Yakuza Rich: Analysis of Newman's Plantar Fasciitis

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
Analysis of Newman's Plantar Fasciitis
by Yakuza Rich
http://yakuzarich.blogspot.com/


duncan_feet_060313_350.jpg


Several Dallas Media outlets are reporting that Terence Newman has plantar fasciitis. Sounds bad and even San Antonio Express writer Tom Orsborne got it confused with the injury 4th round rookie Isaiah Stanback suffered his senior season at Washington, Lisc Franc foot injury. Here's some excerpts I got from the Web on plantar fasciitis at http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/02/27/AR2006022701024.html


The injury involves the plantar fascia, a fibrous band of tissue that runs
along the bottom of the foot between the heel bone and the base of the toes.

Usually this fascia acts as a shock absorber for each footfall. But when it gets
stretched, torn or inflamed -- which often happens to folks who are starting a
new exercise regimen -- you've got the dreaded PF.

Severity ranges from mild (occasional throb when stepping) to extreme
(nail-through-the-heel pain with any move). Risk rises with amount of impact:
Activities involving walking, running and jumping carry higher risk than
swimming, biking or rowing. Overweight people get more PF than others.


I think this gives a pretty good idea of what's going on here, but be reminded that this diagnosis is for the average joe instead of the professional athlete. By that I mean that the average joe is less likely to re-injure himself because he's not as active or doing something where he increases the likelihood of being injured than your pro athlete. On the other hand, the average joe isn't likely to properly heal the injury nearly as quickly since he doesn't have the time, resources or the medical care the average pro athlete will have.

The good news is that this is an injury that has a wide range of pain, treatment and recovery time. It *appears* that Newman caught this injury rather early, so he can rest and recover in time. From doing research, there have been athletes who have played with this condition such as San Antonio Spurs forward Tim Duncan and Toronto Blue Jays third basemen Troy Glaus.

Here's a look at Duncan's numbers before and after having plantar fasciitis (2005-2006 he had it):

Year...............pts/game..................reb/game...........blocks/game

03-04...............22.3........................12.5....................2.7

04-05................20.3.......................11.1.....................2.6

05-06*.............18.6..........................11.0.....................2.0

06-07.................20.0.......................11.6....................2.4


Glaus, who is currently suffering the injuries, has put up the following numbers the past few years (numbers are prorated to 162 games since Glaus hasn't played a full season the past three years):


Year.......batting average...........slugging %...............HR's

2005.......258..........................522.........................40

2006.......252..........................513..........................40

2007*.....249...........................442.........................26



CONCLUSION

If anything, it appears that plantar fasciitis is something that an athlete can play with. Tim Duncan and Troy Glaus have played with it and saw their production tail off. Duncan's production tailed off only slightly to where it was barely noticeable, but Glaus' production is more pronounced, especially when it comes to hitting for power.

That being said, it appears that Newman was diagnosed with the injury almost immediately whereas Duncan was originally misdiagnosed and then the Spurs quickly changed it to the correct diagnosis. Glaus was misdiagnosed for a longer time and it has showed in his dropoff in production. Although as Glaus notes ''That was purely a (bad) swing,'' he said. ''It was a slow bat, no luck, bad swing all the way around.''

Also remember that while football is more likely to cause injuries, Duncan and Glaus where on the court or field of play nearly every day of the week in their professions whereas Newman plays once a week. Surely the team will want him to practice between games, but they can give him a lot more rest in that time should he need it. I'd say that Newman is likely to fall more into the Tim Duncan category of seeing his play dip a little, but still be a very good player than to see a definitive dropoff in effectiveness that Glaus suffered. The team will also probably just change his shoes and give him some orthotics to help ease the pain as well. For more info on the injury and how the Spurs handled it, check out this link below:

http://www.nba.com/spurs/doc/prognosis_060313.html




YAKUZA
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,107
Reaction score
11,452
Mickey said yesterday on a Ranch Report or one of those other DC.com podcasts that Newman was still out doing some drills at practice; he just wasn't practicing with the team. So maybe his isn't too serious a case yet.

Unless it's a very mild case, I bet he has to put up with it all year, though. But maybe they can manage it so that it doesn't bother him too much.
 

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
Great breakdown Yak... as always..


I dont think that less than one basket and a half a block could be considered anything that was from the injury.

If it was gradual from the 03-04 season to the 05-06 season then I say yes.... a difference of almost 2 baskets.... even still I dunno


As far as a baseball player? If they can numb it so you do feel it then how could it affect your power numbers? If lower body and upper body and positioning of the feet, no? I dont know that we draw power from having our feet planted? just guessin though...
 

Paniolo22

Hawaiian Cowboy
Messages
3,936
Reaction score
355
As someone that still has PF, you can definitey play with the injury, and during game time, you can't even tell you have it. The problem is recovery time. In the morning, getting out of bed hurts like hell and feels like someone is stretching the bottom of your feet with every step. It gets tolerable throughout the day, and if you rest, it goes away. Shoe in soles can help but rest is the ony thing that really helps.
 

playmakers

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,238
Reaction score
154
If hes doing drills then its not that serious. The main remedy for this injury is rest and if hes not resting it now then that just tells me its precautionary.
 

speedkilz88

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,950
Reaction score
23,098
As a rookie Crayton had it in minicamps, he rested before training camp and I don't think he had any problems. As long as its a mild case(which it appears), Newman should be okay.
 

newlander

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,205
Reaction score
123
Very good posts guys. Geez it's nice to have some cooler heads prevail here. P.Fasciitis has been around forever, and isn't that serious UNLESS as the above post accurately states: it goes untreated or mistreated. I live in Michigan and Joe Dumars played for years with it and successfully led D-town to a couple championships. You can't tell me that playing CB in the NFL 16 games per year is more physically challenging than being an NBA guard for 82 games per year: no way man. I truly think TNew will be fine with rest and therapy. HOWEVER, I think we needed a veteran corner before this happened. Someone like Aaron Glenn who is solid, if not spectacular. Probably too late to get anyone now, but you never know...............
 

blindzebra

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,560
Reaction score
4,451
Since I ref basketball and know many officials I know dozens of people who have had it.

The worst pain is in the morning...it hurts the least when you are warmed up and moving around...it acts up again after you have been on it too long.

When it is caught early...and all indications and reports tell us that is the case...most people respond well to treatment.

That treatment usually is:

Rest from the activity that caused it...the rest time is normally 2-3 weeks

Stretches that relieve the inflammation and increase flexibility...the towel pull is very common

A special boot that you wear at night that pulls your toes toward your shin...anyone who has every had a cramp in their calf knows what that feels like

Orthotics...custom inserts for your shoes that force the normal high arch that keeps the ligament tight and in the proper position

Most people I know have had very few problems after doing that treatment.

The ones who wait too long to get treatment are the ones who suffer longer and may need surgery to correct the problem.
 

Ashwynn

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,777
Reaction score
500
Yakuza Rich;1604044 said:
Analysis of Newman's Plantar Fasciitis
by Yakuza Rich
http://yakuzarich.blogspot.com/


duncan_feet_060313_350.jpg


Several Dallas Media outlets are reporting that Terence Newman has plantar fasciitis. Sounds bad and even San Antonio Express writer Tom Orsborne got it confused with the injury 4th round rookie Isaiah Stanback suffered his senior season at Washington, Lisc Franc foot injury. Here's some excerpts I got from the Web on plantar fasciitis at http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/02/27/AR2006022701024.html





I think this gives a pretty good idea of what's going on here, but be reminded that this diagnosis is for the average joe instead of the professional athlete. By that I mean that the average joe is less likely to re-injure himself because he's not as active or doing something where he increases the likelihood of being injured than your pro athlete. On the other hand, the average joe isn't likely to properly heal the injury nearly as quickly since he doesn't have the time, resources or the medical care the average pro athlete will have.

The good news is that this is an injury that has a wide range of pain, treatment and recovery time. It *appears* that Newman caught this injury rather early, so he can rest and recover in time. From doing research, there have been athletes who have played with this condition such as San Antonio Spurs forward Tim Duncan and Toronto Blue Jays third basemen Troy Glaus.

Here's a look at Duncan's numbers before and after having plantar fasciitis (2005-2006 he had it):

Year...............pts/game..................reb/game...........blocks/game

03-04...............22.3........................12.5....................2.7

04-05................20.3.......................11.1.....................2.6

05-06*.............18.6..........................11.0.....................2.0

06-07.................20.0.......................11.6....................2.4


Glaus, who is currently suffering the injuries, has put up the following numbers the past few years (numbers are prorated to 162 games since Glaus hasn't played a full season the past three years):


Year.......batting average...........slugging %...............HR's

2005.......258..........................522.........................40

2006.......252..........................513..........................40

2007*.....249...........................442.........................26



CONCLUSION

If anything, it appears that plantar fasciitis is something that an athlete can play with. Tim Duncan and Troy Glaus have played with it and saw their production tail off. Duncan's production tailed off only slightly to where it was barely noticeable, but Glaus' production is more pronounced, especially when it comes to hitting for power.

That being said, it appears that Newman was diagnosed with the injury almost immediately whereas Duncan was originally misdiagnosed and then the Spurs quickly changed it to the correct diagnosis. Glaus was misdiagnosed for a longer time and it has showed in his dropoff in production. Although as Glaus notes ''That was purely a (bad) swing,'' he said. ''It was a slow bat, no luck, bad swing all the way around.''

Also remember that while football is more likely to cause injuries, Duncan and Glaus where on the court or field of play nearly every day of the week in their professions whereas Newman plays once a week. Surely the team will want him to practice between games, but they can give him a lot more rest in that time should he need it. I'd say that Newman is likely to fall more into the Tim Duncan category of seeing his play dip a little, but still be a very good player than to see a definitive dropoff in effectiveness that Glaus suffered. The team will also probably just change his shoes and give him some orthotics to help ease the pain as well. For more info on the injury and how the Spurs handled it, check out this link below:

http://www.nba.com/spurs/doc/prognosis_060313.html




YAKUZA

As a Spurs fan, I can tell you it lingered with Timmy and was crappy. He was a shell of the player he normally is and was severely limited by it. It frustrated him and while he played and put up decent numbers, he was not close to being explosive, dominant or the force he normally is in any game. Its not a career ending injury, but its a production sapping injury. It lingers and really takes a while to fully recover from. This year Timmy was healthy and it showed in his production and we won a title.
 

FuzzyLumpkins

The Boognish
Messages
36,571
Reaction score
27,856
It most negatively effected Duncan in terms of his defnse where has required to move his feet quickly in order to maintain position and he couldnt orchestrate what movements were to happen beforehand.
 

StanleySpadowski

Active Member
Messages
4,815
Reaction score
0
Comparing Newman's injury to that of an NBA or MLB player is like comparing apples and nuclear submarines. You could have compared him to mailmen and orthodontists.


Looking at past NFL injury lists, there are dozens of players listed as "probable" or sometimes even "questionable" every year with "heel" as the listed problem. That's usually platar flasciitis. It'd estimate that there are dozens upon dozens of mild cases that don't ever even make it to the injury list.

The player to miss the most time with it was Bobby Taylor a few years ago in Philly who missed half a season but there were conflicting reports as to whether he had plantar flasciitis or had a full plantar tear.
 

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
YoMick;1604058 said:
As far as a baseball player? If they can numb it so you do feel it then how could it affect your power numbers? If lower body and upper body and positioning of the feet, no? I dont know that we draw power from having our feet planted? just guessin though...

Depends what foot. The tough thing I would imagine is playing defense, especially for Glaus who plays on turf in the Sky Dome.




YAKUZA
 

JerryFan

Active Member
Messages
1,243
Reaction score
7
Albert Puols has had it the previous two years, but I'm not sure about this year. He's done ok with that I think.
 
Top