Projected QB performance rankings for the 2023 season

[erod]

This should be fun:

My PROJECTED gut-feel rankings of what quarterbacks will be this year, not what they've been in the past:

1. Mahomes
2. Burrow
3. Rodgers
4. Allen
5. Herbert
6. Hurts
7. Lawrence
8. G Smith
9. Goff
10. Jackson
11. Cousins
12. Purdy
13. Prescott
14. Tua
15. Stafford
16. Watson
17. D Jones
18. Murray
19. Garrapolo
20. Tannehill
21. Carr
22. Pickett

The rest: Wilson, M Jones, Young, Stroud, Fields, Ridder, Love, Mayfield, Howell, Richardson

 

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

I think Rogers is gonna have his "OMG I'm old" year this year....just like Brady had his last year.

Brady was the outlier....but let's not forget all the other greats like Manning, Marino, Elway, Favre etc etc all kinda lost IT in their late 30's....

I think the Jets honeymoon comes to a crashing end....quick...and is one of the big stories this year

 

[erod]

I think Rogers is gonna have his "OMG I'm old" year this year....just like Brady had his last year.

Brady was the outlier....but let's not forget all the other greats like Manning, Marino, Elway, Favre etc etc all kinda lost IT in their late 30's....

I think the Jets honeymoon comes to a crashing end....quick...and is one of the big stories this year

That's possible. They have a good team, but it's primarily defensive. Their offensive line has to be better for sure.

 

[Swagger]

This should be fun:

My PROJECTED gut-feel rankings of what quarterbacks will be this year, not what they've been in the past:

1. Mahomes
2. Burrow
3. Rodgers
4. Allen
5. Herbert
6. Hurts
7. Lawrence
8. G Smith
9. Goff
10. Jackson
11. Cousins
12. Purdy
13. Prescott
14. Tua
15. Stafford
16. Watson
17. D Jones
18. Murray
19. Garrapolo
20. Tannehill
21. Carr
22. Pickett

The rest: Wilson, M Jones, Young, Stroud, Fields, Ridder, Love, Mayfield, Howell, Richardson

I'm pretty much with you on the top 10 except swapping Jackson to #8 and dropping out Geno Smith and placing Fields at #10.

I think Jimmy G will have a good season. I would push him up to 11th with Tua in 12th. The rest much of a muchness.

I could see Darnold starting and keeping the role for the 49ers.

 

[ActualCowboysFan]

Unqualified random speculation really needed their own thread

 

[movaughn88]

Well before this thread turns into an open bonfire, good for posting your list. I disagree significantly on several (Rodgers down near #10, Geno down near #15, Purdy will be in #20s, Dak closer to #7, Carr up into top #10)

But hey you put your thoughts out there and we'll just have to see how the season goes.

 

[Denim Chicken]

This should be fun:

My PROJECTED gut-feel rankings of what quarterbacks will be this year, not what they've been in the past:

1. Mahomes
2. Burrow
3. Rodgers
4. Allen
5. Herbert
6. Hurts
7. Lawrence
8. G Smith
9. Goff
10. Jackson
11. Cousins
12. Purdy
13. Prescott
14. Tua
15. Stafford
16. Watson
17. D Jones
18. Murray
19. Garrapolo
20. Tannehill
21. Carr
22. Pickett

The rest: Wilson, M Jones, Young, Stroud, Fields, Ridder, Love, Mayfield, Howell, Richardson

What's the metric? Yards, TDs, rating, EPA, Wins?

 

[CowboyFrog]

What's the metric? Yards, TDs, rating, EPA, Wins?

Gut feeling.. this is literally how his gut would rank them....Chicken pot pie nearly made the "Others" list

 

[Cowboy_svt]

imo tua is too low, i think people forget how good he was to start the season before he got knocked around too much in the head.

 

[5Stars]

Gut feeling.. this is literally how his gut would rank them....Chicken pot pie nearly made the "Others" list

Chicken Pot Pie...three of my favorite things.

 

[erod]

What's the metric? Yards, TDs, rating, EPA, Wins?

Quarterback play across the season in meaningful moments against good teams.

Statistics mean nothing to me.

 

[erod]

Gut feeling.. this is literally how his gut would rank them....Chicken pot pie nearly made the "Others" list

Because stats are for fantasy football dorks and moms.

 

[CowboyFrog]

Because stats are for fantasy football dorks and moms.

better be nice to your mom your gut is gonna want that Chicken pot pie again.. How is it going to rank NFL QB's when its empty?

 

[pitt33]

Chicken Pot Pie...three of my favorite things.

I got it.

 

[Mac_MaloneV1]

Quarterback play across the season in meaningful moments against good teams.

Statistics mean nothing to me.

So in other words, gobbledygook.

Guess wins don't mean anything to you either.

 

[Kevinicus]

Quarterback play across the season in meaningful moments against good teams.

Statistics mean nothing to me.

How do you measure that?

 

[CowboyRoy]

I think Rogers is gonna have his "OMG I'm old" year this year....just like Brady had his last year.

Brady was the outlier....but let's not forget all the other greats like Manning, Marino, Elway, Favre etc etc all kinda lost IT in their late 30's....

I think the Jets honeymoon comes to a crashing end....quick...and is one of the big stories this year

Brady had a bad last year because his Oline was terrible. Thats how important Oline is to QB's.

Jets are completely stacked on both sides. Only big issue is their Oline. Which can be a big issue.

 

[CowboyRoy]

This should be fun:

My PROJECTED gut-feel rankings of what quarterbacks will be this year, not what they've been in the past:

1. Mahomes
2. Burrow
3. Rodgers
4. Allen
5. Herbert
6. Hurts
7. Lawrence
8. G Smith
9. Goff
10. Jackson
11. Cousins
12. Purdy
13. Prescott
14. Tua
15. Stafford
16. Watson
17. D Jones
18. Murray
19. Garrapolo
20. Tannehill
21. Carr
22. Pickett

The rest: Wilson, M Jones, Young, Stroud, Fields, Ridder, Love, Mayfield, Howell, Richardson

First off, Picket is going to sail up this list really really fast. That kid is the best young QB in the NFL as far as I am concerned.

As usual, you heard it HERE first!!!!

 

[roy31]

Where’s Lance!!??
Sorry .. lol

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

First off, Picket is going to sail up this list really really fast. That kid is the best young QB in the NFL as far as I am concerned.

As usual, you heard it HERE first!!!!

Bookmarked