We will face the Packers Not Giants

Blackspider214

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,129
Reaction score
15,994
We all know that the Giants have a great defense and a weak offense, and the Packers are pretty much the opposite.

So I took a moment to ask how the Packers have performed against superior defenses. In their 6 week hot streak they've done this:
-Scored 21 on Houston (#1 defense)
-Scored 38 on Seattle (#3)
-Scored 38 on Vikings (#5)

Then I ask...can the Giants score big on mediocre defenses? Answer: They don't seem to score big on anyone aside from Cleveland. Working backwards down the schedule:
19, 19, 17, 10, 14, 22, 21...

Unless Manning totally changes form or they suddenly get a running game...I can't see New York scoring more than 17...maybe 21. And the Packers should have enough to cover that.

Also this: Lambeau field

There is no more mystique of Lambeau Field in the playoffs. Starting when Vick went in there and dominated Favre. Eli has went into GB and won twice when GB was a much better team than this. Kap won there, too.
 

BoysWin

Well-Known Member
Messages
496
Reaction score
420
We all know that the Giants have a great defense and a weak offense, and the Packers are pretty much the opposite.

So I took a moment to ask how the Packers have performed against superior defenses. In their 6 week hot streak they've done this:
-Scored 21 on Houston (#1 defense)
-Scored 38 on Seattle (#3)
-Scored 38 on Vikings (#5)

Then I ask...can the Giants score big on mediocre defenses? Answer: They don't seem to score big on anyone aside from Cleveland. Working backwards down the schedule:
19, 19, 17, 10, 14, 22, 21...

Unless Manning totally changes form or they suddenly get a running game...I can't see New York scoring more than 17...maybe 21. And the Packers should have enough to cover that.

Also this: Lambeau field

And you have FORGOT - the UPSET WIN DET over SEATTLE. Then we play DET and GB travels to ATL.
 

Risen Star

Likes Collector
Messages
89,421
Reaction score
212,337
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Yeah, I agree. Packers.

Not good.

Meanwhile the Patriots will probably play the Texans. Nice.
 

kramskoi

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,387
Reaction score
1,765
We all know that the Giants have a great defense and a weak offense, and the Packers are pretty much the opposite.

So I took a moment to ask how the Packers have performed against superior defenses. In their 6 week hot streak they've done this:
-Scored 21 on Houston (#1 defense)
-Scored 38 on Seattle (#3)
-Scored 38 on Vikings (#5)

Then I ask...can the Giants score big on mediocre defenses? Answer: They don't seem to score big on anyone aside from Cleveland. Working backwards down the schedule:
19, 19, 17, 10, 14, 22, 21...

Unless Manning totally changes form or they suddenly get a running game...I can't see New York scoring more than 17...maybe 21. And the Packers should have enough to cover that.

Also this: Lambeau field
Fact of the matter...the Giants offense is just not of the caliber of 2007, let alone 2011, which was Manning's career year. They run the ball worse than any of the NFC playoff teams...except maybe Detroit. There was some glimmer of hope against Washington (Perkins), and the Packers secondary is teetering on oblivion, so I don't feel totally comfortable saying that they have no chance. Quite the contrary, I think they are the team most likely to score an upset this weekend. That said, they could not breach 20 points against Washington with 3 turnovers and it doesn't bode well for trying to take down a resurgent Rodgers in chilly Lambeau...15 degrees forecast for Jan. 8 at game time.
 

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,783
Reaction score
16,658
The giants defense will have to stifle rodgers, and keep score low for giants to win.
Giants have a good secondary , and they have to play good to stop rodgers.
Should be a good game.
 

Bullflop

Cowboys Diehard
Messages
25,719
Reaction score
30,912
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Rodgers is as hot as a pistol right now and highly capable of beating anyone when that's the case. Eli, on the other hand, is about as likely now to beat his own team as he is the opponent. Not good. I think that will decide the winner and the loser in Green Bay.
 
Last edited:

THEHEREAFTER

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,862
Reaction score
6,301
I'm sure it's been pointed out that the 19 @ wash was a defensive TD on a failed desperation lateral play by wash. Essentially they scored 13
 

Thetriplets22

Active Member
Messages
276
Reaction score
183
Packers have the worst secondary in the NFL; Stanford had guys wide open like that one pass on the boundary that he missed Tate for 6. Did you forget about playoff Eli? 7 straight wins in the postseason. Don't jinx us and pray we face GB
 

_sturt_

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,398
Reaction score
4,304
Green Bay should be strong in red zone. Montgomery has been a revelation for them. They can hit the Giants with their fullback. Rogers can sting with his arm or his feet and has strong receiving core.

The loss of Thomas took the 'hawk defense from five pro bowlers to four. Putting 38 on them was extremely impressive, no matter how you parse it.

21 points isn't impressive against the #1 league defense (houston)? Careful.

Dak and our offense faced top 5 defenses 3 times this year with point totals of 19, 17, 7. Had we scored 21 we would have beat the Giants in both of those losses.

All well taken. You may be right.

Or, I may be right.

We'll see soon enough. And if you're right, you can be sure I'll give you your due.
 

JohnsKey19

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,693
Reaction score
18,715
It's a great match-up. If good Eli shows up, NYG wins by 10+ going away. If normal Eli shows up, it's a dogfight to the end.
 

Cowboy89

Well-Known Member
Messages
412
Reaction score
415
I think it'll be the Giants. Packers don't match up well with them.
 

d_dub88

Well-Known Member
Messages
756
Reaction score
648
No way. Football is meant to be outdoors. I'm fine with a few domes here and there, but for the most part, keep them outside. The fact that New Orleans has a dome is asinine. Same with us, but I can't hate too much.
Exactly. If I owned or coached a team that played in the NFC North there is no way I build a domed stadium. There is such a home field advantage there in December and throughout the playoffs. No one wants to go to Chicago or Green Bay when it's cold. Detroit is Detroit but Minnesota was having playoff success before they put their team in a dome.
 
Top