Kiper Round 1 Winners and Question Marks

Risen Star

Likes Collector
Messages
89,714
Reaction score
213,323
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Biggest winners from Round 1

Philadelphia Eagles
The picks: Jalen Carter, DT, Georgia (No. 9); Nolan Smith, OLB, Georgia (No. 30).

Wow! The rich get richer. Philadelphia moved up one spot, trading Chicago a 2024 fourth-round pick, to get the No. 1 overall prospect on my Big Board. The Eagles are going to reunite Carter with former Georgia teammate Jordan Davis -- the two formed an outstanding interior duo in 2021. I love this pick. This team has the locker-room leadership to make sure Carter stays on track and plays to his potential.

Then the Eagles added another Bulldog late, getting my 12th-ranked player at No. 30. Smith missed half of the 2022 season with a torn pectoral muscle, but he has rare physical tools. He flies off the edge. I thought he'd go much higher. Philly is putting together a defense filled with national champions -- it also picked up linebacker Nakobe Dean last year. This is a great start for the Eagles.

-

Seattle Seahawks
The picks: Devon Witherspoon, CB, Illinois (No. 5); Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR, Ohio State (No. 20)

This is a nice Round 1 for Seattle, which owned a top-five pick as part of the Russell Wilson trade. While I would have gone with Jalen Carter over Witherspoon, the cornerback combo of Witherspoon and Tariq Woolen could quickly become one of the league's best. Witherspoon is my top-ranked corner, a true lockdown cover guy who can run with any receiver. For a team that wants to compete in the NFC West, he's ready to play as a rookie.

As for Smith-Njigba, he complements Tyler Lockett and DK Metcalf extremely well, as I mentioned a month ago when I first made this pairing. I thought he might go a little bit higher, but he landed in a great spot. We're talking about a player who put up 1,600 yards and nine scores in 2021 when he was healthy. He can play outside or inside. Geno Smith has to be thrilled with this addition.

-

Baltimore Ravens
The pick: Zay Flowers, WR, Boston College (No. 22)

What a day for Baltimore, which locked down Lamar Jackson for five more years and then got its quarterback a playmaker in Flowers, one of my favorite prospects in this entire class. He'll make Jackson's life so much easier. He can run every route, and he'll dominate out of the slot. Yes, the Ravens signed Odell Beckham Jr., but that was just a one-year deal. They have plenty of room for Flowers.

The Baltimore wide receivers combined for 248 receiving yards when lined up in the slot last season, fewest in the NFL. Flowers plugs a big hole.

-

Pittsburgh Steelers
The pick: Broderick Jones, OT, Georgia (No. 14)

Pittsburgh got a plug-and-play starter at tackle. He didn't allow a single sack on 446 pass-block snaps for the national champs last season. The Steelers moved up three spots with the Patriots, trading away No. 120 overall to do it, and these are the types of trades up the board I like. Giving up a fourth-round pick won't hurt the rest of this team's haul, which includes two second-round picks. I expect Jones to start in Week 1.

-

New England Patriots
The pick: Christian Gonzalez, CB, Oregon (No. 17)

I also liked what the Patriots did with their part of the trade with the Steelers. Gonzalez is my ninth-ranked prospect, and I thought he was a lock for the top 10. He could be a steal for the Patriots, who have a hole in the defensive backfield and didn't look like a typical Bill Belichick secondary in 2022. Gonzalez can thrive in man or zone coverage.

-

More picks I liked
I wanted to put Arizona in the "winners" category after it added a super-valuable 2024 first-round pick from Houston, but then it went and moved up six spots with Detroit, giving away No. 34 overall. Paris Johnson Jr. (No. 6 overall) is my top-ranked offensive tackle, and he'll be great there. But I can't put the Cardinals as a clear winner.

No. 15 overall pick Will McDonald IV is going to wreak havoc off the edge for the Jets. The edge rusher had 10 career forced fumbles for Iowa State. He's another one of my favorite prospects in this draft.

Speaking of, No. 16 overall pick Emmanuel Forbes is another guy I really like. The 6-foot-1, 166-pound cornerback has a slim frame, but he just makes plays -- he had six pick-sixes at Mississippi State, after all. He has phenomenal ball skills.

Cornerback Deonte Banks is a nice pickup for the Giants, who had just six interceptions all of last season. Banks is fast and tough. He did not allow a catch of over 30 yards all season. The Giants got him at No. 24, and he's No. 20 in my rankings.

How about the Bills moving up for my top-ranked tight end Dalton Kincaid at No. 25 to pair him with Dalton Knox? That's a fun combination, and you know Josh Allen has to love it. Kincaid has the speed to outrun safeties.

Buffalo jumped Dallas for Kincaid, so the Cowboys pivoted to run-stuffer Mazi Smith at No. 26. He's a powerful defensive tackle. Stopping the run was their biggest issue on defense last season.

-

Teams that made head-scratching moves in Round 1

Detroit Lions
The picks: Jahmyr Gibbs, RB, Alabama (No. 12); Jack Campbell, LB, Iowa (No. 18)

I thought I would like this Lions class when they traded down at No. 6. At that time, they owned pick Nos. 12, 18, 34, 48 and 55. But I just don't get these two choices.

Let's start with Gibbs, a multi-dimensional player who racked up receptions for the Crimson Tide. Look who else was on the board at 12, though. One of the cornerbacks -- Christian Gonzalez or Emmanuel Forbes or Deonte Banks -- or edge rusher Nolan Smith made more sense to me. Yes, Detroit has a bunch more picks on Day 2, but it could have found a running back there instead of at No. 12.

As for Campbell, it's a reach of 40 spots on in my rankings. He's my third-ranked inside linebacker. I thought he'd go in the middle of Round 2 instead. When we talk about positional value, both of these positions are not usually prioritized in the first round, so this is the very definition of head-scratching. The funny thing is I had pegged Campbell to Detroit at No. 48 in my two-round mock a couple of weeks ago. There were much better players available when Detroit took him.

-

Houston Texans
The picks: C.J. Stroud, QB, Ohio State (No. 2); Will Anderson Jr., OLB, Alabama (No. 3)

Well, the Houston front office can keep a secret. General manager Nick Caserio kept the pick of Stroud under lock and key. Two weeks ago, I thought he was definitely going to the Texans. Recently, though, I heard a ton about them passing on a quarterback in the top five and going with an edge rusher. And on draft day, they did ... both.

The Texans made back-to-back stunning moves, first taking Stroud and then trading up for Anderson with the Cardinals. They gave up a ton in the process -- pick Nos. 12 and 33 in this draft, along with first- and third-rounders in 2024. In return, they got Anderson and pick No. 105.

In a vacuum, I love the prospects they added. Yes, Stroud is my third-ranked passer, but I had him at No. 5 overall on my Big Board -- he was just behind Will Levis in my position rankings. Anderson had outstanding sack production in college and could rack up 10 sacks per season. The reason I wrote "in a vacuum" there is because of the haul Houston had to send to move up. This is a roster that needs a ton of help, so are we sure that 2024 first-rounder won't end up in the top five again? Houston no longer has a second-round pick in this draft.

That's why I'm putting Houston in the head-scratching category, even though I'm hedging a little bit. I like the players, but I don't love the trade for a team that is still rebuilding.

-

Green Bay Packers
The pick: Lukas Van Ness, DE, Iowa (No. 13)

This is a reach. Green Bay passed up its chance to take any of the wide receivers and any of the tight ends for Van Ness, a 6-foot-5, 272-pound hulking edge rusher. Why not help out inexperienced quarterback Jordan Love? Van Ness is No. 27 overall on my board; I actually thought he could go back to Iowa and get some more seasoning ahead of the 2024 draft.

And if they wanted an edge rusher, Myles Murphy and Will McDonald IV are higher in my rankings. I don't love this one.

-

Atlanta Falcons
The pick: Bijan Robinson, RB, Texas (No. 8)

This is really high for a running back, when there is so much evidence teams can find value on Days 2 and 3 of the draft and get just as much production. Atlanta went that route last year in fifth-rounder Tyler Allgeier, who averaged 4.9 yards per carry as a rookie.

Listen, Robinson is a fantastic player with juice as a receiver too. But I can like the prospect but not love the value, and that's how I feel here. Atlanta could have taken a cornerback or edge rusher and filled a need.

-

Las Vegas Raiders
The pick: Tyree Wilson, DE, Texas Tech (No. 7)

Look, I get it, Wilson is a high-upside pass-rusher with a 6-foot-6 frame, and those types of guys go in the top 10. But this is a reach on my board, especially with cornerback Christian Gonzalez still available when Las Vegas picked. Corner is a bigger need for this team.

I have Wilson at No. 16 overall on my board. His traits didn't always match his production -- he wasn't as dominant as he should have been in the Big 12. Plus, he has a foot injury and didn't work out before the draft. There's some risk here.
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
40,225
Reaction score
37,459
Not sure we pivoted. There's no indication we were going to take Kincaid. Didn't see any signs in the war room that we were upset when Buffalo jumped us and took him.
 

DanA

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,988
Reaction score
5,804
The Eagles got good players but I have so many questions
  • Is Nolan Smith going to displace Graham, Sweat, and Reddick on the edge?
  • Is Jalen Carter supposed to replace Javon Hargraves' 11 sacks?
  • How exactly are they going to extract full value from these guys?
 

Bigdog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,870
Reaction score
11,520
The Eagles got good players but I have so many questions
  • Is Nolan Smith going to displace Graham, Sweat, and Reddick on the edge?
  • Is Jalen Carter supposed to replace Javon Hargraves' 11 sacks?
  • How exactly are they going to extract full value from these guys?
Agree. Smith is good but can he hold up for 17 games. Can Carter stay out of trouble and take to coaching. Heard he Ivan be a headcase. We shall see
 

DBOY3141

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,340
Reaction score
5,956
Impossible to crap on those picks. They got great talent.
You should get great talent with the #9 pick in the draft. I liked the Smith pick and would have taken him over Mazi, but I'm fine with Mazi at 26.
 

Cowboyny

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,237
Reaction score
20,271
The Eagles got good players but I have so many questions
  • Is Nolan Smith going to displace Graham, Sweat, and Reddick on the edge?
  • Is Jalen Carter supposed to replace Javon Hargraves' 11 sacks?
  • How exactly are they going to extract full value from these guys?
We knew why Carter fell, but why did Nolan Smith get passed over, is it something with his medicals?
 

JIMMYBUFFETT

Skinwalker
Messages
3,469
Reaction score
5,727
I won't crap on the Eagles draft because they had the best of the night. That said the Carter deal is scary. Mort said last night that 3 teams in front of the Eagles had taken Carter off their board. The Eagles picked 9th so that's not even including the teams that took Carter off their boards who picked after the Eagles. We also saw Pete Carroll and the Raiders organization pass on Carter. Let that sink in. Pete Carroll passed the #1 defensive player in the draft at a position many felt was the Seahawks biggest need for a corner. That spoke volumes to me.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,769
Reaction score
95,316
Looking forward to all our fans trying to crap on Philly’s draft.
Here's how I view it.

If we had drafted four UGA players in two years, our fans would come up with a catchy nickname for them and 3 to 4 would just end up being busts.

Philly drafted 4 UGA players in two years, their fans will come up with some annoying nickname for them and all four will wreck offenses for the next 4-5 years.

That's the fate of us Cowboys fans.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,769
Reaction score
95,316
I won't crap on the Eagles draft because they had the best of the night. That said the Carter deal is scary. Mort said last night that 3 teams in front of the Eagles had taken Carter off their board. The Eagles picked 9th so that's not even including the teams that took Carter off their boards who picked after the Eagles. We also saw Pete Carroll and the Raiders organization pass on Carter. Let that sink in. Pete Carroll passed the #1 defensive player in the draft at a position many felt was the Seahawks biggest need for a corner. That spoke volumes to me.
Now, to be clear, if in the same situation I'd want the Cowboys to take Carter if they had the 9th pick.

That being said, he definitely has boom or bust potential. His talents are clear. He can be a game wrecker in the middle like a Jones or Cox in his hey day. That being said, he's immature, does stupid things and from what some have reported, can be kind of lazy.
 

JIMMYBUFFETT

Skinwalker
Messages
3,469
Reaction score
5,727
Now, to be clear, if in the same situation I'd want the Cowboys to take Carter if they had the 9th pick.

That being said, he definitely has boom or bust potential. His talents are clear. He can be a game wrecker in the middle like a Jones or Cox in his hey day. That being said, he's immature, does stupid things and from what some have reported, can be kind of lazy.
Yep, I'd of taken him and giving up a 4th to move up was nothing. I just have a feeling Philly better enjoy him while they can.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,769
Reaction score
95,316
Yep, I'd of taken him and giving up a 4th to move up was nothing. I just have a feeling Philly better enjoy him while they can.
Yeah the cost was minimal. Philly has like 12 picks in the 2024 draft when factoring in comp picks. So throwing a future 4th is no big deal.
 

cnuball21

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,923
Reaction score
9,837
I think the Eagles are the clear cut winner as long as Carter pans out.

Just an absolute grand slam getting him AND Smith at 30.
 

Mac_MaloneV1

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,437
Reaction score
5,739
The Eagles got good players but I have so many questions
  • Is Nolan Smith going to displace Graham, Sweat, and Reddick on the edge?
  • Is Jalen Carter supposed to replace Javon Hargraves' 11 sacks?
  • How exactly are they going to extract full value from these guys?
They aren't 30 and they are on rookie deals for 5 years, plus they have ridiculous upside. You're talking Micah Parsons and Chris Jones upside.

Who knows whether they'll actually improve next year, but if you get the same production from rookie deals its a massive win.
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
40,225
Reaction score
37,459
Now, to be clear, if in the same situation I'd want the Cowboys to take Carter if they had the 9th pick.

That being said, he definitely has boom or bust potential. His talents are clear. He can be a game wrecker in the middle like a Jones or Cox in his hey day. That being said, he's immature, does stupid things and from what some have reported, can be kind of lazy.
If Philly took Bijan, I kind of wanted us to take Gibbs. So I kind of like it that Philly took a DT and then we took one. Different players, but it will be fun to see who got the better deal ... and I hope it was us.
 
Top