Dueling mock draft simulators Super Bowl edition

[KingintheNorth]

Three simulators:

NFL Mock Draft Simulator | NFL Mock Draft Database

2024 NFL Mock Draft Simulator With Free Trades - Pro Football Network

2024 NFL Mock Draft Simulator | PFF

No trades, just make the picks. The three sites are not in agreement yet on the Cowboys total amount of draft picks.

For the record, I have the Cowboys with the following picks:

1
2
3
4 to San Francisco – Trey Lance
5 to Kansas City – Eric Scott
6 to Buffalo (via Houston) - Brandon Cooks
7a from Las Vegas – Jonathan Hankins
7b

A few sites have the Cowboys getting two 6th round compensatory picks. Overthecap.com has them getting a 5th (McGovern), a 6th (Schultz), and a 7th (Noah Brown).


PFF appears to have the Cowboys with all their picks. They will adjust that as we get closer to the draft.

R1:24 Tyler Guyton T Oklahoma Grade C-
R2: 56 T’Vondre Sweat DT Texas Grade B
R3: 87 Malachi Corley WR Western Kentucky Grade C
R4: 124 Marshawn Lloyd RB USC Grade A-
R5: 174 Ty’Ron Hopper LB Missouri Grade C-
R6: 212 Trevin Wallace LB Kentucky Grade B
R7: 245 Blake Watson RB Memphis Grade B+
Overall Draft Grade B-

PFN appears to have Comp picks now.

R1:24 Taliese Fuaga T Oregon State
R2: 56 T’Vondre Sweat DT Texas
R3: 87 Payton Wilson LB NC State
R5: 174 Blake Watson RB Memphis
R6: 212 Austin Booker EDGE Kansas
R7a: 230 Edefuan Ulofoshio LB Washington
R7b: 241 Kendall Milton RB Georgia

NFL Mock Draft Database has no 4th round pick

R1: 24 Tyler Guyton T Oklahoma Grade A+
R2: 56 Edgerrin Cooper LB Texas A&M Grade B+
R3: 87 Trey Benson RB Florida State Grade A
R5: 172 Ainias Smith WR Texas A&M Grade A+
R6: 212 Trevin Wallace LB Kentucky Grade B+
R7a: 230 Ladarius Henderson G Michigan Grade A+
R7b: 241 Blake Watson RB Grade F

 

[Kwyn]

Odd how two of the mocks have us taking Guyton but one has it as a C- and the other A+

And … lol … pick 241 gets an F!

 

[Carson]

I used the first one and I don’t like to make trades so I can make it somewhat realistic

(24) Jackson Powers-Johnson IOL A
(56) Edgerrin Cooper LB B+
(87) Ruke Orhorhoro DT A+
(172) Roger Rosengarten OT A+
(212) Gabe Hall DT A+
(230) Brennen Jackson DE A
(241) Emani Bailey RB A+

I feel this was very generous and would never happen lol

 

[McMicah]

Call me crazy but I like Tyler Guyton more than I like Mims and even Joe Alt. That sounds insane, but Guytons anchor is insane. Go watch Joe Alt tape. He’s got better technique than Guyton for sure, but look how quickly he gets walked backwards. Guyton literally doesn’t seem to move when he gets rushed, like he’s made of concrete.

I’d rather teach a guy with a naturally great anchor better hand technique, than the other way around. See Tyler Biadisz for an example of good technique but a weak anchor

 

[rambo2]

Call me crazy but I like Tyler Guyton more than I like Mims and even Joe Alt. That sounds insane, but Guytons anchor is insane. Go watch Joe Alt tape. He’s got better technique than Guyton for sure, but look how quickly he gets walked backwards. Guyton literally doesn’t seem to move when he gets rushed, like he’s made of concrete.

I’d rather teach a guy with a naturally great anchor better hand technique, than the other way around. See Tyler Biadisz for an example of good technique but a weak anchor

If they drafted Tyler Guyton, where would he play?

 

[Carson]

If they drafted Tyler Guyton, where would he play?

Right tackle

 

[rambo2]

Right tackle

What do you do with Steele? Guyton could play left tackle.

 

[Bigdog]

I am taking the PFN one. Fuaga, Sweat, Wilson, Booker are great picks

 

[Carson]

What do you do with Steele? Guyton could play left tackle.

He hasn’t played right tackle (to my knowledge) and projects best at RT. Unsure if he makes the move successfully / attempts it

 

[rambo2]

He hasn’t played right tackle (to my knowledge) and projects best at RT. Unsure if he makes the move successfully / attempts it

He played right tackle at OU because they had a left handed qb.

 

[reddyuta]

I think we will draft a RB in the 3rd or 4th Rd pick.

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

Three simulators:

NFL Mock Draft Simulator | NFL Mock Draft Database

2024 NFL Mock Draft Simulator With Free Trades - Pro Football Network

2024 NFL Mock Draft Simulator | PFF

No trades, just make the picks. The three sites are not in agreement yet on the Cowboys total amount of draft picks.

For the record, I have the Cowboys with the following picks:

1
2
3
4 to San Francisco – Trey Lance
5 to Kansas City – Eric Scott
6 to Buffalo (via Houston) - Brandon Cooks
7a from Las Vegas – Jonathan Hankins
7b

A few sites have the Cowboys getting two 6th round compensatory picks. Overthecap.com has them getting a 5th (McGovern), a 6th (Schultz), and a 7th (Noah Brown).


PFF appears to have the Cowboys with all their picks. They will adjust that as we get closer to the draft.

R1:24 Tyler Guyton T Oklahoma Grade C-
R2: 56 T’Vondre Sweat DT Texas Grade B
R3: 87 Malachi Corley WR Western Kentucky Grade C
R4: 124 Marshawn Lloyd RB USC Grade A-
R5: 174 Ty’Ron Hopper LB Missouri Grade C-
R6: 212 Trevin Wallace LB Kentucky Grade B
R7: 245 Blake Watson RB Memphis Grade B+
Overall Draft Grade B-

PFN appears to have Comp picks now.

R1:24 Taliese Fuaga T Oregon State
R2: 56 T’Vondre Sweat DT Texas
R3: 87 Payton Wilson LB NC State
R5: 174 Blake Watson RB Memphis
R6: 212 Austin Booker EDGE Kansas
R7a: 230 Edefuan Ulofoshio LB Washington
R7b: 241 Kendall Milton RB Georgia

NFL Mock Draft Database has no 4th round pick

R1: 24 Tyler Guyton T Oklahoma Grade A+
R2: 56 Edgerrin Cooper LB Texas A&M Grade B+
R3: 87 Trey Benson RB Florida State Grade A
R5: 172 Ainias Smith WR Texas A&M Grade A+
R6: 212 Trevin Wallace LB Kentucky Grade B+
R7a: 230 Ladarius Henderson G Michigan Grade A+
R7b: 241 Blake Watson RB Grade F

The NFL Draft Database mock without a doubt.

 

[Carson]

He played right tackle at OU because they had a left handed qb.

Correct. But a lot of draft guys Broaddus included feel this way

 

[McMicah]

He played right tackle at OU because they had a left handed qb.

So we draft Penix in the 2nd and call it good? Everybody good with that?

 

[JeffInDC]

Guyton DEFINITELY has the athleticism to play LT.

 

[rambo2]

So we draft Penix in the 2nd and call it good? Everybody good with that?

They wouldn't draft another qb after they already took Lance with their 4th round pick.

 

[Risen Star]

F, F and F.