Your least favorite commentators from 09?

Staggerlee

chip_gilkey
Messages
2,671
Reaction score
257
Thought it would be fun to list our least favorite commentators from last season. My least favorite from last year was Dick Stockton and Charles Davis for the seattle game. Dick kept messing up players names when announcing who made the play and Charles just got on my nerves all game with his annoying *** commentary.
 
Joe Buck, holy moly he's awful. Not just in Cowboys games either.
 
I can't even remember to say who sucked the most.

I do like Gruden though.
 
Those two non-football guys on Monday night football...
 
The two that I absolutely abhor are Troy Aikman and Joe Buck. I have nothing against Troy Aikman until he opens his mouth. Joe Buck is just an annoying dweeb.
 
Gruden was Great; the best MNF has had since Madden and Michaels.

Jaws is annoying as hell with his delivery but he is pretty good with the analysis.

Joe Buck sucks...nuff said.

I like Troy but he tries too hard not to be a homer and it backfires on him.

I like Moose's crew the best but could do without Goose and his flatulent drivel.
 
Buck/Aikman... Even with my tv turned all the way down I can still hear them. They are friggin loud and annoying.

I like to be my own commentator! :)
 
Yeah, Buck thinks he's a journalist out there while calling a game. Just shut up and call the game and let the papers worry about ripping players. Aikman wouldnt be bad if he didnt care what people thought of him. I know hes been called a homer etc and since then he has went down the tubes.

What happen to the days of "this is Pat Summerall along with John Madden" and you got the feel of, lack of a better analogy, comfort. With Buck and Aikman you always get the feeling of how long will it take before the first shot is given. You might as well throw Skip Bayless in the booth as well.

Jon Gruden is old school and is a breath of fresh air. I cant stand Mike Tirco. Every time he calls a big play he sounds like a spoiled kid who is excited because they got a brand new toy. Jaws wants to be an encyclopedia out there. I watched 250 hrs of game tape in the last 2 weeks on how the Cowboys run there draw play. Jaws just shut up.

MNF would be awful without Gruden. I'd say keep Gruden and get rid of Tirco and replace him with Mike Emerick hockey's Pat Summerall. For the 3rd guy you need another person like Gruden who has played the game and is also charismatic. Why not the Rock Dwayne Johnson. He played for the U and is awesome with the mic. I know its radical but its something.
 
I am not a fan of joe buck personally, I think he is a baseball guy and he isnt natural with football.

Having said that his replacement for the atlanta game, Thom Brenneman another baseball guy...dear lord. He was really noticeably poor.

I could live without jim nantz too.
 
chip_gilkey;3437176 said:
Thought it would be fun to list our least favorite commentators from last season. My least favorite from last year was Dick Stockton and Charles Davis for the seattle game. Dick kept messing up players names when announcing who made the play and Charles just got on my nerves all game with his annoying *** commentary.

Chris Collinsworth, his voice has made me turn off the volume and just listen to music watching SNF games.
 
Romo 2 Austin;3437367 said:
Chris Collinsworth, his voice has made me turn off the volume and just listen to music watching SNF games.

I agree with you, its strange i feel dirty now. But collinsworth's voice irks me like no other. I think madden 10 is what did it to me, i have to mute that game when i play now.
 
playmakers;3437337 said:
Yeah, Buck thinks he's a journalist out there while calling a game. Just shut up and call the game and let the papers worry about ripping players. Aikman wouldnt be bad if he didnt care what people thought of him. I know hes been called a homer etc and since then he has went down the tubes.

What happen to the days of "this is Pat Summerall along with John Madden" and you got the feel of, lack of a better analogy, comfort. With Buck and Aikman you always get the feeling of how long will it take before the first shot is given. You might as well throw Skip Bayless in the booth as well.

Jon Gruden is old school and is a breath of fresh air. I cant stand Mike Tirco. Every time he calls a big play he sounds like a spoiled kid who is excited because they got a brand new toy. Jaws wants to be an encyclopedia out there. I watched 250 hrs of game tape in the last 2 weeks on how the Cowboys run there draw play. Jaws just shut up.

MNF would be awful without Gruden. I'd say keep Gruden and get rid of Tirco and replace him with Mike Emerick hockey's Pat Summerall. For the 3rd guy you need another person like Gruden who has played the game and is also charismatic. Why not the Rock Dwayne Johnson. He played for the U and is awesome with the mic. I know its radical but its something.


You're right about Jaws. He says something similar every week.

The Rock is actually an interesting idea.
 
Once a year, I have to listen to Deion Sanders, and it makes me want to murder kittens.
 
People like Chris Colinsworth make me miss the great John Madden. He was so simple, yet so insiteful. MNF would be perfect if it was just Gruden and Tirico. Jaws won't stop nerding out over deep passing plays.
 
Back
Top