Dueling mock draft simulators - Christmas edition

[KingintheNorth]

Three simulators:

NFL Mock Draft Simulator | NFL Mock Draft Database

2024 NFL Mock Draft Simulator With Free Trades - Pro Football Network

2024 NFL Mock Draft Simulator | PFF

No trades, just make the picks. The three sites are not in agreement yet on the Cowboys total amount of draft picks.

For the record, I have the Cowboys with the following picks:

1

2

3

4 to San Francisco – Trey Lance

5 to Kansas City – Eric Scott

6 to Buffalo (via Houston) - Brandon Cooks

7a from Las Vegas – Jonathan Hankins

7b


A few sites have the Cowboys getting two 6th round compensatory picks. Overthecap.com has them getting a 5th (McGovern), a 6th (Schultz), and a 7th (Noah Brown).


NFL Mock Draft Database

1(26). Taliese Fuaga OT | Oregon State A

2(59). Jeremiah Trotter Jr. LB | Clemson A+

3(90). Cooper Beebe OT | Kansas State B+

5(172). James Williams S | Miami (FL) A+

6(211). Ray Davis RB | Kentucky A+

7a(228). DeWayne Carter DL | Duke A+

7b(244). Tony Grimes CB | Texas A&M A+

Pro Football Network

1(26). Kingsley Suamataia OT BYU

2(59). Tyler Guyton OT Oklahoma

3(90). Ty'Ron Hopper LB Missouri

7a(202). Jaylen Wright RB Tennessee

7b(218). Kendall Bohler CB Florida A&M

Pro Football Focus

1(30). Graham Barton T Duke B

2(62). Tyler Guyton T Oklahoma C

3(93). Blake Corum RB Michigan A-

4(130). Junior Colson LB Michigan B+

5(174). Ty’Ron Hopper LB Missouri C-

6(212). Jabbar Muhammad CB Washington B+

7(251). Blake Watson RB Memphis B+

Overall Draft Grade B

 

[Bigdog]

I’ll take the first draft. Absolutely love the first 3 picks. Please for the love of the football gods let that be our draft. Williams, Davis, and Carter is just icing on the cake.

 

[Hardline]

Absolutely unrealistic
The only one remotely possible is the first one.
And Cooper Beebe is going at the top of the 2nd round.
Tyler Guyton is getting first round talk now.

 

[KingintheNorth]

And Cooper Beebe is going at the top of the 2nd round.

Not sure. Solid player but may be maxed out already. I can see anywhere 2nd round to 4th round for him.

Tyler Guyton is getting first round talk now.

Agreed. I don't control where the players are in the simulators. Two of the sites currently have him in that range. That will change soon. It came down to Guytona nd your guy Sweat at that pick. Couldn't pass up on Guyton as much as I would love Sweat in the late 2nd.

Jim Nagy said he thought Guyton is the highest ranked prospect at the Senior Bowl and compared him to Tyron Smith.

OL is such a need. Biadasz is a free agent. Tyron is a free agent and may retire, Steele is not the guy they thought he was when they rushed that extension. Luckily, this upcoming draft is loaded with OL.

 

[Carter]

NFL Mock Draft Database
Traded down 2 Spots with the Ravens and got an additional 3rd, 5th and 7th ol.

Fixed the O-Line and Running Game with that Draft.

That haul in would be beyond crazy.

32.
Troy Fautanu
OT | Washington A

61.
Sedrick Van Pran
IOL | Georgia B+

93.
Trey Benson
RB | Florida State A+

95.
Tyleik Williams
DL | Ohio State A

133.
Tommy Eichenberg
LB | Ohio State A+

172.
Tykee Smith
S | Georgia A+

211.
Malik Washington
WR | Virginia A+

225.
Dwight McGlothern
CB | Arkansas A+

226.
Ashton Gillotte
EDGE | Louisville A+

247.
Deontae Lawson
LB | Alabama B+


2024 NFL Mock Draft Simulator With Free Trades - Pro Football Network

Traded our 2nd for two 3rds with the Vikings

• 30.
  Kingsley Suamataia
  OT BYU
• 79.
  Zach Frazier
  OC West Virginia
  
  
• 81.
  Edgerrin Cooper
  LB Texas A&M
  
  
• 93.
  Bucky Irving
  RB Oregon
• 222.
  Davin Vann
  DT NC State

Would be an okay Draft, also fixed the O-Line.


2024 NFL Mock Draft Simulator | PFF

Here you can only do 3 Rounds.

30.
Troy Fautanu
OT | Washington

61.
T'Vondre Sweat
DT | Texas

93.
Blake Corum
RB | Michigan

Highly unrealistic as Sweat and Corum will likely go a round earlier.

 

[Sydla]

King didn't make trades but I did:

NFL MOCK DRAFT SIMULATOR:

36 - Suamataia, OT, BUY *** traded 30 for 36, 67, 102 and 219 - seems like a massive overpay but whatever I took it ***
61 - Trotter Jr, LB, Clemson
67 - Van Pran, OC/OG, UGA
93 - Williams, DT, Ohio St
102 - Corum, TB, UM
172 - Ford, LB, Texas
211 - Sheppard, CB, Maryland
219 - Ceasar, DE, Houston
226 - Watts, S, ND
202 - Schrader, TB, Missouri

Unreasonable mock but if it came to pass, I'd take this one.

PRO FOOTBALL NETWORK

26 - Mims, OT
61 - Taylor, DT, Miami
98 - Estime, TB, ND
201 - Knight, LB, UTEP
222 - Solomon, DE, Troy

Hate this draft. Estime in the 3rd seems like a reach but the board was wasted at that point.

I didn't do PFF as I don't really like it.

 

[Mr_437]

Was Gilmore a 5th rounder from this coming draft?

Anyway, it's gonna be a rough draft. Dallas will need to hit on their top 3 picks.

Eric Scott Jr. trade is looking bad.

 

[KingintheNorth]

Was Gilmore a 5th rounder from this coming draft?

Anyway, it's gonna be a rough draft. Dallas will need to hit on their top 3 picks.

Eric Scott Jr. trade is looking bad.

1

2

3

4 to San Francisco – Trey Lance

5 to Kansas City – Eric Scott

6 to Buffalo (via Houston) - Brandon Cooks

7a from Las Vegas – Jonathan Hankins

7b

 

[Sydla]

1

2

3

4 to San Francisco – Trey Lance

5 to Kansas City – Eric Scott

6 to Buffalo (via Houston) - Brandon Cooks

7a from Las Vegas – Jonathan Hankins

7b

I assume we get a 6th comp round pick in there somewhere.

But I am totally on board with moving down to add a couple more picks. Like I'd consider moving our first rounder to slide a few spots and maybe pick up a 3rd and 4th or 5th, for example. I think there is going to be some intriguing players in the 35-42 range that aren't much different than if we were picking 29th or 30th.

 

[KingintheNorth]

I assume we get a 6th comp round pick in there somewhere.

Projections have us anywhere from a 5th, 6th, and 7th to two 6th round picks.