Jesse Holley lays out why Blue and Milton got the ax

Bobhaze

Staff member
Messages
22,252
Reaction score
93,997
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan

Jessie Holley lays it all out there. Coach Schottenheimer expects professionalism from every player, every day.

In other words, it’s not just how fast, athletic, or how big your arm is…it’s about bringing your lunch pail every day to practice, being on time, and showing a commitment to the film room, and being committed to being a true professional.

If true, Schotty is setting a good standard. And also reminding us fans that what we see in a PS game or TC practice is not everything the coaches are looking at.
 

Jessie Holley lays it all out there. Coach Schottenheimer expects professionalism from every player, every day.

In other words, it’s not just how fast, athletic, or how big your arm is…it’s about bringing your lunch pail every day to practice, being on time, and showing a commitment to the film room, and being committed to being a true professional.

If true, Schotty is setting a good standard.

Milton is back with the team...
 
In other words, it’s not just how fast, athletic, or how big your arm is…it’s about bringing your lunch pail every day to practice, being on time, and showing a commitment to the film room, and being committed to being a true professional.
Yep. This time, I agree with Holley. Professionalism. Consistency. Accountability. Adulthood. We don’t have time for anything less.

Things have changed in Dallas. Schotty is setting expectations, holding players accountable, and demanding that everyone live up to them. And honestly, it’s about damn time.
 
Milton and Blue are not the same.

They didn't even want Blue on the practice squad.
Agreed. But they also chose not to make Milton the backup QB and were willing to risk losing him to another team. However you choose to slice it, a message was sent - he still has a ways to go.

Nothing against Milton at all. But I don’t see how anyone can say this team didn’t send a message to him.

And in a league starved for even decent QB play, not a single other NFL team wanted him? That says something too X.
 
Yep. This time, I agree with Holley. Professionalism. Consistency. Accountability. Adulthood. We don’t have time for anything less.

Things have changed in Dallas. Schotty is setting expectations, holding players accountable, and demanding that everyone live up to them. And honestly, it’s about damn time.
I like this approach.

But I will say “things have changed” when it’s reflected consistently on the scoreboard. This team looks so much better than last year, for sure.

The difference between “looks better” and “is better” happens between Sept 13th through the end of the season. Until then, I will just say “looks better”.
 

Jessie Holley lays it all out there. Coach Schottenheimer expects professionalism from every player, every day.

In other words, it’s not just how fast, athletic, or how big your arm is…it’s about bringing your lunch pail every day to practice, being on time, and showing a commitment to the film room, and being committed to being a true professional.

If true, Schotty is setting a good standard. And also reminding us fans that what we see in a PS game or TC practice is not everything the coaches are looking at.

Jesse is a firsthand expert on mediocrity.
 

Jessie Holley lays it all out there. Coach Schottenheimer expects professionalism from every player, every day.

In other words, it’s not just how fast, athletic, or how big your arm is…it’s about bringing your lunch pail every day to practice, being on time, and showing a commitment to the film room, and being committed to being a true professional.

If true, Schotty is setting a good standard. And also reminding us fans that what we see in a PS game or TC practice is not everything the coaches are looking at.

Thank you Jessie for telling it like it is, some fans needed to hear this because they think people like me are delusional.

Sam is built for this offense better than milton is also i agree with.
 
Milton and Blue are not the same.

They didn't even want Blue on the practice squad.
They barely even wanted milton on the practice squad. Dallas wasnt kicking down his door while he was on the market. Milton came back because he had to. The coaches weren't losing any sleep over Milton.
 
I like this approach.

But I will say “things have changed” when it’s reflected consistently on the scoreboard. This team looks so much better than last year, for sure.

The difference between “looks better” and “is better” happens between Sept 13th through the end of the season. Until then, I will just say “looks better”.
Well that applies to all the teams not just Dallas. When fans are glazing the rams and seahawks, i am like whatever.
 
In other words, it’s not just how fast, athletic, or how big your arm is…it’s about bringing your lunch pail every day to practice, being on time, and showing a commitment to the film room, and being committed to being a true professional.

If true, Schotty is setting a good standard. And also reminding us fans that what we see in a PS game or TC practice is not everything the coaches are looking at.
This ^^^^^^
 
How do we know blue and milton weren't professional?
With Blue, it was pretty clear based on things Schotty said last year that he had to work on. The word “immature” was used by someone too.

Blue probably has 2nd-3rd round talent in some areas of his game. But the reason he lasted to round 5 was the finer points of being a pro. Even his draft profile from the 2025 combine listed some of his weaknesses that hurt him a lot…here’s some excerpts from his nfl draft profile:

Overview​

Blue played behind very good backs, so his carry count is lower, but he clearly has talent. He’s a narrow-hipped, linear runner with good speed to threaten wide and attack downfield out of the backfield. He has adequate wiggle in the open field but lacks base strength to break tackles. Blue’s lack of tempo and vision inside gets him behind schedule and could limit how teams use him as a ball-carrier. While he can be labeled a “change-of-pace slasher,” his real value will revolve around his ability to mismatch linebackers and threaten defenses as a receiver out of the backfield.

Weaknesses​

  • Lacks tempo and processing quickness as a runner.
  • Runs too small inside and accepts the contact.
  • Fumble rate will be frowned upon.
  • Will have drops on off-frame throws.
  • Mental mistakes in protection caused sacks.
All of these weaknesses hurt him. That last bullet - his inability to pass block is a killer. A back who isn’t good at picking up blitzers won’t play. It’s that simple. Schotty isn’t going to risk the starting QBs backside to guy who can’t block.
 
With Blue, it was pretty clear based on things Schotty said last year that he had to work on. The word “immature” was used by someone too.

Blue probably has 2nd-3rd round talent in some areas of his game. But the reason he lasted to round 5 was the finer points of being a pro. Even his draft profile from the 2025 combine listed some of his weaknesses that hurt him a lot…here’s some excerpts from his nfl draft profile:

Overview​

Blue played behind very good backs, so his carry count is lower, but he clearly has talent. He’s a narrow-hipped, linear runner with good speed to threaten wide and attack downfield out of the backfield. He has adequate wiggle in the open field but lacks base strength to break tackles. Blue’s lack of tempo and vision inside gets him behind schedule and could limit how teams use him as a ball-carrier. While he can be labeled a “change-of-pace slasher,” his real value will revolve around his ability to mismatch linebackers and threaten defenses as a receiver out of the backfield.

Weaknesses​

  • Lacks tempo and processing quickness as a runner.
  • Runs too small inside and accepts the contact.
  • Fumble rate will be frowned upon.
  • Will have drops on off-frame throws.
  • Mental mistakes in protection caused sacks.
All of these weaknesses hurt him. That last bullet - his inability to pass block is a killer. A back who isn’t good at picking up blitzers won’t play. It’s that simple. Schotty isn’t going to risk the starting QBs backside to guy who can’t block.
Yeah its fairly well known at this point. Anyone paying attention knew Blue wasn't completely committed last year, and I suspect his approach improved this off season, but still wasn't enough to meet or exceed expectations.

I actually thought Milton was committed though. I don't recall any stories about him lacking work ethic or focus etc. Not saying its wrong, just that I hadn't seen or heard it reported.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
475,290
Messages
14,597,372
Members
24,217
Latest member
Cowboysforlyfe47
Back
Top