Who are the top players at each position?

[jwitten82]

QB-Peyton Manning, Tom Brady
RB-Tomlinson, LJ
FB-Neal
WR-TO, Moss, S.Smith, C.Johnson
TE-Gates, Witten, Gonzales
DT or NT- Sapp, Williams, and Harris
DE- Freeney, Peppers
ILB/MLB- Vilma, Lewis, Urlacher,Lofa Tatupu, Nick Barnett, OLB- Ware, Merriman
CB- Bailey, Mathis, Asante Samuel
FS- Dawkins, Reed, SS- Williams, Troy Polamalu,
K- Vinetari P- Moorman, McBriar

 

[Q_the_man]

no disrespect but i think sanders and taylor are better than roy

 

[ajk23az]

QB-Peyton Manning, Tom Brady
RB-Tomlinson, LJ
FB-Neal
WR-TO, Moss, S.Smith, C.Johnson
TE-Gates, Witten, Gonzales
DT or NT- Sapp, Williams, and Harris
DE- Freeney, Peppers
ILB/MLB- Vilma, Lewis, Urlacher,Lofa Tatupu, Nick Barnett, OLB- Ware, Merriman
CB- Bailey, Mathis, Asante Samuel
FS- Dawkins, Reed, SS- Williams, Troy Polamalu,
K- Vinetari P- Moorman, McBriar

You forgot Kellen Winslow...Moss is better than TO right now....Chad Johnson isnt as dominant as he used to be....Other than those, pretty good imo

 

[jwitten82]

Arent those two both FS

no disrespect but i think sanders and taylor are better than roy

​

 

[BehindEnemyLinez]

I think there are a few other DEs that may be better than Freeney (he seems too one dimensional IMO). Kampman (GB), Jason Taylor (MIA), Strahan (NYG) all play the run better and put up better sack totals.

 

[Clarkson]

Jared Allen.

 

[AbeBeta]

Roy has no business on that list

 

[NoLuv4Jerry]

QB-Peyton Manning, Tom Brady
RB-Tomlinson, LJ
FB-Neal
WR-TO, Moss, S.Smith, C.Johnson
TE-Gates, Witten, Gonzales
DT or NT- Sapp, Williams, and Harris
DE- Freeney, Peppers
ILB/MLB- Vilma, Lewis, Urlacher,Lofa Tatupu, Nick Barnett, OLB- Ware, Merriman
CB- Bailey, Mathis, Asante Samuel
FS- Dawkins, Reed, SS- Williams, Troy Polamalu,
K- Vinetari P- Moorman, McBriar

Sean Taylor is the best FS in the NFL....the NT in NE is better than Sapp...C Johnson is not a winner...but a good list otherwise

 

[utrunner07]

QB-Peyton Manning, Tom Brady
RB-Tomlinson, LJ
FB-Neal
WR-TO, Moss, S.Smith, C.Johnson
TE-Gates, Witten, Gonzales
DT or NT- Sapp, Williams, and Harris
DE- Freeney, Peppers
ILB/MLB- Vilma, Lewis, Urlacher,Lofa Tatupu, Nick Barnett, OLB- Ware, Merriman
CB- Bailey, Mathis, Asante Samuel
FS- Dawkins, Reed, SS- Williams, Troy Polamalu,
K- Vinetari P- Moorman, McBriar

Not too sure about the running backs...Tomlinson, yeah, LJ nah...there are others just as good as him, imo

 

[jwitten82]

Well name some other SS that should be on there

Roy has no business on that list

​

 

[Ren]

Sean Taylor is the best FS in the NFL....the NT in NE is better than Sapp...C Johnson is not a winner...but a good list otherwise

can't remember his name but Pittsburgs NT is probably the best NT in the league

 

[jwitten82]

Taylor is good but not better than Reed or Dawkins

Sean Taylor is the best FS in the NFL....the NT in NE is better than Sapp...C Johnson is not a winner...but a good list otherwise

​

 

[Rampage]

can't remember his name but Pittsburgs NT is probably the best NT in the league

casey hampton

 

[NoLuv4Jerry]

Taylor is good but not better than Reed or Dawkins

we will agree to disagree...but for my money..there is not another DB in the NFL with Taylor's combination of size, speed and power...and he has more range than any Safety in the NFL

 

[dallasfaniac]

we will agree to disagree...but for my money..there is not another DB in the NFL with Taylor's combination of size, speed and power...and he has more range than any Safety in the NFL

I would argue that the man in the same defensive backfield would give him a run for the money, he's just handles SS responsibilites right now.