1. Like to discuss POLITICS? Come join us at PUNNDITS.com!
    If you like discussing politics and other related topics then your new home (hopefully) for doing just that can be found on Punndits.com! Come join us and help us grow Punndits into a wonderful and safe place to discuss politics with everyone.
    Dismiss Notice

Billy Joel vs Elton John

Discussion in 'Off-topic Zone' started by CowboyDan, Apr 19, 2011.

  1. CowboyDan

    CowboyDan Anger is a Gift

    3,422 Messages
    151 Likes Received
    This is a tough one. Both artists have had incredible careers, both are amazing piano players and singers, but if I had to choose one it would be Billy Joel. Elton and Bernie were a great tandem, but his music lost a bit for me after they stopped writing music together. Boy this should be a good thread..........

    Here's one of my favorites from Billy Joel

    [youtube]23uuW79KBhE&feature=related[/youtube]
     
  2. Sam I Am

    Sam I Am Unfriendly and Aloof!

    36,525 Messages
    4,270 Likes Received
    Ugh.

    Just not really my style of music.
     
  3. Joshmvii

    Joshmvii Cowboys baby!

    2,691 Messages
    72 Likes Received
    I have to go with Elton John, but it's purely personal taste, and you can't go wrong with either.
     
  4. Achilleslastand

    Achilleslastand Well-Known Member

    2,529 Messages
    1,032 Likes Received
    Elton john and its not even close
     
  5. Sam I Am

    Sam I Am Unfriendly and Aloof!

    36,525 Messages
    4,270 Likes Received
    The Uptown Girl is pissed off at you!
     
  6. Yeagermeister

    Yeagermeister Active Member

    47,592 Messages
    17 Likes Received
    That's a tough one but I'd say I listen to Elton John's songs more than Billy Joel.
     
  7. Eric_Boyer

    Eric_Boyer Well-Known Member

    5,278 Messages
    905 Likes Received
    I'm amazed this is even a thread. Billy Joel's music does not seem to live up to the test of time at all, I cringe when it comes on the radio.
     
  8. big dog cowboy

    big dog cowboy THE BIG DOG Staff Member

    63,210 Messages
    15,489 Likes Received
    Elton John
     
  9. CowboyDan

    CowboyDan Anger is a Gift

    3,422 Messages
    151 Likes Received
    Really??

    Captain Jack
    Piano Man
    New York State of Mind
    While the Night is Still Young
    The Longest Time
    Keeping the Faith
    Scenes from an Italian Restaurant
    Allentown
    She's Got a Way
    Always a Woman
    We Didn't Start the Fire
    Just the Way You Are
    Only The Good Die Young
    You May Be Right
    Don't Ask Me Why
    Tell Her About it
    The River of Dreams
    Shameless
    The Downeaster Alexa

    I think all of these have stood the test of time. Can you think of 19 Elton John songs that have? Here's what I've got so far:

    Your Song
    Tiny Dancer
    Daniel
    Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
    Saturday Night's Alright for Fighting
    Rocket Man
    Candle in the Wind
    Bennie and the Jets
    Don't Let The Sun Go Down on Me
    Burn Down the Mission
    Daniel
    Crocodile Rock??
    Honky Cat??
    Don't Go Breaking My Heart??
     
  10. Doomsday101

    Doomsday101 Well-Known Member

    85,996 Messages
    8,647 Likes Received
    [youtube]w-M8Hi3vNKM[/youtube]
     
  11. Doomsday101

    Doomsday101 Well-Known Member

    85,996 Messages
    8,647 Likes Received
    Did not know he was gay until he did the song
    "Hold me close oh Tony Danza" :lmao:
     
  12. Yeagermeister

    Yeagermeister Active Member

    47,592 Messages
    17 Likes Received
    I can't say I have ever heard those played on the radio.....great songs just never hear them being played.
     
  13. Faerluna

    Faerluna I'm Complicated

    5,144 Messages
    4 Likes Received
    While both are great, I have to go with Billy Joel, easily.

    [youtube]dcnd55tLCv8[/youtube]
     
  14. DFWJC

    DFWJC Well-Known Member Zone Supporter

    30,266 Messages
    6,845 Likes Received
    Same here.
     
  15. Eric_Boyer

    Eric_Boyer Well-Known Member

    5,278 Messages
    905 Likes Received
    I would turn off the radio or turn the channel if any of these were played.

    For some of them, I might also kick the dog for good measure. And as a kid, I liked his music, so it sure didn't pass the test of time for me.
     
  16. Sam I Am

    Sam I Am Unfriendly and Aloof!

    36,525 Messages
    4,270 Likes Received
    You've never heard Shamless on the radio?!?!?

    The only Shamless song I've heard more on the radio than Billy Joel's Shamless is when Garth Brooks covered Billy's song. :laugh2:
     
  17. CowboyDan

    CowboyDan Anger is a Gift

    3,422 Messages
    151 Likes Received
    Not that radio play is any indicator of song quality, but I'll give you
    Shameless, The Downeaster Alexa , While the Night is Still Young....

    but are you serious that these 3 don't get radio play??

    Captain Jack
    Scenes from an Italian Restaurant

    Don't Ask Me Why
     
  18. CowboyDan

    CowboyDan Anger is a Gift

    3,422 Messages
    151 Likes Received
    Unfortunately I hear the Garth Brooks version waaaaaay more. :(
     
  19. CowboyDan

    CowboyDan Anger is a Gift

    3,422 Messages
    151 Likes Received
    Well, at least we can agree on Rage Against the Machine :D

    now get out of my thread!! ;)
     
  20. Eric_Boyer

    Eric_Boyer Well-Known Member

    5,278 Messages
    905 Likes Received
    I think the lead singer of The Band is who he actually had a crush on.
     

Share This Page