Dak Top 6 in QB Tiers this week, but not Top 3

[Yobwocs]

I call a revote.

How is he not Top 3? Burrow thru 2 back-to-back INTs against the Texans and his offense stagnated for 2 and a half quarters before a few late big plays and the Tight End got all the blame for that drop, yet it was Burrow who put them in that position in the first place.

This has been an ongoing thing all year..... their offense didn't do much against Seattle either, just Geno couldn't get the ball in the endzone.

I think Dak should be Top 3.

 

[5Stars]

Poor Dak...he should be #1. He never gets any respect.

 

[Fontaine]

Can we pump the brakes on Stroud a bit. I understand he’s playing good, but let’s give the kid a full season before we pop him into the top 3.

 

[zeke21]

Can we pump the brakes on Stroud a bit. I understand he’s playing good, but let’s give the kid a full season before we pop him into the top 3.

I take it you haven't watched him play yet?

I realise we tend to overhype some rookies but his is playing really well.. in a crap team. Great footwork, great pocket awareness. Stroud is making all the throws.. full play book and making his whole offence look better. This isn't Dak driving a bus behind the leagues best OLine with Zeke running for 120 every game. Stroud is legit almost a one man offence right now and making it look easy.

Very early call but Stroud is real deal and I would happily have him in that top tier.

 

[Hawkeye0202]

Can we pump the brakes on Stroud a bit. I understand he’s playing good, but let’s give the kid a full season before we pop him into the top 3.

See what you saying but he's balling and taking the team on his shoulders. In other words, see if you can name one of his WRs in 5 seconds (LOL).

 

[Hawkeye0202]

I take it you haven't watched him play yet?

I realise we tend to overhype some rookies but his is playing really well.. in a crap team. Great footwork, great pocket awareness. Stroud is making all the throws.. full play book and making his whole offence look better. This isn't Dak driving a bus behind the leagues best OLine with Zeke running for 120 every game. Stroud is legit almost a one man offence right now and making it look easy.

Very early call but Stroud is real deal and I would happily have him in that top tier.

Exactly........ watched him for the first time Sunday. Man-O-Man, love his arm.......John Elway type throws IMO. Like you said, it's early but he has my attention.

 

[Yobwocs]

This isn't Dak driving a bus behind the leagues best OLine with Zeke running for 120 every game. Stroud is legit almost a one man offence right now and making it look easy.

Very early call but Stroud is real deal and I would happily have him in that top tier.

You don't need to diss Dak to praise Stroud

 

[Jarntt]

It's one persons list. You can do "Yobwocs" list and put him in

 

[Redsfan_83]

Can we pump the brakes on Stroud a bit. I understand he’s playing good, but let’s give the kid a full season before we pop him into the top 3.

As much as I may agree with you, this kid is something else. He is poised like a Vet, dead eye accurate and a cannon of an arm. All this, and I dare you to give me the name of 3 Texans on the offensive side of the ball. What he's doing is simply remarkable, and I don't think it's a fluke

 

[big dog cowboy]

How could he not be #1 when "Dak an already an All Time Great Cowboys QB" or so I read.

 

[JayFord]

im tired boss

slot him wherever just win baby

 

[Motorola]

I call a revote.

How is he not Top 3? Burrow thru 2 back-to-back INTs against the Texans and his offense stagnated for 2 and a half quarters before a few late big plays and the Tight End got all the blame for that drop, yet it was Burrow who put them in that position in the first place.

This has been an ongoing thing all year..... their offense didn't do much against Seattle either, just Geno couldn't get the ball in the endzone.

I think Dak should be Top 3.

Don't know why anyone refers to Wright's "mountain" at all, when he ranks a college quarterback in with the pros.

 

[NFCBeasts]

Oh boy …. this is worst case scenario for some folks who think Nick Wright is the only good sports analyst …. now what ?

 

[Nav22]

Dak's been great, but Nick Wrong will never get my respect as any kind of football mind.

 

[Captain-Crash]

When he gets to number 1 I think he's going to ask you to marry him. sweet

 

[Calvin2Tony2Emmitt2Julius]

How could he not be #1 when "Dak an already an All Time Great Cowboys QB" or so I read.

Is Dak a Great Qb? Is He a Cowboys QB ? Does he have the numbers to be listed as All Time Great? So what's the problem? He is an All Time great Cowboys QB

Staubach and Troy are the only one's better. The didn't say "Greatest" They said great. I'd have to say Yes. Especially at the end of this season

 

[Chuck 54]

Dak is in a groove in an offense that appears to fit him, and it should get better. That said, there’s not an NFL coach or gm who would take Dak over those top three right now. Just enjoy that a little of the annoying arguments here have been more quiet. It won’t last.

 

[conner01]

I call a revote.

How is he not Top 3? Burrow thru 2 back-to-back INTs against the Texans and his offense stagnated for 2 and a half quarters before a few late big plays and the Tight End got all the blame for that drop, yet it was Burrow who put them in that position in the first place.

This has been an ongoing thing all year..... their offense didn't do much against Seattle either, just Geno couldn't get the ball in the endzone.

I think Dak should be Top 3.

Can we pump the brakes on Stroud a bit. I understand he’s playing good, but let’s give the kid a full season before we pop him into the top 3.

Isn’t this a weekly thing?

 

[CT Dal Fan]

The Stroud hype is eerily reminiscent of another rookie QB that broke all kinds of records back in 2016. I think there's several hundred threads about that guy here every month.

The kid's playing lights out, but I'm not ready to give him a gold jacket halfway through his first season.

 

[America's Cowboy]

What a joke.

Burrow sucked this past Sunday. He literally contributed to the Bengals loss with his several INTs.

Mahomes has looked average at times this season.

Stroud is a rookie who though playing well a majority of the time has had several games where he was average and overall has a lower passer rating than Dak.