CFZ Cowboys consistently good - the McCarthy effect

Jumbo075

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,042
Reaction score
7,535
For the first time since Jimmy Johnson's teams, the Cowboys have become consistently good under Head Coach Mike McCarthy. Of course, Landry fielded consistently good teams for 20 straight years. So, at this point, you have to consider that McCarthy is ascending to the same class of both Johnson and Landry when it comes to Cowboys' head coaches. Also, like both Landry and Johnson, McCarthy is a Super Bowl winning QB. But he still hasn't taken that next step with the Cowboys.

My hope is that the front office and fans will not become impatient with McCarthy. We haven't seen a team that was this consistently good in nearly 30 years. With the departure of Kellen Moore, it seems that Dak has taken the next step up as a QB. It took a few weeks into the season, but since the bye week, the Cowboys offense has been on fire, and Dak has played like the best QB in the NFL - and that includes the 49ers phenom Brock Purdy, who may follow in the footsteps of undrafted Kurt Warner, and late round pick Tom Brady on his way to becoming one of the better QB's in the NFL. But Purdy has not yet been able to bring his team from behind, while Dak has many, many 4th quarter and overtime comeback wins on his resume. Under the tutelage of McCarthy, who coaches HOF QB's like Montana, Young, Favre and Rodgers, Dak seems to be playing at a higher level than at any other time in his career.

This is not meant as a knock on Kellen Moore, who I believe may still be on track to becoming an NFL head coach some day. But McCarthy has done it longer and better than Moore. McCarthy is showing why he should be kept as the long-term head coach of the Cowboys. This level of consistent winning doesn't happen by accident. Jason Garrett enjoyed consistently good drafts by the Cowboys, but was unable to mold that talent into a team that won consistently. In fact, it appears that Garrett was more often than not bailed out by Tony Romo. You have to wonder if Romo would have had a more decorated career under a coach like McCarthy.

Let's be honest. Right now, the 49ers look like a juggernaut headed for Super Bowl glory. So, the Cowboys may well fall short again this year. But every team is striving to be the best, not just the Cowboys. And for the first time in decades, the Cowboys have become consistently good. They may yet prove that the early season losses were an anomaly and show that they can compete with and win against the Eagles and maybe even the 49ers in the playoffs. But, if they don't, that is still not a reason to cut ties with McCarthy. He's taking this team to the next level. You can see the development right before your eyes, if you are paying attention.

I believe the Cowboys, Eagles and 49ers are the class of the NFC. The Lions are on the rise also. Meanwhile, the Chiefs appear to be taking a step back after 5 consecutive seasons of domination in the AFC, and the NFL as a whole. We don't yet know which other teams will step up in the AFC, but Miami, Baltimore, and Jacksonville all seem to be on track to challenge the Chiefs this year, while teams like the Bengals and Bills seem to have fallen back into the pack. The Cowboys, given the right events, could become champions again this season. So, this is not an attempt to excuse them ahead of time for any future losses. But honesty compels one to admit that right now, until proven otherwise, the 49ers and Eagles seem to be a bit ahead of the 'Boys. Nevertheless, becoming a consistently good team that has double digit wins year in and year out is a HUGE step forward for a team that has been mired in mediocrity for longer than Tom Landry was coach of the team. Let's not allow that to get lost, no matter what happens the rest of the year.

I believe the Cowboys have finally laid the foundation to become a great team. Do they have the edifice of a great team, yet? I don't know. The 2001 Patriots were not yet a great team, but won the Super Bowl anyway. The Cowboys can do that this year. The Patriots became a great team AFTER winning their first Super Bowl. And the Cowboys can become a great team by building on the success of this year, and the past two seasons. I certainly hope they do it like the Patriots - starting off their greatness with an unexpected Super Bowl win. But I hope that regardless of what happens, the Cowboys allow Mike McCarthy to continue to build on what he's accomplished so far in Dallas.
 

links18

Well-Known Member
Messages
24,238
Reaction score
19,984
How long are we going to have to wait to get the penalty fest cleaned up?
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,486
Reaction score
94,760
Seems like spiking the ball before you reach the endzone.

We are going to learn a ton about this team over the next month - Philly, Buffalo, Miami and Detroit are all good teams and teams that we typically lose to more often than not. Seems premature to talk about we are consistent winners when in reality we've gotten good at beating bad teams but more often that not spit the bit against the good teams. If they do something like go 1-3 during that stretch, it's going to be hard to try to continue to make that case.

Willie is gonna laugh because we keep talking about this but if this team limps home in December and gets bounced in the playoffs early again, I see no point in bringing McCarthy back.
 

ICP

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,076
Reaction score
3,816
Imagine what the possibilities could have been if they wouldn't have wasted 10 years with the clapping idiot
 

Pompey-Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,994
Reaction score
3,563
Seems like spiking the ball before you reach the endzone.

We are going to learn a ton about this team over the next month - Philly, Buffalo, Miami and Detroit are all good teams and teams that we typically lose to more often than not. Seems premature to talk about we are consistent winners when in reality we've gotten good at beating bad teams but more often that not spit the bit against the good teams. If they do something like go 1-3 during that stretch, it's going to be hard to try to continue to make that case.

Willie is gonna laugh because we keep talking about this but if this team limps home in December and gets bounced in the playoffs early again, I see no point in bringing McCarthy back.
Head to head,

Lions 16 & 11
Bills 6 & 5
Eagles 70 & 55
Dolphins 7 & 7.

We don't " typically lose" to any of those teams.
 

Jake

Beyond tired of Jerry
Messages
36,067
Reaction score
84,351
"Consistently good" isn't a bad thing, but win something in the postseason, please.
 
Top