Everyone one saying Payton was overrated

[Shannon1]

Everyone one saying Payton was overrated ,He went in cleaned house took a major salary cap hit with Wilson ! Look what they are doing with a rookie QB now !

 

[Xelda]

Shoot, I thought you were talking about Paintin Manning. You are correct in your observation. It's a shame that type of magic doesn't happen in Dallas.

 

[jwitten82]

Everyone one saying Payton was overrated ,He went in cleaned house took a major salary cap hit with Wilson ! Look what they are doing with a rookie QB now !

He had Drew Brees for 15 years, and theyve won one Superbowl. Payton and McCarthy coaching careers are pretty similar

 

[gtb1943]

He had Drew Brees for 15 years, and theyve won one Superbowl. Payton and McCarthy coaching careers are pretty similar

well they were cheated out of a shot at another one by the refs but yeah he had a HOF QB for that long and only got one Ring
so its arguable

 

[DZSierra]

Am I the only one who believes that a good football coach has to be on the SAME page with the GM and owner?

One variable that can't be eliminated is ownership when it comes to management style, and Jerry isn't the guy when it comes to management "style" (is Stephen?).

A good coach sooner or later is going to get more press then the ownership of the cowboys, and that's going to cause a lot of friction IMO.

 

[darthseinfeld]

He had Drew Brees for 15 years, and theyve won one Superbowl. Payton and McCarthy coaching careers are pretty similar

When we hired McCarthy, their resumes were eerily similar. Especially considering Brees and Rodgers is almost a wash. Rodgers is probably better, but not by enough to make a real difference in McCarthy or Paytons career