LarryCanadian
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 1,815
- Reaction score
- 382
I think the Front Office has done the right things in cutting the overpaid and underachieving players. Loved Barber in his prime, loved Columbo and think he has great attitude, but body that is failing him. Roy was a mistake in retrospect, but decent guy, and he's just cursed. Davis was a pro-bowler for us, but has declined in ability and effort it seems. So those moves were good from both a cost and production standpoint.
The contracts they have given Spears, Free, Kosier, and K Coleman (decent big guy - rotation role player) were reasonable. Don't think they overpaid for any of these guys. Tought to lose Bowen, and even if it works out to a short term deal in Wash, that is a lot of dough.
BUT, I hate our depth and there isn't a ton of impact guys that would significantly upgrade our roster available in free-agency. We cut 4 guys with starter type snaps.
So the team is relying on the return of injured players and better/different creative coaching to improve this year. PLUS the "hoped for" return to form of Spencer, Austin, Rat, Jenkins, Newman.
I think from that standpoint we are in trouble compared to teams in our own division like Eagles, and probably the Giants as well. We lack depth and have a lot of question marks still.
I worry in particular about:
Offense:
OT if Free is hurt or 1st Rounder takes time like he very well could/should (particularly with short off season). I don't like Barron and our other young guys are pretty darn raw.
OG - Holland is ok, Kosier is coming back but has been hurt. Not much behind them with any experience. 4th round pick sounds promising, but again, how ready could he be?
C - Gurode IS hurt, and heavy because he hasn't been able to train much. 1 year older and even wonkier slowly degenerative knee(s). Costa is pretty raw and unproven and only started like 1 game.
OLINE Depth is terrible at the moment, even if we hit on this years draft. I'd like to see them try and get O Kreutz who was cut from the Bears as a depth guy, or if Gurode recovers and had to go to guard for a game or two, Kreutz could take over at centre?
FB:
I hope Chapas emerges, because Gronk wasn't great last year. With Jason Garrett liking a bit more of the traditional running game, FB might be more important and we haven't had an impact one since Moose. I know Phillips at TE might play some HB/FB and I REALLY like him, but this might be an area to address late in camp if a savy vet is available.
WR:
We really could use a dependable vet. If Austin or Dez is hurt, I think we are in trouble at WR.
RB, TE, QB are solid and I don't worry about them.
Defense:
I think Ryan's scheme will be biggest help for everything, but do we have any pocket collapsers or pressure guys at DE at all now. Bowen got a bit of pressure on QB, but we seem to have a pure 4 man run stopper rotation now: Spears, Olshansky, Coleman, Lissemore - none of these are QB pressurers.
NOW, with a slimmer Rat (please don't wear this guy out at training camp, rest him), I think we will use him for the "pressure" guy, BUT, that leaves Josh Brent as only true nose-tackle 3-4 type on team no?
I think we could use one more situational pass rusher for front end, maybe a role player type for 3rd downs. Remember, Spears was taken out for many 3rd down plays. Who fills that role now. OR, if that is Rat's new role, then we could use some depth in terms of a big strong NT type - to back up Brent.
If Rat or Brent go down with injury we are in trouble again.
ILB - we have a lot of injury concerns there. Can Lee (who looks like a smart emerging defensive leader) stay on field. Our 2nd round draft pick is 90%. Brooking is older an already hurt and we rely way too much on him and James who have a lot of miles. One injury away from potentially starting a player whose name 95% of Cowboy fans haven't heard of.
OLB - nice to hear reports that Butler and Williams seem to have the lightbulb coming on. Need Spencer to rebound in a big way. If Butler and Williams are just training camp wonders and can't rotate in, then another pass rushing OLB role player would help, especially if Spencer plays like last year. BUT, I think we are probably OK at this position and I hope they give Butler and Williams a ton of snaps and really push them and rotate them in a lot. These guys NEED to step up.
Secondary - BRUTAL. I just am not sold that Jenkins will fully go back to being the player he was 2 years ago. We had a great pass rush and pressure front line that year, and not sure, no matter how creative Ryan's D is this year, that we have the horses to consistently get pressure. It might be expecting too much.
Scandrick showed improvement last year, but I'd love a solid vet corner added to mix.
Newman is a year older and seemed to make a lot of mistakes last year.
None of our guys seem to turn around and have eye on ball.
Safety is just a mess. Sign Elam already, just because he knows Ryan's system and can help organize the secondary. Nobody else is left. I'd love a Sharper for a year or someone like that, but doesn't seem to be any interest from Front office to go the "old" guy route, and I get it, because you overpay. BUT, I'd rather overpay a Sharper for 1 year or 2, than overpay Sensi for 3-4 years, and you're going to have to. I just don't think Sensi is worth the kind of money he wants, and he really disappointed after his 1st season with us.
This is where I fault the Front Office. We have had safety issues for years now and we have NOT found even one consistent solution there. I am almost certain this is going to be a HUGE achilles heel for us AGAIN this year.
I shudder to think of what we start the season with at safety, and that is even before Kwasi or Church tweak a hamstring or something like that.
I have no idea what special teams will be like, outside our punter and long snapper. Who returns kicks/punts (every year that isn't solved). Our coverage team lost Hurd. Early in camp Buehler doesn't sound any farther along or close to consistent.
Lots of questions and holes in this team. I think we have some excellent talent, and am really excited about Garrett coaching and Ryan's scheme and coaching, but the depth is SCARY.
Been a patient Front Office, but I think we need to sign a few vets if we want to make the playoffs this year. One or two injuries at the wrong spots and we would have gaping holes. Which players would provide an upgrade over the draft picks or journeyman guys we are trying to develop at moment though. Not a ton left out there. Maybe we are waiting for more cuts from teams, but that is scary too.
8-8 is my prediction based on lack of depth. 9-7 if we can avoid significant injuries. Add a couple of savy pieces (harder and harder as each day goes by) maybe 10-6. Coaching/scheme improvement will help, but only so much.
LarryCanadian
The contracts they have given Spears, Free, Kosier, and K Coleman (decent big guy - rotation role player) were reasonable. Don't think they overpaid for any of these guys. Tought to lose Bowen, and even if it works out to a short term deal in Wash, that is a lot of dough.
BUT, I hate our depth and there isn't a ton of impact guys that would significantly upgrade our roster available in free-agency. We cut 4 guys with starter type snaps.
So the team is relying on the return of injured players and better/different creative coaching to improve this year. PLUS the "hoped for" return to form of Spencer, Austin, Rat, Jenkins, Newman.
I think from that standpoint we are in trouble compared to teams in our own division like Eagles, and probably the Giants as well. We lack depth and have a lot of question marks still.
I worry in particular about:
Offense:
OT if Free is hurt or 1st Rounder takes time like he very well could/should (particularly with short off season). I don't like Barron and our other young guys are pretty darn raw.
OG - Holland is ok, Kosier is coming back but has been hurt. Not much behind them with any experience. 4th round pick sounds promising, but again, how ready could he be?
C - Gurode IS hurt, and heavy because he hasn't been able to train much. 1 year older and even wonkier slowly degenerative knee(s). Costa is pretty raw and unproven and only started like 1 game.
OLINE Depth is terrible at the moment, even if we hit on this years draft. I'd like to see them try and get O Kreutz who was cut from the Bears as a depth guy, or if Gurode recovers and had to go to guard for a game or two, Kreutz could take over at centre?
FB:
I hope Chapas emerges, because Gronk wasn't great last year. With Jason Garrett liking a bit more of the traditional running game, FB might be more important and we haven't had an impact one since Moose. I know Phillips at TE might play some HB/FB and I REALLY like him, but this might be an area to address late in camp if a savy vet is available.
WR:
We really could use a dependable vet. If Austin or Dez is hurt, I think we are in trouble at WR.
RB, TE, QB are solid and I don't worry about them.
Defense:
I think Ryan's scheme will be biggest help for everything, but do we have any pocket collapsers or pressure guys at DE at all now. Bowen got a bit of pressure on QB, but we seem to have a pure 4 man run stopper rotation now: Spears, Olshansky, Coleman, Lissemore - none of these are QB pressurers.
NOW, with a slimmer Rat (please don't wear this guy out at training camp, rest him), I think we will use him for the "pressure" guy, BUT, that leaves Josh Brent as only true nose-tackle 3-4 type on team no?
I think we could use one more situational pass rusher for front end, maybe a role player type for 3rd downs. Remember, Spears was taken out for many 3rd down plays. Who fills that role now. OR, if that is Rat's new role, then we could use some depth in terms of a big strong NT type - to back up Brent.
If Rat or Brent go down with injury we are in trouble again.
ILB - we have a lot of injury concerns there. Can Lee (who looks like a smart emerging defensive leader) stay on field. Our 2nd round draft pick is 90%. Brooking is older an already hurt and we rely way too much on him and James who have a lot of miles. One injury away from potentially starting a player whose name 95% of Cowboy fans haven't heard of.
OLB - nice to hear reports that Butler and Williams seem to have the lightbulb coming on. Need Spencer to rebound in a big way. If Butler and Williams are just training camp wonders and can't rotate in, then another pass rushing OLB role player would help, especially if Spencer plays like last year. BUT, I think we are probably OK at this position and I hope they give Butler and Williams a ton of snaps and really push them and rotate them in a lot. These guys NEED to step up.
Secondary - BRUTAL. I just am not sold that Jenkins will fully go back to being the player he was 2 years ago. We had a great pass rush and pressure front line that year, and not sure, no matter how creative Ryan's D is this year, that we have the horses to consistently get pressure. It might be expecting too much.
Scandrick showed improvement last year, but I'd love a solid vet corner added to mix.
Newman is a year older and seemed to make a lot of mistakes last year.
None of our guys seem to turn around and have eye on ball.
Safety is just a mess. Sign Elam already, just because he knows Ryan's system and can help organize the secondary. Nobody else is left. I'd love a Sharper for a year or someone like that, but doesn't seem to be any interest from Front office to go the "old" guy route, and I get it, because you overpay. BUT, I'd rather overpay a Sharper for 1 year or 2, than overpay Sensi for 3-4 years, and you're going to have to. I just don't think Sensi is worth the kind of money he wants, and he really disappointed after his 1st season with us.
This is where I fault the Front Office. We have had safety issues for years now and we have NOT found even one consistent solution there. I am almost certain this is going to be a HUGE achilles heel for us AGAIN this year.
I shudder to think of what we start the season with at safety, and that is even before Kwasi or Church tweak a hamstring or something like that.
I have no idea what special teams will be like, outside our punter and long snapper. Who returns kicks/punts (every year that isn't solved). Our coverage team lost Hurd. Early in camp Buehler doesn't sound any farther along or close to consistent.
Lots of questions and holes in this team. I think we have some excellent talent, and am really excited about Garrett coaching and Ryan's scheme and coaching, but the depth is SCARY.
Been a patient Front Office, but I think we need to sign a few vets if we want to make the playoffs this year. One or two injuries at the wrong spots and we would have gaping holes. Which players would provide an upgrade over the draft picks or journeyman guys we are trying to develop at moment though. Not a ton left out there. Maybe we are waiting for more cuts from teams, but that is scary too.
8-8 is my prediction based on lack of depth. 9-7 if we can avoid significant injuries. Add a couple of savy pieces (harder and harder as each day goes by) maybe 10-6. Coaching/scheme improvement will help, but only so much.
LarryCanadian