I still wouldn't take Cutler over Romo for any reason. Not a single one. Right now there is exactly one QB who I'd take, for sure, over Romo and that's Phillip Rivers.
That's not because I don't think Tony is darn good, and will be great, but it's because I just am a huge fan of Phillip Rivers. That and Rivers has won a few playoff games with a team with less talent on the offensive side of the ball than Dallas.
That said I'm not one of those people who blames those playoff losses entirely on Tony either cause I learned long ago, by virtue of actually having played football, that there is no such thing as a single player who wins or loses ball games. It's a team effort in both cases.