CFZ Sometimes the Guy Calling Plays Gets in the Way

Chuck 54

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,052
Reaction score
12,026
How many times over the last decade + have we seen the various offensive coordinators struggle to move the offense, but then when Romo or Dak went to the hurry up, calling their own plays, suddenly both QBs were more successful and the offense scores?

Often, under Garrett and Linehan, we would say maybe Romo should just stay in the hurry up and call his own plays all game? I see much of the same thing from Dak, even in the first half during the hurry up.

Obviously, no one is going to the hurry up with the QB calling his own plays, but think about it. Romo knew what plays he was most comfortable with during the game vs whatever the defense was doing at the time. Dak seems to have great success the same way, calling and even changing calls at times to his plays.

My only point is this. Forget that Romo often frustrated the heck out of us in big games or with turnovers. Forget that Dak did not play well consistently yesterday. Maybe when you have a genius play designer, that guy falls in love with his play designs (we often hear announcers call them great designs) but forgets what his QB and receivers do best.

Can you imagine Norv Turner falling so in love with his X’s and O’s that in big situations or third downs, he tries to outwit the defensive coordinator instead of letting Aikman and Irvin go to the short slant or quick out?
Maybe we don’t need a boy genius.

Maybe we need an experienced run game coordinator who can design our run game to fit our OL and RBs and a play-caller who also takes into consideration what our receivers and QB do best. Maybe if we want more consistency on offense, just maybe it’s not all about just the X’s and O’s.
 

Kingofholland

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,901
Reaction score
6,317
How many times over the last decade + have we seen the various offensive coordinators struggle to move the offense, but then when Romo or Dak went to the hurry up, calling their own plays, suddenly both QBs were more successful and the offense scores?

Often, under Garrett and Linehan, we would say maybe Romo should just stay in the hurry up and call his own plays all game? I see much of the same thing from Dak, even in the first half during the hurry up.

Obviously, no one is going to the hurry up with the QB calling his own plays, but think about it. Romo knew what plays he was most comfortable with during the game vs whatever the defense was doing at the time. Dak seems to have great success the same way, calling and even changing calls at times to his plays.

My only point is this. Forget that Romo often frustrated the heck out of us in big games or with turnovers. Forget that Dak did not play well consistently yesterday. Maybe when you have a genius play designer, that guy falls in love with his play designs (we often hear announcers call them great designs) but forgets what his QB and receivers do best.

Can you imagine Norv Turner falling so in love with his X’s and O’s that in big situations or third downs, he tries to outwit the defensive coordinator instead of letting Aikman and Irvin go to the short slant or quick out?
Maybe we don’t need a boy genius.

Maybe we need an experienced run game coordinator who can design our run game to fit our OL and RBs and a play-caller who also takes into consideration what our receivers and QB do best. Maybe if we want more consistency on offense, just maybe it’s not all about just the X’s and O’s.

This offense hums in the hurry up and don't know why we don't mix in a few drives a game where we're going hurry up. I get that you can't run it every time because you can tire out your defense if it doesn't work, but we do this way too late.

Also for the many that think Moore is a genius play designer I don't know how true that is. Respectable opposing defenses usually seem ready for our plays. Maybe it is Moore trying to out think the defense, but the 1 long drive yesterday incorporated things Moore doesn't regularly do. Run in back to back plays.
 

ChronicCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,850
Reaction score
14,320
Tony got really good at running the offense with minimal help from the sidelines. I don’t think Dak has shown the same ability.
 

Chuck 54

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,052
Reaction score
12,026
Tony got really good at running the offense with minimal help from the sidelines. I don’t think Dak has shown the same ability.
Probably not yet, but my real point wasn’t that either Or any QB should call his own plays. My point is that the coordinator should call the plays the receivers run well and the QB plays well, even if it’s predictable, like the Aikman to Irvin slant on 3rd down. I don’t think 3rd down is the time for novelty and trickery, but the time for confidence from the line, the RB, the QB, and the receivers.
 
Top