Twitter: Mike Peirera believes Cruz TD catch was incomplete

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by blindzebra, Sep 11, 2013.

  1. blindzebra

    blindzebra Well-Known Member

    10,475 Messages
    2,031 Likes Received
     
    mullet and koolaid like this.
  2. jimnabby

    jimnabby Well-Known Member Zone Supporter

    5,826 Messages
    2,896 Likes Received
    I was screaming about that one when it happened. Couldn't believe it didn't get a more thorough review.
     
  3. danielofthesaints

    danielofthesaints Well-Known Member

    1,133 Messages
    263 Likes Received
    So Mike P. contradicts his previous tweet about this matter, interesting.
     
  4. blindzebra

    blindzebra Well-Known Member

    10,475 Messages
    2,031 Likes Received
    He was hit with lots of tweets so he took a second look...and in another tweet he said the league office confirmed it was a bad call.
     
  5. Idgit

    Idgit If you food, you gonna be ate. Staff Member

    45,731 Messages
    31,662 Likes Received
    Here're the two plays, one after the other.

    The answer to the question at the end of the clip is 'because Cruz plays for the Giants.'

     
  6. whynot

    whynot Well-Known Member

    229 Messages
    275 Likes Received
    Coach can't challenge a scoring play anymore either.
     
  7. Texas_Pete

    Texas_Pete Well-Known Member

    3,803 Messages
    4,758 Likes Received
    That rule should be changed.
     
  8. Ultra Warrior

    Ultra Warrior 6 Million Light-years beyond believability.

    2,363 Messages
    1,286 Likes Received
    The play would have still resulted in a 1st down & goal at the1. ( or less ) Chances are, they were punching it in anyway.
     
  9. Iago33

    Iago33 Well-Known Member

    1,715 Messages
    293 Likes Received
    How does an incomplete pass result in a first down?
     
  10. tupperware

    tupperware A Plastic Container

    7,269 Messages
    93 Likes Received
    Well, it's hard to argue with a former head of officiating, but I thought otherwise.
    NFL really needs to work on the consistency of their calls.
     
  11. Cowboys22

    Cowboys22 Well-Known Member

    5,584 Messages
    2,774 Likes Received
    No, it should have been incomplete. The league did not say he was down before crossing the goal line. He did not complete the catch because the ball came out of his hand went it hit the turf. The rule now it that you must maintain possession of the ball if you go to the ground as part of the play. He did and the ball came out. Incomplete pass.
     
    DCBoysfan likes this.
  12. Vertigo_17

    Vertigo_17 Well-Known Member

    2,277 Messages
    55 Likes Received
    Thought it was incomplete too, surprised that they didn't even appear to review it and I thought all scoring plays were supposed to be reviewed.

    We won the game, guess it doesn't matter but consistency would be nice. Not even going to get into the salsa dancing celebrations...
     
  13. aikemirv

    aikemirv Well-Known Member

    8,195 Messages
    997 Likes Received
    I think there is a difference between CJ and Cruz catches. I dont think Cruz was going to the ground on the catch. I think he got 2 feet established and then was tackled down. I don't think he was necessarily going to the ground with the cacth like CJ was.

    If that was a Cowboy, I would be livid if they had called that incomplete. The blatant hold on the play though.... that should have been called!
     
    bsheeern likes this.
  14. visionary

    visionary Well-Known Member

    11,705 Messages
    6,757 Likes Received

    exactly
    and the giants also had a first down and goal at the1 after the interception, hw did that work out for them?
     
    treykin32 likes this.
  15. JohnsKey19

    JohnsKey19 Well-Known Member

    10,545 Messages
    4,118 Likes Received
    I initially thought he established possession with 2 feet hitting the ground first as the tackle carried him to the ground. Wow,wasn't that a 3rd down? Could've potentially been a huge blown call.
     
  16. Zordon

    Zordon Well-Known Member

    14,347 Messages
    14,831 Likes Received
    these zebras are screwing up something every week.
     
  17. WoodysGirl

    WoodysGirl U.N.I.T.Y Staff Member

    74,283 Messages
    23,347 Likes Received
    Well, it was changed because all scoring plays are supposed to be reviewed.
     
    Texas_Pete likes this.
  18. Cowboys22

    Cowboys22 Well-Known Member

    5,584 Messages
    2,774 Likes Received
    Not true. He was clearly going to the ground before he established possession of the ball. He only got one foot down so he didn't establish possession until his arm hit the ground. Obviously at that point he is heading to the ground and must maintain possession of the ball throughout the entire process. The problem with the rule is that it doesn't pass the eye test. It clearly looks like a catch and a TD and most would agree it should be but the rule as in place at the moment says incomplete pass.
     
  19. Cowboys22

    Cowboys22 Well-Known Member

    5,584 Messages
    2,774 Likes Received
    No, the replay officials in the Dallas game botched it. The rule is still the same as evidenced by CJs TD being overturned and the league confirming today that Cruz's TD should have been ruled incomplete.
     
  20. big dog cowboy

    big dog cowboy THE BIG DOG Staff Member

    68,056 Messages
    24,628 Likes Received
    So much for home field advantage.
     

Share This Page