Is this the Worst Defense in Cowboys History?

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by Blue Eyed Devil, Nov 11, 2013.

  1. Blue Eyed Devil

    Blue Eyed Devil Active Member

    474 Messages
    55 Likes Received
    I don't mean this to be a hyperbolic "let's all get angry on Monday" post, I mean this to be completely cold and honest. Is this legitimately the worst defense the Dallas Cowboys have ever fielded in their history? Certainly it has a lot of competition. The 2010 Dallas Cowboys defense is probobly the gold standard of bad defense. Last year's 2012 MASH unit defense also makes a strong argument. So how could this defense really be worse?

    The 2013 Dallas Cowboys are the only defense in the history of the NFL to surrender four 400-yard passing performances in a season, and the season isn't even over! Two weeks ago they set the record for most yards given up by a defense at 623 against the Lions only to break their own record by allowing 625 to the Saints. They are the first defense in the NFL to give up 40 first-downs in a game.

    Some might argue that those stats are just numbers and that the team isn't quitting like Mike Jenkins famously did against Green Bay in 2010. Well I'd like to bring in Exhibit A - Bruce Carter. Bruce Carter gave up last night every bit as much as Jenkins did. If you watch that 4th quarter Carter was jogging around trying to find every reason not to be involved in a tackle. When an offensive lineman got anywhere between him and a ball-carrier he just extended his arms and walked into him "well, guess you blocked me! oops! my bad!" It looked like a walk-through where the 2nd team defense lets the offensive linemen practice going where they are supposed to. It's bad enough when a cornerback doesn't want to tackle, but when your guy playing middle linebacker is thinking about how he doesn't want to be sore so he can enjoy the bye week instead of tackling, that is showing a lot of give-up from the team. Also, Jason Hatcher's statement yesterday that the reason he doesn't want to play is because he's about to be a free agent and doesn't want to put bad film out there says a lot about how these players have given up on this team.

    So is this the worst defense in Cowboys history?
    jobberone, CowboyMike and lostar2009 like this.
  2. perrykemp

    perrykemp Well-Known Member

    9,952 Messages
    6,273 Likes Received
    This one takes the cake.
  3. JoeyBoy718

    JoeyBoy718 Well-Known Member

    8,521 Messages
    6,248 Likes Received
    The question should be is this the worst defense in NFL history
  4. DFWJC

    DFWJC Well-Known Member

    36,153 Messages
    18,289 Likes Received
    If they were healthy? No.
    As they are as of today? They have to be in consideration
  5. Cowboyz88

    Cowboyz88 Well-Known Member

    6,106 Messages
    2,380 Likes Received
    Why stop at the franchise's worst? They're looking at the NFL's worst.
  6. BrAinPaiNt

    BrAinPaiNt Backwoods Sexy Staff Member

    68,369 Messages
    16,239 Likes Received
    You add this one and last years together and you get a special bonus prize of a ulcer and pack of hemorrhoids for all cowboys fans.
  7. 17yearsandcounting

    17yearsandcounting Benched

    2,391 Messages
    1,677 Likes Received
    It is the worst in the history of the league. We makin history boys.
    lostar2009 likes this.
  8. perrykemp

    perrykemp Well-Known Member

    9,952 Messages
    6,273 Likes Received
    Never saw that prize in my box of crackjacks.
  9. Sarge

    Sarge Red, White and brew... Staff Member

    25,028 Messages
    11,302 Likes Received
    :eek::eek:o_Oo_O :confused:
    Trouty likes this.
  10. Matts4313

    Matts4313 Well-Known Member

    344 Messages
    266 Likes Received
    We are like ~20th in points given up. Were not even the worst Cowboys defense of the last 12 months.
  11. BrAinPaiNt

    BrAinPaiNt Backwoods Sexy Staff Member

    68,369 Messages
    16,239 Likes Received

    Like I said it depends on what statistic you decide to use.

    We were worse in some last year, worse in others this year.

    Both years I think we reach record levels in a bad statistic or two just different ones. give up an NFL RECORD of first downs...that's a pretty good indicator of being bad.
  12. Matts4313

    Matts4313 Well-Known Member

    344 Messages
    266 Likes Received
    Ohh were bad, Im not arguing that.

    I will never get the yardage thing though is the comparison of defenses. Points is really what matters. If I had to rank the key statistics of how you judge a defense:



    Splash plays (Sacks/INTS/forced fumbles)

    (Big Gap)

    koolaid likes this.
  13. wileedog

    wileedog Well-Known Member

    11,049 Messages
    1,834 Likes Received

    While I think you could make a legitimate argument about Points, I would rank Yards before Splash plays. Not all fumbles are forced. Not all INTs are great plays by the defense. Turnovers have an element of luck to them that can't really be compared from team to team.

    Yards are a constant. Generally good defenses don't give up many of them. Bad defenses typically give up lots of them. That is pretty consistent throughout the games history.
  14. hornitosmonster

    hornitosmonster Well-Known Member

    7,934 Messages
    2,741 Likes Received
    I think so. And when they don't create turnovers the end result is what we saw last night. It will get worse with Lee out
  15. Asklesko

    Asklesko Well-Known Member

    1,256 Messages
    150 Likes Received
    from doomsday to day after....
  16. Zman5

    Zman5 Well-Known Member

    7,966 Messages
    4,238 Likes Received
    JG is working hard to get the Cowboys in the record books.
  17. JPM

    JPM Well-Known Member

    5,662 Messages
    167 Likes Received
    A mixed bag of dog poo.
  18. Seven

    Seven Messenger to the football Gods

    14,705 Messages
    4,285 Likes Received

    Stats can't even begin to describe the dis-functionality of this group. But, I guess they gotta place 'suckage' in one category or the other.

    Worse defense in my 37 years of watching the Cowboys. Hands. Down.
    munkee likes this.
  19. Risen Star

    Risen Star Likes Collector Zone Supporter

    39,213 Messages
    47,616 Likes Received
    At least this is a simpler defense that allows guys to come in off the street and play in.
  20. unionjack8

    unionjack8 Well-Known Member

    4,835 Messages
    2,275 Likes Received
    to answer your question, yes it is

Share This Page