- Messages
- 59,644
- Reaction score
- 58,114
I wanted to get a feel for how well we've done in free agency thus far. I also wanted to compare our pickups with other clubs.
So, I took a third party’s, Scout.com, ratings of available free agents. Scout.com uses the star rating system (i.e. 5 stars = excellent, 4 stars = very good, ,etc.). For a five star player, I assigned an A+, four star player received a B+, etc. Afterwards, I averaged all FA players’ grades per team. The league average so far has been a C-. These were the results so far. (Disclaimer: my data came from Scout.com and it may not be totally updated):
So, I took a third party’s, Scout.com, ratings of available free agents. Scout.com uses the star rating system (i.e. 5 stars = excellent, 4 stars = very good, ,etc.). For a five star player, I assigned an A+, four star player received a B+, etc. Afterwards, I averaged all FA players’ grades per team. The league average so far has been a C-. These were the results so far. (Disclaimer: my data came from Scout.com and it may not be totally updated):
PHP:
Dallas Cowboys
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
WR Terrell Owens UFA 5.0 A
OT Jason Fabini UFA 3.0 C
OLB Akin Ayodele UFA 3.0 C
OG Kyle Kosier UFA 2.0 D
TE Ryan Hannam UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.8 C
PHP:
Arizona Cardinals
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
RB Edgerrin James UFA 5.0 A
FB Obafemi Ayanbadejo UFA 2.0 D
DT Kendrick Clancy UFA 2.0 D
Overall 3.0 C+
PHP:
Atlanta Falcons
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
S Lawyer Milloy UFA 4.0 B
FB Fred McCrary UFA 1.0 F
S Omare Lowe UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.0 D+
PHP:
Baltimore Ravens
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
RB Jamal Lewis UFA 4.0 B
RB Mike Anderson UFA 3.0 C
DT Trevor Pryce UFA 3.0 C
DT Justin Bannan UFA 2.0 D
OLB Bart Scott UFA 2.0 D
RB Musa Smith RFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.5 C-
PHP:
Buffalo Bills
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
DT Larry Tripplett UFA 3.0 C
WR Josh Reed UFA 2.0 D
WR Andre Davis UFA 2.0 D
S Matt Bowen UFA 2.0 D
TE Robert Royal UFA 1.0 F
OG Greg Jerman UFA 1.0 F
C Mike Schneck UFA 1.0 F
OLB Mario Haggan RFA 1.0 F
Overall 1.6 F
PHP:
Carolina Panthers
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
RB Deshaun Foster Fran. 4.0 B
C Justin Hartwig UFA 3.0 C
DT Ma'ake Kemoeatu UFA 3.0 C
DT Damione Lewis UFA 2.0 D
QB Chris Weinke UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.6 C-
PHP:
Chicago Bears
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
TE John Gilmore UFA 2.0 D
OG Terrence Metcalf UFA 2.0 D
CB Dante Wesley UFA 2.0 D
Overall 2.0 D+
PHP:
Cincinnati Bengals
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
S Dexter Jackson UFA 2.0 D
S Anthony Mitchell UFA 2.0 D
Overall 2.0 D+
PHP:
Cleveland Browns
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
C LeCharles Bentley UFA 5.0 A
OLB Willie McGinest UFA 4.0 B
P Dave Zastudil UFA 4.0 B
WR Joe Jurevicius UFA 3.0 C
OT Kevin Shaffer UFA 3.0 C
DE Orpheus Roye UFA 3.0 C
OG Bob Hallen UFA 2.0 D
DT Ted Washington UFA 2.0 D
TE Darnell Dinkins UFA 1.0 F
Overall 3.0 C+
PHP:
Denver Broncos
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
DT Gerard Warren UFA 3.0 C
RB Ron Dayne UFA 2.0 D
MLB Nate Webster UFA 2.0 D
Overall 2.3 C-
PHP:
Detroit Lions
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
QB Jon Kitna UFA 3.0 C
WR Corey Bradford UFA 3.0 C
QB Josh McCown UFA 2.0 D
RB Shawn Bryson UFA 2.0 D
WR Eddie Drummond UFA 2.0 D
TE Dan Campbell UFA 2.0 D
DE Kalimba Edwards UFA 2.0 D
RB Arlen Harris UFA 1.0 F
OT Victor Rogers RFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.0 D+
PHP:
Green Bay Packers
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
RB Ahman Green UFA 4.0 B
DE Aaron Kampman UFA 4.0 B
DT Ryan Pickett UFA 3.0 C
S Marquand Manuel UFA 3.0 C
FB William Henderson UFA 2.0 D
WR Rod Gardner UFA 2.0 D
OT Kevin Barry UFA 2.0 D
DT Kenny Peterson RFA 2.0 D
DT Cullen Jenkins RFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.6 C-
PHP:
Houston Texans
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
QB Sage Rosenfels UFA 2.0 D
DE Anthony Weaver UFA 2.0 D
FB Jameel Cook UFA 1.0 F
TE Matt Murphy UFA 1.0 F
Overall 1.5 D-
PHP:
Indianapolis Colts
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
WR Reggie Wayne UFA 4.0 B
K Jose Cortez UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.5 C-
PHP:
Jacksonville Jaguars
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
CB Brian Williams UFA 3.0 C
OT Stockar McDougle UFA 2.0 D
CB Terry Cousin UFA 2.0 D
DE Marcellus Wiley UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.0 D+
PHP:
Kansas City Chiefs
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
DE Carlos Hall UFA 3.0 C
QB Damon Huard UFA 1.0 F
TE Kendall Gammon UFA 1.0 F
Overall 1.7 F
PHP:
Miami Dolphins
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
OT L.J. Shelton UFA 3.0 C
RB Travis Minor UFA 2.0 D
OLB Sedrick Hodge UFA 2.0 D
CB Andre' Goodman UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.0 D+
PHP:
Minnesota Vikings
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
RB Chester Taylor UFA 3.0 C
WR Koren Robinson UFA 3.0 C
K Ryan Longwell UFA 3.0 C
OG Jason Whittle UFA 2.0 D
OLB Ben Leber UFA 2.0 D
S Willie Offord UFA 2.0 D
Overall 2.5 C-
PHP:
New England Patriots
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
WR Reche Caldwell UFA 3.0 C
OG Ross Tucker UFA 2.0 D
OLB Don Davis UFA 2.0 D
S Artrell Hawkins UFA 2.0 D
CB Hank Poteat UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.0 D+
PHP:
New Orleans Saints
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
QB Drew Brees UFA 5.0 A
RB Michael Bennett UFA 3.0 C
OLB Scott Fujita UFA 2.0 D
OG Dwayne Ledford UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.8 C
PHP:
New York Giants
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
CB Sam Madison UFA 3.0 C
OT Bob Whitfield UFA 2.0 D
S Will Demps UFA 2.0 D
CB R.W. McQuarters UFA 2.0 D
CB Jason Bell UFA 2.0 D
S Quentin Harris UFA 1.0 F
CB Brandon Williams UFA 1.0 F
Overall 1.9 D
PHP:
New York Jets
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
DE Kimo von Oelhoffen UFA 2.0 D
OLB Matt Chatham UFA 1.0 F
Overall 1.5 D-
PHP:
Oakland Raiders
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
S Derrick Gibson UFA 2.0 D
TE Randal Williams UFA 1.0 F
OG Corey Hulsey UFA 1.0 F
S Jarrod Cooper UFA 1.0 F
Overall 1.3 F
PHP:
Philadelphia Eagles
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
DE Darren Howard UFA 4.0 B
QB Jeff Garcia UFA 2.0 D
WR Jabar Gaffney UFA 2.0 D
TE Matt Schobel UFA 2.0 D
OLB Shawn Barber UFA 2.0 D
WR Darnerien McCants UFA 1.0 F
DE Juqua Thomas UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.0 D+
PHP:
Pittsburgh Steelers
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
CB Deshea Townsend UFA 3.0 C
QB Charlie Batch UFA 2.0 D
OT Barrett Brooks UFA 2.0 D
DE Rodney Bailey UFA 2.0 D
DE Brett Keisel UFA 2.0 D
TE Jerame Tuman UFA 1.0 F
S Ryan Clark UFA 1.0 F
Overall 1.9 D
PHP:
San Diego Chargers
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
S Marlon McCree UFA 3.0 C
TE Aaron Shea UFA 2.0 D
Overall 2.5 C-
PHP:
San Francisco 49ers
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
WR Antonio Bryant UFA 3.0 C
MLB Derek Smith UFA 3.0 C
K Joe Nedney UFA 3.0 C
CB Walt Harris UFA 2.0 D
FB Chris Hetherington UFA 1.0 F
WR Bryan Gilmore UFA 1.0 F
OLB Brandon Moore UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.0 D+
PHP:
Seattle Seahawks
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
RB Shaun Alexander UFA 5.0 A
DT Rocky Bernard UFA 4.0 B
WR Peter Warrick UFA 2.0 D
DT Russell Davis UFA 2.0 D
Overall 3.3 F
PHP:
St. Louis Rams
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
OLB Will Witherspoon UFA 5.0 A
WR Isaac Bruce UFA 4.0 B
DT La'Roi Glover UFA 3.0 C
S Corey Chavous UFA 3.0 C
QB Gus Frerotte UFA 2.0 D
CB Fakhir Brown UFA 2.0 D
Overall 3.2 C+
PHP:
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
DT Chris Hovan UFA 3.0 C
K Matt Bryant UFA 3.0 C
OG Toniu Fonoti UFA 2.0 D
CB Juran Bolden UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.3 F
PHP:
Tennessee Titans
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
WR David Givens UFA 4.0 B
C Kevin Mawae UFA 3.0 C
S Chris Hope UFA 3.0 C
OLB David Thornton UFA 2.0 D
Overall 3.0 C+
PHP:
Washington Commanders
Pos Name Type Rank Grade
WR Antwaan Randle El UFA 4.0 B
S Adam Archuleta UFA 4.0 B
WR Brandon Lloyd RFA 3.0 C
OLB Andre Carter UFA 3.0 C
FB Rock Cartwright UFA 2.0 D
TE Christian Fauria UFA 2.0 D
QB Todd Collins UFA 1.0 F
DT Cedric Killings UFA 1.0 F
MLB Khary Campbell UFA 1.0 F
Overall 2.3 C-
