Games that cemented a player's reputation with Cowboys fanbase -- good or bad?

VaqueroTD

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,804
Reaction score
17,700
Tried to pick short clips wherever I could, but as usual, have to click into YouTube to see them because of NFL rights.

As an example, here are some obvious recent ones that cemented a great reputation:

Jason Witten - 2007, the Helmet Off Game. His first 1,000 yard season. Already becoming a great one, but the legend was his to lose after this game.


Emmitt Smith - 1993, the One Shoulder Game. Lost first two games with his holdout. Came back, Emmitt dominated, Cowboys won home field advantage here. Madden pimped it much better than ESPN. Emmitt on to be MVP, and Cowboys win second Super Bowl. HOFer forever after this.


Bill Parcells - 2003, 4th Qtr/OT Win against Giants, Game 2 of his first season
This was the one after three 5-11 seasons with Campo that fans knew the Cowboys were back in the Tuna era. NEVER would have seen this type of last minute execution from preparation and results (or as Big Mac calls them, the Mojo Moments) in the Campo Era. Best part though is the team believed it too after this. I also thought at the time maybe it was a breakout game for Quincy and AB to have long successful careers.... oh well.


Here is probably the most obvious bad example in Cowboys history:

Jackie Smith - 1979 Super Bowl against Steelers, The Drop
A HOF career for Smith before he was in Dallas, but forever remembered by Cowboys fans for this drop that might have led to a win in the 35-31 loss, and chance for 70's Cowboys to be on same pedestal as the 70's Steelers.


Tony Romo - 2006 Wild Card vs Seahawks, Fumbled FG Game
Maybe this is more NFL fans than Cowboys fans, but Romo would have had to win the Super Bowl after this infamous play to forever take away the choker tag. Felt bad for the guy, cause he was such a welcome breath of fresh air at QB after all the experiments since Aikman. And then could say the Giants loss in first round sealed his rep forever, fair or not.
 

McKDaddy

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,577
Reaction score
10,260
Miles Austin against KC

Larry Allen chasing down the guy in preseason

Demarco Murray against the Rams

Alvin Harper against the Niners

Sean Lee against Colts (I believe) had like 2 or 3 interceptions and was basically a one man wrecking machine.

Some of the ones that jump to mind for me.
 

VaqueroTD

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,804
Reaction score
17,700
Miles Austin against KC

Larry Allen chasing down the guy in preseason

Demarco Murray against the Rams

Alvin Harper against the Niners

Sean Lee against Colts (I believe) had like 2 or 3 interceptions and was basically a one man wrecking machine.

Some of the ones that jump to mind for me.
Good one on that Miles Austin game. He was the man after that. Just fizzled out after 2 years.

I feel like Larry Allen should have a game like that but I remember so many great "whoah" plays or games.

 

MarcusRock

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,936
Reaction score
17,459
Dez' non-catch in Green Bay, only because it came after his finger out in the last seconds in that game against the Giants. It cemented that he was a player on the cusp of legendary status but kept getting snakebit.
 

Dallasfann

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,415
Reaction score
7,427
Honestly, you missed the biggest one. Patrick Crayton vs the Giants playoffs..one could argue Patrick Crayton all by himself kept a lot of all time great Cowboy players from winning a Super Bowl.
 

VaqueroTD

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,804
Reaction score
17,700
Honestly, you missed the biggest one. Patrick Crayton vs the Giants playoffs..one could argue Patrick Crayton all by himself kept a lot of all time great Cowboy players from winning a Super Bowl.
Good point. I think the Giants game is for Cowboys fans. The Romo is a good QB, but can't catch a break. Seahawks fumble is for the NFL fans who didn't watch as many games as us.

The one thing I don't remember from that game rewatching the clip is the disgusted look on Jerry's face. LOL

 

john van brocklin

Captain Comeback
Messages
39,621
Reaction score
44,843
Tried to pick short clips wherever I could, but as usual, have to click into YouTube to see them because of NFL rights.

As an example, here are some obvious recent ones that cemented a great reputation:

Jason Witten - 2007, the Helmet Off Game. His first 1,000 yard season. Already becoming a great one, but the legend was his to lose after this game.


Emmitt Smith - 1993, the One Shoulder Game. Lost first two games with his holdout. Came back, Emmitt dominated, Cowboys won home field advantage here. Madden pimped it much better than ESPN. Emmitt on to be MVP, and Cowboys win second Super Bowl. HOFer forever after this.


Bill Parcells - 2003, 4th Qtr/OT Win against Giants, Game 2 of his first season
This was the one after three 5-11 seasons with Campo that fans knew the Cowboys were back in the Tuna era. NEVER would have seen this type of last minute execution from preparation and results (or as Big Mac calls them, the Mojo Moments) in the Campo Era. Best part though is the team believed it too after this. I also thought at the time maybe it was a breakout game for Quincy and AB to have long successful careers.... oh well.


Here is probably the most obvious bad example in Cowboys history:

Jackie Smith - 1979 Super Bowl against Steelers, The Drop
A HOF career for Smith before he was in Dallas, but forever remembered by Cowboys fans for this drop that might have led to a win in the 35-31 loss, and chance for 70's Cowboys to be on same pedestal as the 70's Steelers.


Tony Romo - 2006 Wild Card vs Seahawks, Fumbled FG Game
Maybe this is more NFL fans than Cowboys fans, but Romo would have had to win the Super Bowl after this infamous play to forever take away the choker tag. Felt bad for the guy, cause he was such a welcome breath of fresh air at QB after all the experiments since Aikman. And then could say the Giants loss in first round sealed his rep forever, fair or not.

Good stuff, my man !
 

Ranching

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,866
Reaction score
111,178
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Tried to pick short clips wherever I could, but as usual, have to click into YouTube to see them because of NFL rights.

As an example, here are some obvious recent ones that cemented a great reputation:

Jason Witten - 2007, the Helmet Off Game. His first 1,000 yard season. Already becoming a great one, but the legend was his to lose after this game.


Emmitt Smith - 1993, the One Shoulder Game. Lost first two games with his holdout. Came back, Emmitt dominated, Cowboys won home field advantage here. Madden pimped it much better than ESPN. Emmitt on to be MVP, and Cowboys win second Super Bowl. HOFer forever after this.


Bill Parcells - 2003, 4th Qtr/OT Win against Giants, Game 2 of his first season
This was the one after three 5-11 seasons with Campo that fans knew the Cowboys were back in the Tuna era. NEVER would have seen this type of last minute execution from preparation and results (or as Big Mac calls them, the Mojo Moments) in the Campo Era. Best part though is the team believed it too after this. I also thought at the time maybe it was a breakout game for Quincy and AB to have long successful careers.... oh well.


Here is probably the most obvious bad example in Cowboys history:

Jackie Smith - 1979 Super Bowl against Steelers, The Drop
A HOF career for Smith before he was in Dallas, but forever remembered by Cowboys fans for this drop that might have led to a win in the 35-31 loss, and chance for 70's Cowboys to be on same pedestal as the 70's Steelers.


Tony Romo - 2006 Wild Card vs Seahawks, Fumbled FG Game
Maybe this is more NFL fans than Cowboys fans, but Romo would have had to win the Super Bowl after this infamous play to forever take away the choker tag. Felt bad for the guy, cause he was such a welcome breath of fresh air at QB after all the experiments since Aikman. And then could say the Giants loss in first round sealed his rep forever, fair or not.

Don't forget the Hail Mary! I was 7 years old. Haven't missed a game since.
 

LonnieElam

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,631
Reaction score
3,038
Not a game, but the stretch that Zeke was suspended made me realize that Dak is NOT the man. Didn't the offense go scoreless for like 6 quarters straight?
 

VaqueroTD

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,804
Reaction score
17,700
Dez' non-catch in Green Bay, only because it came after his finger out in the last seconds in that game against the Giants. It cemented that he was a player on the cusp of legendary status but kept getting snakebit.
For me that's the epitome game of the Romo/Parcells/Wade/Garrett Cowboys. Always one step to breaking the wall down, but never quite there.

Hoping Big Mac and Dak can stop whatever curse Jerry sold his soul for those three Super Bowls.
 

HanD

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,471
Reaction score
3,608
George teague in cowboys folklore.
tumblr_nb3rzr2PmS1ra90n2o7_400.gif
 
Top