ABQ, I completely disagree with your assesment of Irons, especially camparisons to J.J.
He is the anti-J.J. IMO.
My biggest concern with J.J. is that he doesn't display that elusiveness, wiggle, slipperyness or vision that great backs have. He rarely makes the first guy miss or squirts through the pile.
Kenny Irons is one of my absolute favorite players in this draft, in in fact I have stated many times that he is my first choice for us, I liken him to a Portis, both guys when you watched them in college, always seemed to be running through & around defenders, ultru productve.
For some reason both guys were kind of afterthoughts, or discounted as first round players, largely due to size/durabilty issues as well as not having any individual eye popping measurable.
Like Portis, when I watch Irons I see a baller, a big time runner who always seems to be squirting through defenses. Irons best traights IMO are J.J.'s weakneses.
Irons has rare vision, great elusiveness and that uncanny nack for making the first defender miss. He runs hard like Barber on every play. He always seems to get stronger by the carry, he is the kind of back you can give the ball to eight times in a row.
Irons is also a great athlete, he has very good quickness and top end speed. I think he very well could be every bit as good as Ronny Brown or Caddilac, if he stays healthy.
Like Portis, I think the reason he slips to the second, and possibly the third are durabilty and concerns over his ability to be an every down back. Like Portis I think he will prove to be a steal, and I would love to have him. He would be an Ideal guy to pair with Barber IMO.
I think we should draft him regardless of if we trade J.J. or not, I think he is a better back than J.J., if J.J. busts out this year, then we have a plethora of wealth at RB and could trade one. If J.J. continues to underachieve, then we have a guy ready to take over.
I think he will be one of the best values in this draft, I like him as much as any back other than Peterson, and we could get him with a second or third.