Late and Close: Career QB Comparison

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by percyhoward, Nov 27, 2013.

  1. percyhoward

    percyhoward Research Tool

    12,745 Messages
    12,080 Likes Received
    I think they're $tirring controver$y.
    dstovall5 likes this.
  2. Hoofbite

    Hoofbite Well-Known Member

    35,095 Messages
    4,367 Likes Received
    Pretty impressive. Try adding game outcome of "win" to the mix.

    Romo goes up to 120.0 and Eli actually moves up to 115.8

    One thing that sticks out is opportunity. Romo has a ridiculous number of attempts relative to other QBs who have played a lot more games. I wonder how much early game performance breeds the chance to rack up stats in these situations. If you are a slow starter are you more likely to have opportunities in games where a QB who comes out of the gate hot has done enough early on to negate such a chance?

    In any event the numbers are impressive. When given the chance, he's making the most of them.
  3. ufcrules1

    ufcrules1 Well-Known Member

    9,253 Messages
    3,140 Likes Received
    This is an excellent question. The stat game is fun to play and reveals a lot, but what it hides can be even more revealing.
  4. DandyDon1722

    DandyDon1722 It's been a good 'un, ain't it?

    4,952 Messages
    4,383 Likes Received
    Percy there is nothing I would love to see more than you, a chalkboard and Rodney Harrison. Shannon Sharpe, Marshall Faulk and Steven A Smith on a nationally televised debate.

    Somebody would have to call 911 because you would murder them.

    We'll done sir.
    percyhoward likes this.
  5. ufcrules1

    ufcrules1 Well-Known Member

    9,253 Messages
    3,140 Likes Received
    Hopefully we don't get a repeat of 2012!
  6. ufcrules1

    ufcrules1 Well-Known Member

    9,253 Messages
    3,140 Likes Received
    Can you run this list again with a 7-point difference in the score? I'm curious how it would change.
  7. GusTheo

    GusTheo Active Member

    207 Messages
    73 Likes Received
    I don't see how it would make much of a difference really. Every opportunity with a 7 point difference will also be an opportunity with an 8 point difference. The reason for the 8 is because that's the max for a single score. So I'm not sure how many scenarios will be eliminated by changing it from 8 to 7.
  8. Gameover

    Gameover Well-Known Member

    6,061 Messages
    1,919 Likes Received
    If that's the case, why didn't it work in Oakland?

    Maybe his knee injury is the reason he was done?
  9. T-RO

    T-RO Well-Known Member

    6,637 Messages
    2,963 Likes Received
    And precisely why you should. The fact that there is only one peculiarity in this stellar list of great quarterbacks tells you everything. It's an evidentiary slam dunk if ever there was one.

    To be on this list is almost like being in the HOF. To be at the TOP of the list?

    Don't miss this fact: Culpepper barely qualifies in terms of pass attempts. Schaub barely qualifies.

    If we make the bar, 600 attempts...

    Romo 388 of 608 5204 yd 37 td 15 int 100.9
    PManning 577 of 904 6731 yd 47 td 24 int 92.6
    Brees 530 of 814 6102 yd 38 td 27 int 89.3
    Brady 467 of 786 5681 yd 35 td 25 int 83.3

    This is a torrent of scalding hot water pouring down on any Romo critic.
  10. KB1122

    KB1122 Well-Known Member

    2,015 Messages
    630 Likes Received
    So, are you arguing that Tony Romo isn't just not a choker, but is actually the greatest clutch quarterback of this era? Because you pretty much have to argue that. Or you have to admit that your numbers and assumptions are meaningless.
  11. DandyDon1722

    DandyDon1722 It's been a good 'un, ain't it?

    4,952 Messages
    4,383 Likes Received
    No he doesn't.

    All he has to do is admit this -- much like you do. Tony Romo is as clutch as the players around him. He's done his job even if the team hasn't and as much as fate hasn't been kind to him. You know the numbers on defensive help and if you don't Percy will crush you with them.

    Joe Montana is clutch because Carl Williamson grabbed Drew Pearsons jersey by a fingertip or he's gone for one of the greatest TDs ever and the 49ers lose a championship game. Montana is also clutch because Loius Billups dropped a sure INT right in his hands the play before the TD to beat the Bengals in the Super Bowl or he loses that on a crushing INT. Add Eli to this list also as the benefactor of some great fortune.

    Think about the games that stand out in Romo's career that people point to as him being a choker--


    Except for the Lions game All nationally televised high profile games. If you break those games down did the defense vail him out at all? Drew Bree's picks although just as crucial, were for the most part buried in regional telecasts.

    Tom Brady has thrown 3 INTs on TWO separate AFC Championship games yet won them both -- can you explain that? Was that "clutch" -- please. And btw he is great and I believe the best ever.

    I didnt include Seattle as it's a non quarterback play or the Giants playoff game as that was the same as a Hail Mary.

    It's truly incomprehensible how some of you will try and dispute his greatness...and he is great -- or nitpick at disingenuous alternatives to his numbers.

    Don't worry though unless we get really bad or really lucky Quincy Carter is looming once again and you will have plenty of numbers to dispute.
    RXP, dstovall5 and 03EBZ06 like this.
  12. percyhoward

    percyhoward Research Tool

    12,745 Messages
    12,080 Likes Received
    You're confusing efficiency with production. You don't "rack up" a high passer rating, because passer ratings don't increase with more attempts. The more attempts the passer has, as long as INT%, TD%, completion%, and yards per attempt stay the same, passer rating stays the same. The only way to raise or lower it is to pass better or worse.
    dstovall5 likes this.
  13. percyhoward

    percyhoward Research Tool

    12,745 Messages
    12,080 Likes Received
    Romo 101.8
    PManning 93.9
    Culpepper 93.8
    Brees 89.4
    EManning 87.5
    dstovall5 likes this.
  14. percyhoward

    percyhoward Research Tool

    12,745 Messages
    12,080 Likes Received
    I'd skip the hyperbole and just stick with my own understanding of it, rather than someone else's interpretation. It sounds like you grasp the significance of the numbers. Maybe you overrate the significance of "clutchness" itself. Not that there's much difference in Romo's case, anyway, but the whole game is important.
    nickjamesw43 likes this.
  15. Dodger12

    Dodger12 Well-Known Member

    3,531 Messages
    2,298 Likes Received
    I cringed when Staubach retired but was pleasantly surprised with Danny White who is extremely underrated (followed a HOF QB and came close 4 times to taking us to the SB). Same when Danny White retired until we drafted Aikman. Then we had to suffer through this team's attempts to find a quality QB until Romo came along.

    People better start appreciating what they're seeing with Romo because when he's gone, there's no Landry, Johnson, Parcells/Payton to find (and develop) the next QB. There are dark days on the horizon.
  16. dstovall5

    dstovall5 Well-Known Member

    3,156 Messages
    2,206 Likes Received
    I honestly don't think Moss in Oak was the same Moss in Min. It seemed like Moss didn't want to be in Oakland, and we all know how that works out ... And if I'm not mistaken he was injured most of his time there.
  17. nickjamesw43

    nickjamesw43 Well-Known Member

    573 Messages
    332 Likes Received
    Culpepper actually had his MVP season largely without Moss. Moss only had 767 yards that year and was hampered by injuries. For comparison Culpepper threw for 4717 yards 39 tds and 11 ints.

    He was a good QB for about three years. His sophomore season in 2000 was excellent. He was bad 2001 and 2002. Then 2003 and 2004 he was elite again before falling off a cliff. My suspicion is the knee injury was a much bigger factor then the departure of Moss.
  18. Gameover

    Gameover Well-Known Member

    6,061 Messages
    1,919 Likes Received
    Great post!
  19. noshame

    noshame I'm not dead yet...... Zone Supporter

    5,431 Messages
    2,644 Likes Received
    When your QB's passes travel less than ten yds to get to the receiver, while others are throwing deep stuff on a regular basis, it's easy to look grand on the stat sheet.
  20. RXP

    RXP Well-Known Member

    6,631 Messages
    6,019 Likes Received
    So who's throwing deep stuff on a regular basis. Romo has one of the highest career YPA in history.

    Every team throws lots of short stuff. The idea that Romo dinks and dunks while everybody else heaves it deep in simply incorrect.

Share This Page