Would you trade Marion Barber for a 1st?

[CF74]

Wow. A lot more people are down on Barber than I would have guessed.

Even his own son.

 

[Established1971]

I think I would.

RB's are generally easy to find, we could get another Barber/Choice in 4th-5th round. Also Im much more worried about the OL and secondary than RB. I really wouldnt be worried about Choice and Felix starting. If healthy, they will be more than enough to win, wed need another vet/draft pick as insurance, but that wouldnt be as hard to find as a tackle, or safety.

Unless theres a huge cap hit that hurts for multiple years.

Barring that, Id trade him for the Cardinals pick(31st). Nice spot for a LT(Beatty), S(Sean Smith) or another pass rusher(Barwin, Sintim)

in a heartbeat

 

[TellerMorrow34]

Maybe for a top 10 pick PRIOR to the deal he signed last year. At this point there is no way I'd trade him and eat the cap hit for anything less than 2 first round draft choices.

 

[28 Joker]

I wouldn't trade Marion Barber. He demoralizes the other team, and he's stud.

His game agaisnst Tampa Bay last year, was one of his best. He only had about 73 yards, but he did it against 8 and 9 man fronts and little help.

 

[bluenut]

That would be a solid No from me. Like many have said before, the running situation is a good one with all 3 at our disposal. Barber will be the anchor down the stretch.