I agree. You just can't GIVE someone a spot. Hayden started last year. I know his talent level, but he is the incumbent. Let someone beat him- it shouldn't be too hard before giving anything. What if they can't? You willing to give that guy a spot? He can't even beat Hayden out. Let the stiff lose his position instead of giving his position away. Either way the result will end up the same and the winner will feel more of a... winner than some guy handed a job.