Beware of counting out the Re-tread coach

armadillooutlaw · Jan 12, 2020

Look at Andy Reid. He had a long, successful run in Philadelphia that, of course, had a very ugly end. 4-12. Averaged under 20 points a game on offense. Stale. You name it.
Then he goes to Kansas City and has obviously added some fresh material to his offense. He's on his sixth playoff trip in seven years with the Chiefs and now his second straight AFC Championship game appearance.
Certainly Philly fans thought he was no good. A lot like how some Green Bay fans view McCarthy.
Don't be shocked if McCarthy ends up having new life with a new team like Reid did...

nightrain · Jan 12, 2020

armadillooutlaw said:
Look at Andy Reid. He had a long, successful run in Philadelphia that, of course, had a very ugly end. 4-12. Averaged under 20 points a game on offense. Stale. You name it.
Then he goes to Kansas City and has obviously added some fresh material to his offense. He's on his sixth playoff trip in seven years with the Chiefs and now his second straight AFC Championship game appearance.
Certainly Philly fans thought he was no good. A lot like how some Green Bay fans view McCarthy.
Don't be shocked if McCarthy ends up having new life with a new team like Reid did...

Shocked? I fully expect McCarthy to take the Cowboys to new heights.

armadillooutlaw · Jan 12, 2020

nightrain said:
Shocked? I fully expect McCarthy to take the Cowboys to new heights.

Same here. Watching Reid and the Chiefs win just made me think of some of the folks that are more reserved when it comes to the idea of McCarthy, as a reason for optimism.

big dog cowboy · Jan 12, 2020

McCarthy will win multiple Super Bowls with the Cowboys.

Book it!

BigTimeBlues · Jan 12, 2020

Andy Reid is essentially always done this. He's got several NFFCG wins and has even been to the big dance once. Not a surprise, to me at least, that he's making an AFCCG appearance.

armadillooutlaw · Jan 12, 2020

big dog cowboy said:
McCarthy will win multiple Super Bowls with the Cowboys.

Book it!

Nobody is saying that.
Just saying that a retread coach isn't necessarily a bad thing.

armadillooutlaw · Jan 12, 2020

BigTimeBlues said:
Andy Reid is essentially always done this. He's got several NFFCG wins and has even been to the big dance once. Not a surprise, to me at least, that he's making an AFCCG appearance.

Right on.
Also, I don't remember anyone discounting his success because he had the likes of McNabb and Westbrook, Brian Dawkins, ect.
Or Mahomes for that matter.

Jake · Jan 12, 2020

big dog cowboy said:
McCarthy will win multiple Super Bowls with the Cowboys.

Book it!

Booked.

morat1959 · Jan 12, 2020

MM and staff are way better than what we had. That being said, Reid’s got Mohomes. MM has Dak. End of discussion based on your analysis.

cowboyec · Jan 12, 2020

he's a helluva coach and feels like he's got something to prove.
i like talent thats pissed.

CATCH17 · Jan 12, 2020

morat1959 said:
MM and staff are way better than what we had. That being said, Reid’s got Mohomes. MM has Dak. End of discussion based on your analysis.

Its amazing to me how people want to ignore the type of QBs these guys have and not factor it into their success.

Andy Reid can make just about anyone play QB at a decent level in this league.

EST_1986 · Jan 12, 2020

nightrain said:
Shocked? I fully expect McCarthy to take the Cowboys to new heights.

Coming from Garrett that’s not a hard accomplishment but I expect to not look like an undercoached high school team for sure

Oz-of-Cowboy-Country · Jan 12, 2020

A new head coach is like a draft pick. You never know what you have in them until they've been here for three full seasons.

amame25 · Jan 12, 2020

big dog cowboy said:
McCarthy will win multiple Super Bowls with the Cowboys.

Book it!

He'd be the first. No other coach has won the Superbowl with multiple teams.

Bigdog · Jan 12, 2020

armadillooutlaw said:
Look at Andy Reid. He had a long, successful run in Philadelphia that, of course, had a very ugly end. 4-12. Averaged under 20 points a game on offense. Stale. You name it.
Then he goes to Kansas City and has obviously added some fresh material to his offense. He's on his sixth playoff trip in seven years with the Chiefs and now his second straight AFC Championship game appearance.
Certainly Philly fans thought he was no good. A lot like how some Green Bay fans view McCarthy.
Don't be shocked if McCarthy ends up having new life with a new team like Reid did...

Hope you’re right. Love to add to our SB case.

shabazz · Jan 12, 2020

Oz-of-Cowboy-Country said:
A new head coach is like a draft pick. You never know what you have in them until they've been here for three full seasons.

Very true, but in McCarthy we have a known entity. He can go to the house with talent. The question is can he do it with this “talent”?

CATCH17 · Jan 12, 2020

shabazz said:
Very true, but in McCarthy we have a known entity. He can go to the house with talent. The question is can he do it with this “talent”?

Or without Rodgers who looks like he’s headed back to a NFC championship.

Makes you wonder if Cowboys fans are giving McCarthy too much credit for GBs success.. Hmmmm

irishline · Jan 12, 2020

armadillooutlaw said:
Don't be shocked if McCarthy ends up having new life with a new team like Reid did...

Bill Belichick is a re-tread coach after going 36-44 over 5 years with the Browns (and only 1 winning season). So I completely agree anything is possible...

baltcowboy · Jan 12, 2020

armadillooutlaw said:
Look at Andy Reid. He had a long, successful run in Philadelphia that, of course, had a very ugly end. 4-12. Averaged under 20 points a game on offense. Stale. You name it.
Then he goes to Kansas City and has obviously added some fresh material to his offense. He's on his sixth playoff trip in seven years with the Chiefs and now his second straight AFC Championship game appearance.
Certainly Philly fans thought he was no good. A lot like how some Green Bay fans view McCarthy.
Don't be shocked if McCarthy ends up having new life with a new team like Reid did...

McCarthy was better with Green Bay then Reid was in Philthy.

xwalker · Jan 12, 2020

armadillooutlaw said:
Look at Andy Reid. He had a long, successful run in Philadelphia that, of course, had a very ugly end. 4-12. Averaged under 20 points a game on offense. Stale. You name it.
Then he goes to Kansas City and has obviously added some fresh material to his offense. He's on his sixth playoff trip in seven years with the Chiefs and now his second straight AFC Championship game appearance.
Certainly Philly fans thought he was no good. A lot like how some Green Bay fans view McCarthy.
Don't be shocked if McCarthy ends up having new life with a new team like Reid did...

Belichick had been a Head Coach before he was hired by the Pats...

Beware of counting out the Re-tread coach

Well-Known Member

Since 1971

Well-Known Member

THE BIG DOG

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Beyond tired of Jerry

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

1st Round Pick

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

1st Round Pick

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member