Drafting Claiborne vs. Brockers/Wagner

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by Zordon, Jan 11, 2013.

  1. Zordon

    Zordon Well-Known Member

    14,258 Messages
    14,358 Likes Received
    Which would have been better for a 4-3 defense?

    Could you imagine for a second, Wagner-Lee-Carter as our linebacker unit?

    How about a rotation of Hatcher-Ratliff-Brockers on the inside?
  2. 187beatdown

    187beatdown Lack of Big Plays

    7,108 Messages
    4,144 Likes Received
    That would have been very nice indeed.

    Probably one of the best front 7 in the league on paper.

    But we had a 3-4 at the time and were coming off a year that secondary was the most pressing issue.
  3. RS12

    RS12 Well-Known Member

    21,721 Messages
    8,866 Likes Received
    Or some combination of Brockers/Wagner/Hayward would have had them miles ahead.
  4. Idgit

    Idgit That sounds really boring Staff Member

    45,247 Messages
    29,752 Likes Received
    The Mark Barron question comes back into play, as well, now.
  5. Risen Star

    Risen Star Likes Collector Zone Supporter

    39,006 Messages
    46,891 Likes Received
    4-3 or 3-4...I'll take Brockers and Wagner. And I said that right after the draft.
  6. Eddie

    Eddie Well-Known Member

    11,772 Messages
    2,403 Likes Received
    I am never a proponent of giving up multiple picks for a single player.

    Both those guys would look good now. But we have Mo ...
  7. LatinMind

    LatinMind iPhotoshop

    12,227 Messages
    4,870 Likes Received
    No it doesnt. Claiborne was the right pick
  8. da_whiz_kid

    da_whiz_kid Active Member

    975 Messages
    216 Likes Received
    mo. quite simply because he is here and they are not. and im bias as hell. lol cant miss what we never had. how do you feel about ogeltree this year?
  9. cowboysooner

    cowboysooner Well-Known Member

    1,382 Messages
    30 Likes Received
    Well since no Tampa 2 team in history has ever traded up to the top 10 to take a corner I'd rather have 2 future pro bowlers at dt and linebacker. Tampa did not even stay where they were to take Claiborne.

    Spencer played up to a contract and it is like we decided if he is that nice we just can't afford it. It is moving out of a house bc the property taxes are too high.

    Brockers is going to be an absolute star btw. He'd be a star in any scheme. Really good offensive lines like San Francisco can't move him and he gives great inside push He had 4 or 5 sacks in 12 games. Btw. William Hayes might be a decent piece. He had decent pressure as their third end.
  10. Deep_Freeze

    Deep_Freeze Well-Known Member

    8,161 Messages
    1,694 Likes Received
    Hindsight is always 20/20, we did what was best for us at that time.

    I'd rather have JJ Watt over Tyron (although thats a dirty one noone wants to admit).....but who cares, its over now.
  11. CowboyStar88

    CowboyStar88 Well-Known Member

    9,628 Messages
    5,717 Likes Received
    They weren't a Tampa 2 team when they made the trade. Also according to Kiffin they are not going to run the "zone" like everyone is crying about. He is going to let these guys play man like they were suppose to. People just don't want to read or listen they rather complain. SMH:rolleyes:
  12. MichaelWinicki

    MichaelWinicki "You want some?" Staff Member

    41,085 Messages
    13,323 Likes Received
    You're right.
  13. cowboysooner

    cowboysooner Well-Known Member

    1,382 Messages
    30 Likes Received
    The point of the question is by its nature reflective of last years draft. If you don't like the question or discussion okay I guess but it is the very reason this move is questionable.

    If we had taken zeitler and Cordy Glenn last year switching to a 4-3 would not be as big of a deal.
  14. InmanRoshi

    InmanRoshi Zone Scribe

    18,334 Messages
    79 Likes Received
    I remember when the entire board crapped their pants when it was rumored we would have taken Wagner in the 2nd round.
  15. cowboysooner

    cowboysooner Well-Known Member

    1,382 Messages
    30 Likes Received
    I wonder if they had not gotten Claiborne if they would not have traded spencer for a pick on the second day of the draft.
  16. rbr651

    rbr651 Active Member

    690 Messages
    55 Likes Received

    The improvement that we made at CB I think was much more important than upgrading at LB or in the front 3 at the time of the draft. Nobody new that we would be switching back to a 43 last year, hell as far as that goes nobody knows for sure that we'll be playing a 43 next year, yeah it's probable but not definitive, at least not yet.
  17. rocyaice

    rocyaice Well-Known Member

    12,250 Messages
    4,377 Likes Received
    We still made the right decision. Even in hindsight. I still believe Claiborne will be a better player than Brockers and there was no need for ANOTHER ILB on this team. Just wasn't.
  18. el_chevo

    el_chevo El Serrano

    872 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    Sometimes, I believe, folks tend to overlook one component of athletes - the mind. You can draft all the talent you want, but if they are too mentally challenged to develop, well then, you have made a draft mistake.
  19. theogt

    theogt Surrealist Zone Supporter

    45,816 Messages
    5,733 Likes Received
    I guarantee you most GMs would still make the same trade. A top corner is infinitely more valuable than a linebacker or interior defensive lineman. Brockers lucked out with 4 sacks in 3 games. Otherwise he was pretty ineffective, and almost certainly will be in the remainder of this career.

    Wagner would have seen the field this year, but only because of our injuries. Without the injuries, he would have been a special teams player.
  20. perrykemp

    perrykemp Well-Known Member

    9,926 Messages
    6,223 Likes Received
    Well, if we are talking hindsight, Casey Heyward is a prototypical zone CB. Incredible ball skills -- good tackler, etc.

    If you are talking hindsight AND have the hindsight of knowing the team was moving to a 4-3 Tampa 2 defense the next year, taking Bockers in the 1st and Heyward in the 2nd would have much better in hinsight.

    Again, a lot of hindsight there.

Share This Page