the media did it, it would be just another list and fewer would watch it.

 

[DallasEast]

Not just this year, not just last year, every year this list has been trash.

 

[AzorAhai]

Well that's the thing, the appeal of this show, of this list, is it is the only thing done 100% by the players. If the media did it, it would be just another list and fewer would watch it.

If they were to market a top 100 by prominent voters for All-Pro, HoF voters, or even add in coaches it would still get just as high of ratings. Maybe higher since a large portion of people who watch NFLN during the offseason are passionate football fans who have some semblance of knowledge and recognize stupidity. They could market based on the highlights, keep the commentary from the players and whomever else which is probably the reason most tune in. Most lists are just lists that you read through and most likely from one writer or at most a small sample size. I seriously doubt the big draw is the players vote. People tune in to see where players from their team rank and could care less about who does the voting.

 

[Alexander]

While the players are voting on this, it will be consistently bad.

It is one reason I stopped watching it once it became clear how the voting worked, if it is even legitimate.

It was a joke the first year when Donovan McNabb made it and it has not changed.

Now it is just an idiotic show that a bad network puts on to generate outrage interest with casual fans.

Wait, my favorite player was ranked what? Argh argh, grrr, let me Tweet about it.

 

[rynochop]

Tony wasnt even on the list last year if you want to know how big a joke it is.
I thought some players came out last year saying they never voted on this list

 

[Jstopper]

Tony wasnt even on the list last year if you want to know how big a joke it is.
I thought some players came out last year saying they never voted on this list

Nah he was on the list last year, he was in the 70's. The year before that he was in the 90's. and the year before that he wasn't on the list at all. So yeah that list is some bs basically.

 

[DallasEast]

Player voting isn't the problem. The problem is the ballot format. Always has been. I could re-type the same thing each year but there isn't any reason to do so:

http://cowboyszone.com/threads/nfl-top-100-players-opinion-and-guess.290002/#post-5550612