Deunta Williams vs Deandre McDaniel

[Trace1015]

Who do you guys think is the better safety?

 

[Cowboy Brian]

I really dont see any FS's in this draft that even compare too last years 2nd round prospects, burnett and allen.

 

[realtick]

Not overly impressed with either prospect as a "gotta have" type of player.

Deunta Williams reminds me of the Giants 3rd round pick last year, Chad Jones.

Not crazy about DeAndre McDaniel either; he's a stiff athlete and doesn't have quickness.

I agree with Romo2Austin, I think both of these guys would fall somewhere in or after last year's 2nd-tier group of Allen, Burnett, Chad Jones, et cetera.

Having said all that, I would take Deunta over McDaniel.

 

[Manwiththeplan]

FWIW the DBs coach at UNC, Troy Douglass was the DBs coach at USF when Mike Jenkins/Nate Allen were there (not allen's sr. year)

 

[Cowboy Brian]

Not overly impressed with either prospect as a "gotta have" type of player.

Deunta Williams reminds me of the Giants 3rd round pick last year, Chad Jones.

Not crazy about DeAndre McDaniel either; he's a stiff athlete and doesn't have quickness.

I agree with Romo2Austin, I think both of these guys would fall somewhere in or after last year's 2nd-tier group of Allen, Burnett, Chad Jones, et cetera.

Having said all that, I would take Deunta over McDaniel.

Truthfully, last years third round pick Major Wright looks like a better prospect than either of these two.

 

[JeffInDC]

Who do you guys think is the better safety?

Neither one of them is as good as the top 2 Jr.'s - Mark Barron (Bama) & Rahim Moore (UCLA). As a matter of fact, I would probably take Kenny Tate (MD) before them as well.

 

[JeffInDC]

Truthfully, last years third round pick Major Wright looks like a better prospect than either of these two.

Yep. Great 2 round draft by the way.