How Cowboys rank in terms of quarterback play in Super Bowl era

Hardline · Jun 26, 2020

The thread title should be this.

How the Cowboys rank in terms of quarterback play in the Super Bowl era

https://www.bloggingtheboys.com/202...rms-of-quarterback-play-in-the-super-bowl-era

darthseinfeld · Jun 26, 2020

Hardline said:
The thread title should be this.

How the Cowboys rank in terms of quarterback play in the Super Bowl era

https://www.bloggingtheboys.com/202...rms-of-quarterback-play-in-the-super-bowl-era

People complain about the period in between Aikman and Romo. I get it. But I live in Bills country, and they are still trying to replace Jim Kelly

John813 · Jun 26, 2020

darthseinfeld said:
People complain about the period in between Aikman and Romo. I get it. But I live in Bills country, and they are still trying to replace Jim Kelly

I live in Florida, and it's been almost two decades and probably 18 QB's since Marino last played for the Phins.

darthseinfeld · Jun 26, 2020

John813 said:
I live in Florida, and it's been almost two decades and probably 18 QB's since Marino last played for the Phins.

And they Jets are still trying to replace Testaverde lol

DallasInDC · Jun 26, 2020

darthseinfeld said:
People complain about the period in between Aikman and Romo. I get it. But I live in Bills country, and they are still trying to replace Jim Kelly

Agreed, while it was painful at the time, it was only 5 1/2 years between the two. That is not an unreasonable time frame given most teams go through multiple QBs or settle on mediocrity in that period of time.

leeblair · Jun 26, 2020

darthseinfeld said:
People complain about the period in between Aikman and Romo. I get it. But I live in Bills country, and they are still trying to replace Jim Kelly

John813 said:
I live in Florida, and it's been almost two decades and probably 18 QB's since Marino last played for the Phins.

darthseinfeld said:
And they Jets are still trying to replace Testaverde lol

Ever notice how quarterback success only comes when a team has a real head coach?
It's no coincidence.
Joe Gibbs even made Jay Schroeder and Mark Rypien look like starters.

ABQCOWBOY · Jun 26, 2020

DallasInDC said:
Agreed, while it was painful at the time, it was only 5 1/2 years between the two. That is not an unreasonable time frame given most teams go through multiple QBs or settle on mediocrity in that period of time.

And honestly, it may not have been that long if the organization had not put itself in such a terrible cap situation, draft situation by simply trying to hold on too long. Giving bloated contracts to aging stars, making bad trades for players, in an attempt to provide weapons to a lack luster offense, just poor management moves. It is what it is.

Whyjerry · Jun 26, 2020

If McCarthy can get this team fixed and go on a bit of run, the Romo era will not be treated well by history. Guy had one of the longest, least successful runs of any starting QB.

glimmerman · Jun 26, 2020

John813 said:
I live in Florida, and it's been almost two decades and probably 18 QB's since Marino last played for the Phins.

Same here, live in Florida. My family are all fins fans and they have been searching forever so they say. Had tannehill and let him go and now he just signed a huge contract and made the playoffs. Lol. Maybe it’s not your QB.

DFWJC · Jun 26, 2020

Whyjerry said:
If McCarthy can get this team fixed and go on a bit of run, the Romo era will not be treated well by history. Guy had one of the longest, least successful runs of any starting QB.

The hate runs deep in this one.

Super_Kazuya · Jun 26, 2020

DFWJC said:
The hate runs deep in this one.

lol, I was literally going to post the same thing. If McCarthy is the one who fixes it, shouldn’t it be the Garrett era that isn’t treated well? We need smarter trolls here.

Captain-Crash · Jun 26, 2020

if we can get dak to beat an average to good defense we might get somewhere. "if" or hope he gets hurt and dalton takes us to the Superbowl and wins it all.

DFWJC · Jun 26, 2020

Super_Kazuya said:
lol, I was literally going to post the same thing. If McCarthy is the one who fixes it, shouldn’t it be the Garrett era that isn’t treated well? We need smarter trolls here.

Yeah, I almost said more. I suspect the irony of his post escapes him.

DFWJC · Jun 26, 2020

Hardline said:
The thread title should be this.

How the Cowboys rank in terms of quarterback play in the Super Bowl era

https://www.bloggingtheboys.com/202...rms-of-quarterback-play-in-the-super-bowl-era

Although Pro Bowl are a terrible indicator--especially for QBs (see 2018 Pro Bowler Mitch Trubisky) I think they may've given us more than we really got.
Not that it matters

Now All-Pro is a totally different level (only 2 in the entire league make it)

I think the Pro Bowls are:

6--Staubach, (Plus 1 All-Pro)
6--Aikman
4--Romo, (Plus 1 All-Pro)
3--Merideth, (Plus 1 All Pro)
2--Prescott
1--White

Whyjerry · Jun 26, 2020

DFWJC said:
The hate runs deep in this one.

Hate?

You know the saying “don’t hate the mirror because you are ugly...”?

I don’t hate Romo at all. Good player but he won nothing in over a decade. It’s a fact. Biggest game of his life and he takes off to Mexico to rattle the bed posts with Jessica Simpson. Now I don’t blame him for that but he could have done that any old time. I am considering doing a analysis of QBs with over 100 starts and playoff experience. I suspect Romo is going to look like crap. Guy lead a ten plus year run of mediocrity.

DFWJC · Jun 26, 2020

Whyjerry said:
Hate?

You know the saying “don’t hate the mirror because you are ugly...”?

I don’t hate Romo at all. Good player but he won nothing in over a decade. It’s a fact. Biggest game of his life and he takes off to Mexico to rattle the bed posts with Jessica Simpson. Now I don’t blame him for that but he could have done that any old time. I am considering doing a analysis of QBs with over 100 starts and playoff experience. I suspect Romo is going to look like crap. Guy lead a ten plus year run of mediocrity.

Short Bus is waiting.

The fact that went to straight to a brain dead idea like Cabo mattered ...at all...speaks volumes. I hope you reserve those feeling for Witten too then.
Two week off, facilities closed, told to get out away from it all to reboot by the coaching staff. Goes for a few days with his girlfriend--who complains all he did was talk football with Witten. Meanwhile half the team his hitting strip bars, going to Vegas or Miami, etc....but somehow Cabo is only thing mentioned. All back for a full week of practice before the game too.

You are consistently making disparaging comments about Tony...and often unrelated to the thread.

Whyjerry · Jun 26, 2020

DFWJC said:
Short Bus is waiting.

The fact that went to straight to a brain dead idea like Cabo mattered ...at all...speaks volumes. I hope you reserve those feeling for Witten too then.
Two week off, facilities closed, told to get out away from it all to reboot by the coaching staff. Goes for a few days with his girlfriend--who complains all he did was talk football with Witten. Meanwhile half the team his hitting strip bars, going to Vegas or Miami, etc....but somehow Cabo is only thing mentioned. All back for a full week of practice before the game too.

You are consistently making disparaging comments about Tony...and often unrelated to the thread.

I liked Tony. Just honest about his lack of success. I am sure he appreciates your slobbering admiration.

How Cowboys rank in terms of quarterback play in Super Bowl era

Hardline

Well-Known Member

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru

John813

Well-Known Member

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru

DallasInDC

Well-Known Member

leeblair

Well-Known Member

ABQCOWBOY

Regular Joe....

Whyjerry

Well-Known Member

glimmerman

Well-Known Member

DFWJC

Well-Known Member

Super_Kazuya

Well-Known Member

Captain-Crash

Well-Known Member

DFWJC

Well-Known Member

DFWJC

Well-Known Member

Whyjerry

Well-Known Member

DFWJC

Well-Known Member

Whyjerry

Well-Known Member