Who hits the hardest? Sean Taylor or Roy Williams

[redskins1]

sean taylor or roy williams who hits the hardest..its close,but i have to lean towards sean taylor...reason being roy grabs from behind alot and he gets big hits on people who are not ready to protect themselves,sean has more head to head were the other guy is squared up and sean goes head to head and knocks the runner backwards,i think sean comes with more force..how do you see it?

 

[superpunk]

Taylor hits like a girl.

Roy rules all things.

Have a nice day.

 

[AdamJT13]

The first time I see Sean Taylor hit anyone as hard as I've seen Roy hit people numerous times, I'll let you know.

I'm sure you'll be waiting a long time.

 

[Bizwah]

Ask Shaun Alexander or Laveraneous Coles who hits harder.

 

[Ken]

honestly,
Roy hits twice as hard as Taylor.

And much more often.

 

[BigDFan5]

The first time I see Sean Taylor hit anyone as hard as I've seen Roy hit people numerous times, I'll let you know.

I'm sure you'll be waiting a long time.

Taylor tried to hit someone as hard as Roy hits once, He knocked himself out, remember?

 

[wxcpo]

Why the hell would a Skins fan come to a Cowboys board and ask such a dumb question. Even IF the answer was Taylor not like anyone here would say so, but in all reality it isn't even close. Taylor tries to hit people as hard as Roy does, but he can't even carry Roy's jock.

 

[Arch Stanton]

Greg Jones.

 

[firehawk350]

Why the hell would a Skins fan come to a Cowboys board and ask such a dumb question. Even IF the answer was Taylor not like anyone here would say so, but in all reality it isn't even close. Taylor tries to hit people as hard as Roy does, but he can't even carry Roy's jock.

Haha, i agree with the first part of this post, but you kinda sounded condicatory.. You just said that any response in a cowboys forum would be invalid because your asking on a cowboys forum, but you decided to go ahead and say what every cowboys fan has already said. It's like saying, "this statement is a lie".

 

[theebs]

THis is because as I have come to believe all Commanders fans on the internet are 12 years old, or act like it. Its like that board they have, its ridiculous I never go there, but the 4 or 5 times I have in three years all the topics are like "best wr in the nfc east" best rb in the nfc east etc.....then they get 500 replies like, man brunell is so much better than mcnabb because mcnabb runs too much and eats chunky soup......

These threads are a waste of time like that board. These topics have to be thought of by a 12 year old.

 

[redskins1]

why does everything has to be based on what team you like,can folks give a opinion based on how they honestly feel,leaving your bias out of it...i can..

 

[t.o.boys81]

why does everything has to be based on what team you like,can folks give a opinion based on how they honestly feel,leaving your bias out of it...i can..

Don't worry, we're not being biased by saying Roy hits harder than Taylor. We're just telling the truth. There's nothing to it.

 

[firehawk350]

Ask Shaun Alexander or Laveraneous Coles who hits harder.

Or we can ask Terry Glenn or Randy Moss. Hell, ask TO. Yes, Roy Williams broke his leg, but that wasn't because it was a monster hit. It was because it was a horse-collar tackle. In all fairness, it wasn't illegal at the time, but the point being it wasn't a hard tackle. Just ackward. You can ask the Cards RB too, he ducked (on 4th and 2 with the game on the line no less) avoid a Taylor hit as opposed to fight for the yards and the game.
Or let's turn it around, and ask Santana Moss. Has Roy ever been close enough to hit Santana?

 

[big dog cowboy]

I've seen MANY running backs that hit harder than Taylor. Stupid thread.

 

[FLcowboy]

sean taylor or roy williams who hits the hardest..its close,but i have to lean towards sean taylor...reason being roy grabs from behind alot and he gets big hits on people who are not ready to protect themselves,sean has more head to head were the other guy is squared up and sean goes head to head and knocks the runner backwards,i think sean comes with more force..how do you see it?

Your analysis of Roy pulling down from behind is because he was forced to play more coverage support, as opposed to run support. I think this year you won't see Roy playing so deep, and he will be knocking the bejeebers out of running backs, or WRs coming out of the slot with the ball in their hands.

Let's answer this question after this season. If you still want to ponder a question now, will Sean's off-season behavior impact his on-field play, or is all that behind him now with the plea bargain.

 

[firehawk350]

THis is because as I have come to believe all Commanders fans on the internet are 12 years old, or act like it. Its like that board they have, its ridiculous I never go there, but the 4 or 5 times I have in three years all the topics are like "best wr in the nfc east" best rb in the nfc east etc.....then they get 500 replies like, man brunell is so much better than mcnabb because mcnabb runs too much and eats chunky soup......

These threads are a waste of time like that board. These topics have to be thought of by a 12 year old.

And you yourself sound so informed to group every Skins fan into one group. Of course there are the blind homers, you'll get them anytime you go to an opposing fans board. There are plenty of them here. How many times have you heard a case trying to be made, saying that Bledsoe is better then Rothlesberger? Or Julius Jones is an elite RB? Or the Dallas O-line is be dominating this year? I've even heard that somebody thinks that Watkins or Davis = Sean Taylor. One of those things man, you just gotta ignore them and have an intelligent conversation with the better posters.

 

[DBoys]

:dissskin:


I got 3 hits for you

Shaun Alexander
Lav Coles
SF return guy

All you have is a no pro bowl gun carrying spitter.

 

[firehawk350]

Your analysis of Roy pulling down from behind is because he was forced to play more coverage support, as opposed to run support. I think this year you won't see Roy playing so deep, and he will be knocking the bejeebers out of running backs, or WRs coming out of the slot with the ball in their hands.

Let's answer this question after this season. If you still want to ponder a question now, will Sean's off-season behavior impact his on-field play, or is all that behind him now with the plea bargain.

Then again, you don't see Sean Taylor pulling down from behind even though he's forced into coverage. Laying a big hit has a lot to do with position, and if Taylor is in better position more often, then you could say that Taylor IS the better hitter.

Good second question though, and my outlook on this is he had it hanging over his head all last season, right? If anything, an unresolved court case would affect his play more then a resolved one, so if anything, we should see an improvement on the mental aspect. If it did affect him, we will probably see a better Taylor. But I don't think it did so we should see the normal progression of a second into third year player.

 

[RW31]

Sean Taylor

 

[DGreenFan87]

so obviously my opinion doesn't matter here. yea you guessed it, i think sean taylor hits harder. let the roasting begin.

And you yourself sound so informed to group every Skins fan into one group. Of course there are the blind homers, you'll get them anytime you go to an opposing fans board. There are plenty of them here. How many times have you heard a case trying to be made, saying that Bledsoe is better then Rothlesberger? Or Julius Jones is an elite RB? Or the Dallas O-line is be dominating this year? I've even heard that somebody thinks that Watkins or Davis = Sean Taylor. One of those things man, you just gotta ignore them and have an intelligent conversation with the better posters.

very good point. case in point, every team defends their players. saying that everyone on ES are 12 year olds is immature and stupid because there are people who intelligently back up their opinions and don't always go the homer route. i can honestly say there are intelligent people on this board who aren't homers, but i can also say that i've seen a lot of people just blindly praise your team for no reason. it's how the game is played. both our boards are infested with immature people. deal with it.