Twitter: Jason Garrett Update - Giants offensive rankings

[Zman5]

When you look at em it's blurry, but if you squint you can make out McCarthy a little better.

Are you saying MM is fat?

 

[DFWJC]

Worse decision: Splitting with Jimmy or giving the keys to Garrett for a decade?

I'd argue the latter. Handicapping a generation of talented players with this level of coaching is easily Jerry's worst decision.

Jimmy was leaving regardless......so staying with Garrett wins by default!

 

[Stash]

Worse decision: Splitting with Jimmy or giving the keys to Garrett for a decade?

I'd argue the latter. Handicapping a generation of talented players with this level of coaching is easily Jerry's worst decision.

There can no longer be a shadow of a doubt.

 

[Vanilla2]

They have too much talent to be THAT bad

Do they? They got some shiny pieces but the o line is bad and the guy pulling the trigger isn’t much more than a fancy nickname. I hope they see themselves the way you see them for our sake.

 

[Plankton]

 

[Blake]

Some of us saw that. Others saw the next Tom Landry.

Some even convinced themselves that X’s and O’s mean nothing and we just need better players as if coaching and game plans didn’t matter and allowing the other team to basically know our every move was ok.

I wanted him to be the next Landry, but following 2016 season of getting bounced once again from playoffs with a 13-3 squad; it was evident he needed to go. Dak’s first couple of years of development as the starter should’ve been with a different coach.

 

[TequilaCowboy]

Worse decision: Splitting with Jimmy or giving the keys to Garrett for a decade?

I'd argue the latter. Handicapping a generation of talented players with this level of coaching is easily Jerry's worst decision.

I find it difficult to place either stupid decision over the other. They both have given us this Cowboy nuclear winter for the number of years everyone knows. It all comes down to the ego and stubbornness of this man. Amazing how it has been the most financially rewarding for him in his life and at the same time the most disappointing and nightmarish for the fans.

 

[Zman5]

Danny Dimes looked so bad last Sunday. Worst I've seen him play. That should end the "JG is a QB guru and an offensive genius" BS.

 

[Easyout66]

He's better than MM on many eyes! Lol

He will never work on the sidelines in any professional capacity, he's a snake charmer who talks himself into jobs where he's completely in over his head, then talks his way out of getting fired in end of season meetings, his post game interviews with media should have been a total red flag exposing his limitations, he could talk endlessly with no finer points or bring any kind of clarity on the question at hand, he's been nothing but a total fraud... And as a fan waiting every off-season for Jerry to pull the plug on this horrible hire only to wait year after year watching this chump fail miserably has been a pure joy, really hoping he can some how buy himself another year at NY Giants OC, and watch Giants fans storm the front office compound would be a thing of beauty

 

[Redline360]

I still blame Romo for carrying his *** all those years lol

 

[ICP]

Ugg, why do I keep seeing this clown's name on this board? WHO CARES what he does good or bad, can't we just move on?!?!

 

[ShortRound]

They are both huge decisions Jerry is to blame for. Wasting Romo, Witten, Dez, etc on Garrett? Ooof.

 

[The Quest for Six]

I Just didn't understand the Jason Garrett hire in New York after tens years playing against his offense that was so predictable....

I think the Giants are cleaning house after this season from the GM down

 

[Jake]

Garrett's Garrett and I'm glad he's gone, but their offensive line is trash and Barkley has missed all but 3 or 4 games.

Even a creative OC wouldn't do much with that bunch.

 

[CATCH17]

I wanted him to be the next Landry, but following 2016 season of getting bounced once again from playoffs with a 13-3 squad; it was evident he needed to go. Dak’s first couple of years of development as the starter should’ve been with a different coach.

I knew long ago we weren’t getting any help from the coach.

Romo was asked to do far too much while he was here.

They drafted a great Oline so scheme became less important and they had a group of guys that could impose their will on defenses and overcome the lack of coaching.


I’ve just never seen a guy call a game with such an ego. You have guys like Phil Costa in your starting lineup and you just abandon the short passing game and have these long slow developing plays.

Garrett was a mess and the guy would just always fail up with Jerry in charge.

 

[reddyuta]

I think Jerry is attracted to dumb HCs who he can boss around,thats why he got rid of Jimmy and hired Garrett and Mccarthy.

 

[visionary]

Garrett hands down no question

total garbage

 

[Plankton]

I Just didn't understand the Jason Garrett hire in New York after tens years playing against his offense that was so predictable....

I think the Giants are cleaning house after this season from the GM down

The Giants have trended toward hiring people that they are familiar with for years. Gettleman was a top lieutenant of Ernie Accorsi. So was Jerry Reese before him. Accorsi came on board to work under George Young in his later years as the GM. Garrett played for the team, and is a friend of the Mara family.

 

[BBGTYCOON]

The reason I disagree - Jimmy wanted out too and the salary cap was going to hinder our ability to maintain those teams.

Consider this: Jason Taylor, Zack Thomas, Daryl Gardner, Sam Madison, Patrick Surtain were all DRAFTED on Jimmy's watch. He was already primed for roster building in the free agent Era, he was Belichick minus the cheating.

 

[ShortRound]

to be fair, the Giants have been a hotmess for awhile now, before Garrett got there. I don't know WHY they hired him.