Hostile;2807842 said:
Teams rarely used 8 man fronts to stop Barry. They tried to limit him to 1 or 2 big gains per game. Teams had to deal with Herman Moore and Brett Perriman and Johnny Morton. I saw a stat one time that said if you took away Barry's longest carry in each game of his career that he averaged 2.5 yards per carry on the rest of them. He also lost more yardage than any RB in History.
It is my own wacky opinion but I simply would not want Barry on my team no matter what. Give me a straight ahead runner every time. 2nd & long is a handicap. 3rd & long is even worse. You simply can't beat those odds hoping for your Defense to hold up in the hope that 1 or 2 times a game he is gone for a long score.
The author of the piece eludes me at this time as does the source, but somebody on either BSPN or NFL.com did an article about Barry detailing exactly what you mentioned in bold. I expect you read the same.
Come to think of it, it might have been Simmons in response to Easterbrook. Gregg always harps on going for it on short yardage situations based on the mean gain of a rushing play in the NFL while someone else pointed out that the median gain of a play is what you should weigh your play selection and strategy on.
Same thing applies to Barry as you mentioned. His stat sheet at the end of a game might look like 1, -2, 2, 0, -5, 1, 3, -1, 0, 56, 2, -1, 3, 4. When you add it all up, it looks like a good average per carry but you have to look at the effects of those short runs on the overall game.
As you mentioned, Barry left his team in many difficult to convert 3rd and longs resulting in punts. That puts even more pressure on your defense along with relegating your offense to sputter along without any resemblance of rhythm or continuity.
However, the viewing public loves those big gains for TD's and the occasional short yardage TD that gave Barry a great box score and two clips of dynamic highlights on Sports Center. However, when you look at it from a coaching and strategy perspective, Barry Sanders gives you a multitude of headaches on your team and in my mind draws similar unflattering comparisons to Vick the running back trying to get by at playing quarterback.