CFN Fiutak WR capsules

Discussion in 'Draft Zone' started by RS12, Apr 17, 2009.

  1. RS12

    RS12 Well-Known Member

    21,722 Messages
    8,866 Likes Received
    Not as crazy about Crabtree as everybody else, likes Brandon Tate:star:

    The Wide Receivers

    2009 NFL Draft Post-Workout Rankings

    By Pete Fiutak

    This class is ... strong. There will be plenty of second guessing up top between Maclin, Harvin and Crabtree, but there’s great value to be had in the mid-rounds. There are a few unpolished gems to be plucked on the second day.

    The Best Value Pick Will Be ... Louis Murphy, Florida

    Most Underrated ... Brian Robiskie, Ohio State

    Most Overrated … Hakeem Nicks, North Carolina

    The Deep, Deep Sleeper Is .. Dominique Edison, Stephen F. Austin

    1. Jeremy Maclin, Missouri 6-1, 210 (3rd year Soph.)
    Does he have the ability to stay healthy and get more physical? While he’s tough, he played through an ankle injury, he’s mostly been a finesse target who’s been great on the move and in space. He has the hands, he has the top-end speed, and he has the return ability to become an instant impact playmaker in a variety of ways. It’s his speed that sets him apart with an extra gear when he gets going. How fast is he? He tore off a “disappointing” 4.4 at the Combine even though he had a dinged up leg. When he’s right, he’ll be a No. 1 receiver and a big-time playmaker, but he can’t be counted on for a full 16-game season.
    CFN Projection: First Round

    2. Percy Harvin, Florida 5-11, 195 (Jr.)
    A smaller, better running version of Jeremy Maclin, Harvin was an elite playmaker when he was able to stay on the field. Oh sure, Tim Tebow had the speech and has been the signature star, but Florida doesn’t win the SEC title or the national title without Harvin. While he’s not all that big, he’s strong, well-built, and tough. However, he gets hurt way too often to be a top target to build a passing game around. He’ll have to be a complementary weapon who’ll do a little of everything for an offense, and he’ll likely be tried out and used as a returner. A top offensive coordinator will drool at the possibilities, and there will be some big games when Harvin explodes, but he’ll have a tough time being consistent and he’s not going to stay healthy.
    CFN Projection: First Round

    3. Michael Crabtree, Texas Tech 6-1, 215 (3rd year Soph.)
    Everyone has fallen in love with Crabtree because of his size, desire, and his tremendous production at Texas Tech. However, there are major warning signs that he might not be the be-all-end-all No. 1 target. For one, he’s not as big as expected. Considered to be in the same category as Larry Fitzgerald, Calvin Johnson, and Andre Johnson, top receivers who went in the top three overall, Crabtree isn’t nearly as tall and he’s nowhere near as fast. And then there’s the foot issue. No one is considering for a second that there’s anything strange about the injury, the timing couldn’t be better. He’s not a 4.4 runner, and he’s more likely around a devastatingly stock-dropping 4.6. Is that for sure? No way, but it’s asking a lot to draft a wide receiver in the top 10 without knowing if he can run. He needs to get the ball in a quick-hitting passing attack and on the move. Randy Moss he’s not; he’s not going to get deep on any NFL starting cornerback. Ultra-competitive, he’s the type who’ll want to make himself better and he’s the one true No. 1 type of receiver in the draft. All the doubters out there and all the question marks are a major positive. It’ll all light a fire under him that could carry into an extremely productive pro career in the right offense.
    CFN Projection: First Round

    4. Darrius Heyward-Bey, Maryland 6-2, 210 (Jr.)
    Speed, speed and more speed. There’s no questioning his athleticism, his wheels, or his raw skills that everyone knew about throughout his career, and were then shown off at the Combine and in workouts. However, he might be a one-trick pony as a speed receiver. Not a consistent playmaker for the Terps and not a do-it-all sort of performer, he’s a deep threat who’ll stretch the field and create major problems for any secondary and any top corner. However, he has work to do to become more of a short-to-midrange target to go along with the elite wheels. He’ll do what he has to. He’ll work his tail off to become more than just a track guy playing football and isn’t a prima donna.
    CFN Projection: First Round


    5. Brian Robiskie, Ohio State 6-3, 209
    While he’s not all that fast and he’s not quite good enough to be an elite go-to target, he’s ready to step in and be a starter right now. He’s polished, productive, and smart. He’ll get the pro playbook right away, will be a favorite for any quarterback because of his route running ability, and he’ll make the plays thrown his way. What he doesn’t have is the top-end gear to get past an NFL corner, but he should grow into a terrific No. 2 target who thrives alongside a speedy No. 1. While there might be a bit of a ceiling on what he can become, he was underutilized in his final year once Terrelle Pryor took over. While he might have disappeared at times, that’s not going to happen once he sets foot in a pro-style offense.
    CFN Projection: Second Round

    6. Hakeem Nicks, North Carolina 6-1, 212 (Jr.)
    With great hands, a No. 1 target attitude, and good size and toughness, he has the look of a possible Cris Carter-type who could grow into a superstar if he can stay in shape. That’s been an issue since the end of the year after beefing up, and not necessarily in a good way. His speed is average at best as is, and he might have big problems if he’s not in tip-top shape at all times. Even so, if it all comes together, and if he has the right attitude, it’s all there for him to be a major steal. He’ll demand the ball, will go get it when it’s thrown to him, and will make the highlight reel play when he’s on a roll. He’s a difference maker who could become special.
    CFN Projection: Second Round

    7. Derrick Williams, Penn State 5-11, 195
    He’ll go on the cheap compared to Jeremy Maclin and Percy Harvin, similar players who have a better buzz. No, Williams isn’t as fast as some of the top prospects and he was a disappointment as a receiver considering he was considered the nation’s top high school prospect. However, he’s a versatile playmaker who’ll be used as a returner and can get a few carries per game. While he might not be a special NFL receiver, he’ll likely hang around the league for a decade and be very, very solid as a dirty work, inside target.
    CFN Projection: Second Round

    8. Kenny Britt, WR Rutgers 6-4, 215 (Jr.)
    There are two questions: speed and character. Everything else is there. He produced even though he was the target of every defense, QB Mike Teel wasn’t always great, and Ray Rice and the running game dominated the offense until last year. Extremely strong, he’ll beat up defensive backs fighting for the ball and as a blocker. While he doesn’t have top-end speed, he’s a better deep threat than he probably could be. He’s a fighter, and not just on the field. He might rub coaches the wrong way and he could check out if he’s not a No. 1 option. However, he could be a No. 1 option. If he can harness his energy and be focused full-time, he has Pro Bowl potential.
    CFN Projection: Second Round

    9. Demetrius Byrd, LSU 6-1, 200
    The epitome of the million-dollar talent with a ten-cent head. He has it all with size, speed, and tremendous upside. He can hit the home run, find the hole in the seam, and do big things when he gets the ball on the move. However, he’s not a refined route runner, will drop passes, and didn’t produce like a superstar receiver he should’ve become. He was plenty good, and he’ll be solid for someone on raw skills alone, but he could be great. Special. If it all kicks in and if he finds the desire to become the NFL’s best receiver, it’s all there for him. The world is his if he wants it.
    CFN Projection: Third Round

    10. Brandon Tate, North Carolina 6-1, 185
    If given time he could be great. One of the all-time great kickoff returners in college football history, he was on his way to a special year as a receiver as well as a return man before suffering a horrendous knee injury that could still keep him at far less than 100% well into the 2009 NFL season. Before the injury he was tremendously quick, hard to get a hold of, and productive. In time, he’ll be a top-shelf special teamer and a very, very good inside receiver once he’s healthy again. He might have been a late first rounder if he didn’t have the knee problem.
    CFN Projection: Third Round

    11. Louis Murphy, Florida 6-2, 205
    The skills are all there and he has tremendous upside, but he has to work on becoming a wide receiver. His sub-4.4 speed alone makes him a strong deep threat, and he’s a great athlete who can jump out of the stadium. Throw in the character, he was a captain on a national championship team, and he would seem like a near-perfect prospect. However, he needs polish in a big way. He was good for the Gators but he didn’t become great until his senior year. Even so, he was underrated compared to the rest of the stars on last year’s team; he never got enough credit for all he did for the offense. He’s not going to be anything to count on right away unless he’s used as a pure deep threat, but he can improve his concentration, limit the drops, a work and work and work on his basic receiving skills, he could make a lot of money as a long-time pro.
    CFN Projection: Third Round

    12. Juaquin Iglesias, Oklahoma 6-0, 205
    While he’s not going to impress on the stopwatch and he might have flourished because he played in the Oklahoma offense, he’s a flat-out wide receiver who has an extremely low downside. He has great hands, is a strong route runner, and plays faster than he times. Get him the ball on the move and he’ll make something happen. While he’ll get beaten up by physical defensive backs and he’s not going to hit the home runs he did for the Sooners, he’s a hard worker and a good enough player to make a coaching staff instantly happy once camp starts. He’s not going to be one of the top receivers in the draft, but he’ll stick.
    CFN Projection: Third Round

    13. Ramses Barden, Cal Poly 6-6, 205
    Very big, very tall, and very, very productive, he was one of the most dominant offensive weapons on the FCS level over the last four years. While he played at a lower level, he caught six passes for 83 yards and a score at Wisconsin. However, he didn’t see any other action against FBS teams and was erased at the Senior Bowl. He’s not all that fast and he’s not nearly as physical as he should be for a player of his size, but he knows how to make plays and he knows how to score. It’ll take a little while and a lot of work on his refinement, but if he hits the weights, gets a nasty attitude, and develops a niche, like as a goal line playmaker, he could grow into a weapon.
    CFN Projection: Fourth Round

    14. Mike Thomas, Arizona 5-8, 185
    If he was two inches taller he might be seen as a first rounder. Cut, he’s extremely well built and is tough as nails. He’ll fight though injuries and will have to be dragged off the field. Ultra-productive for Arizona, he did a little of everything well and wasn’t afraid to catch the ball in traffic even at his size. The size, or lack of it, is a major factor, even though his phenomenal vertical leaping ability makes up for it a little bit. With 4.3 wheels, he could grow into a deep threat who punishes defenses for not paying attention to him. The intangibles are all there, but he’ll be dragged down because he’s just too short.
    CFN Projection: Fourth Round

    15. Mohamed Massaquoi, Georgia 6-1, 205
    While he never lived up to the immense prep hype, he grew into a dependable all-around playmaker for the Bulldogs by the end of his career. He’s not going to be a star, but he’s going to be a very, very good, reliable pro for a long time because he does all the things coaches like. He blocks, he’s tough, he goes over the middle, and he’ll do whatever he needs to do. A good athlete, he has just enough speed to get by. However, he’s just not that good a receiver. He’ll make too many drops and will disappear for long stretches. While he’ll be a nice part of an offense, he’ll never be great.
    CFN Projection: Third Round

    16. Jarett Dillard, Rice 5-10, 185
    Ultra-productive, he was unstoppable even when everyone was focused on stopping him. Part of the equation was the wide-open spread attack, and part of it was that Dillard was simply that good. He makes every catch, takes his game to another level when he’s trying to score, and will work his tail off. While he’s too small to not get beaten up, and he’s not a blazer, he jumps out of the stadium and plays much bigger than he is. He’ll stick on a roster because he’ll run every route needed, will catch every pass, and will do everything asked of him. But there’s a ceiling on what he can do because of his size and lack of top speed.
    CFN Projection: Fourth Round

    17. Deon Butler, Penn State 5-10, 185
    Always seen as part of the receiving corps, nothing more, he busted out this off-season with a jaw-dropping 4.36 that had everyone at the Combine buzzing. With his superior quickness and his great hands, he could explode as a slot receiver if he can get the ball in space on a regular basis. While he’s not a returner, he’ll work to try to become one. If he can bust out one nice return in practices, he could stick around for a while and will get a lot more attention. The problem is his size; this is it. He bulked up this off-season, but he doesn’t have any room to get any bigger and he isn’t all that physical.
    CFN Projection: Fourth Round


    18. Greg Carr, Florida State 6-5, 215
    Why didn’t Florida State throw jump balls to Carr on every other play? If nothing else, he scared the heck out of secondaries. Underutilized at times, he had one thing he could do and he did it very well. However, he’s a one-trick pony. He’s not nearly physical enough for his size, doesn’t go over the middle, and he’ll get shoved around. It’s all about what he can do on the goal line and if he can become a specialist. Throw it up, let him go get it as a possible matchup nightmare, and let him work outside the hashmarks.
    CFN Projection: Sixth Round

    19. Patrick Turner, USC 6-5. 220
    He went from being undraftable to an interesting late round prospect after the season. Way too slow and not nearly productive enough considering his high school résumé, and the offense he played in, he opened up eyes at the Combine and in Senior Bowl practices. More fluid this off-season than he ever appeared to be at USC, his combination of size and hands make him a safe flier.
    CFN Projection: Sixth Round

    20. Brandon Gibson, Washington State 6-0, 200
    Very productive despite all his limitations, Gibson works hard, was productive for some bad teams, and is tough. He’ll be a good possession receiver who’ll block anyone needed to be hit, but he doesn’t have enough speed to be anything more than a complementary target. While he didn’t stand out this off-season, he could be a big surprise once he gets an NFL quarterback throwing his way.
    CFN Projection: Fifth Round

    21. Kevin Ogletree, Virginia 6-2, 190 (Jr.)
    It was a bit of a shock when he said he was leaving early, and no one at Virginia appeared to be too upset. A brutal knee injury limited a one-time promising career, but he did a decent job and had some big games when he was on the field. Extremely fast, he had a great Combine and now could be used as a deep threat, even though he didn’t do much field-stretching for the Cavaliers.
    CFN Projection: Sixth Round

    22. Austin Collie, BYU 6-2, 200 (Jr.)
    While everyone just assumes Michael Crabtree led the nation in all the top receiving categories because of the offense he was in, but it was Collie who led the nation in receiving yards. While he doesn’t run all that well and he’s not all that quick, he’s a pure receiver who runs great routes, catches everything, and goes after the ball well. He’s a polished target, but he doesn’t have a lot of upside.
    CFN Projection: Fifth Round

    23. Brian Hartline, Ohio State 6-2, 185 (Jr.)
    He should’ve come back for another year, but the writing was on the wall that the Buckeye offense just wasn’t going to do much with the passing game with Terrelle Pryor under center. Hartline went from undraftable to a possible No. 3 inside receiver after showing phenomenal quickness at the Combine. Far more quick than fast, he’s not going to burn anyone deep and he’s not going to shove anyone around, but he has the potential to be decent.
    CFN Projection: Sixth Round

    24. Jeremy Childs, Boise State 6-0, 195 (Jr.)
    Productive when he was on the field, Childs had problems off the field, mainly in school. He’s very tough with excellent hands and will fight for the ball, but he doesn’t have special skills. The speed isn’t there and he’ll struggle to separate from a good defensive back at the next level. Even so, he’s a good receiver who’ll be where he needs to be, will run solid routes, and could make a roster as a possession target.
    CFN Projection: Fifth Round

    25. Kenny McKinley, South Carolina 5-11, 185
    Fantastic for the Gamecocks and extremely productive in SEC play, he’ll have problems finding a role at an NFL level. While he’s very fast and he did a good job against bigger defensive backs, he’ll get beaten up if he’s not always in space. He doesn’t play up to his speed and he’ll get shoved around, but he has good hands and he’s a fighter who’ll be tough to cut.
    CFN Projection: Sixth Round

    26. Aaron Kelly, Clemson 6-5, 195
    With great size and leaping ability he could find a niche as an inside target and a possession receiver, and he could also grow into a goal line target if he’s given a chance. However, he’s not physical enough to be a regular blocker and there will be durability concerns. There isn’t enough of a burst to do anything on the outside.
    CFN Projection: Seventh Round

    27. Brooks Foster, North Carolina 6-0, 211
    Could be the best of the Tar Heel lot that’ll be drafted with a good blend of size and speed. However, he didn’t stand out often enough.
    CFN Projection: Fourth Round

    28. Sammie Stroughter, Oregon State 5-9, 190
    Tremendously productive when healthy, he’ll make his money as a returner and a fourth receiver.
    CFN Projection: Sixth Round

    29. Johnny Knox, Abilene Christian 5-11, 185
    He’ll make a roster on his 4.34 speed alone, but he’s not big enough. He’ll get beaten up and won’t be able to use his wheels.
    CFN Projection: Fifth Round

    30. Mike Wallace, Ole Miss 6-1 200
    Extremely fast, he should be tried out as a returner and a deep threat. Very, very raw as a receiver.
    CFN Projection: Sixth Round

    31. Quan Cosby, Texas 5-9 195
    A very small, very old (he’s 27) slot receiver, he’s polished and could bounce around the league for several years.
    CFN Projection: Free Agent

    32. Tiquan Underwood, Rutgers 6-1 185
    The running mate next to Kenny Britt, he’s a phenomenal athlete with jaw-dropping speed and leaping ability. He’s not nearly physical enough and will be knocked off a route by a soft breeze.
    CFN Projection: Seventh Round

    33. Darius Passmore, Marshall 6-1 188
    Character and durability issues overshadow how fluid he is. Very thin and not physical, he needs to use his athleticism to find a role as a returner.
    CFN Projection: Free Agent

    34. Jaison Williams, Oregon 6-5 235
    Huge, he needs to establish himself as a possible H-Back. He’s a good athlete with nice hands, but he’s way too slow.
    CFN Projection: Sixth Round

    35. Jordan Norwood, Penn State 5-11 180
    Too small, too slow, and not strong enough, he doesn’t have NFL talent. However, he’s a good football player who’ll run good routes.
    CFN Projection: Free Agent

    36. Brennan Marion, Tulsa, 5-11 185
    37. Eron Riley, Duke 6-3 200
    38. Michael Jones, Arizona State 6-3 205
    39. Nate Swift, Nebraska 6-2 205
    40. David Richmond, San Jose State 6-2 196
    41. Derek Kinder, Pitt 6-0 215
    42. Deon Murphy, Kansas State 5-10 170
    43. Dicky Lyons, Kentucky 5-10 180
    44. Rodgeriqus Smith, Auburn 5-11 195
    45. Dominick Goodman, Cincinnati 5-11 205
    46. Marcus Herford, Kansas 6-1 200
    47. Quentin Chaney, Oklahoma 6-4
    48. Greg Orton, Purdue 6-3 207
    49. Taurus Johnson, South Florida 6-0 200
    50. Andrew Means, Indiana 6-1 215
  2. igtmfo

    igtmfo Well-Known Member

    1,282 Messages
    69 Likes Received
    Thnx for posting. This will come in handy Sunday as the "who?" guys are picked.

    I bet we draft 2 WRs along the way. And I bet we convince several of the top UDFAs to sign here who figure they might unseat Hurd, Stanback at the least. Agents have to know we have a thin crew at WR and will point their guys to the Cowboys.

    Cowboy scouts have been working overtime grading WR since there will be some late gems there ...

Share This Page