Ring of Honor - Yay or Nay

[Badattitude]

Danny White

Nate(your friendly neighborhood weedman)Newton

Jay Novacek

Charles Haley

Deion Sanders

 

[aikemirv]

Novacek- IMO is the only one to go in.

 

[Chief]

Danny White

Nate(your friendly neighborhood weedman)Newton

Jay Novacek

Charles Haley

Deion Sanders

None of the above.

The first three were good players, but not great.

Deion and Haley sort of fall into the same category. There were great players, but didn't spend enough of their careers with the Cowboys.

If you put them in, then you need to go back and put in Dan Reeves (as a coach), Mike Ditka, Lance Alworth, Herb Adderly, etc.

 

[Doomsday101]

None of the above.

The first three were good players, but not great.

Deion and Haley sort of fall into the same category. There were great players, but didn't spend enough of their careers with the Cowboys.

If you put them in, then you need to go back and put in Dan Reeves (as a coach), Mike Ditka, Lance Alworth, Herb Adderly, etc.

I agree but it does make you think with todays FA how many years must a player play on the team to be considered for the ROH?

 

[Chocolate Lab]

Exactly, Chief... Nay to all of those.

 

[CrazyCowboy]

Nay to all of them but Jay Novachek would get some strong consideration. Then I would still say Nay........

 

[jman]

Danny White - Yea (Most of the records Aikman broke were Danny's, not Roger's) And especially if he would have won a Super Bowl as the starting QB. But mostly because I don't think he gets the credit he deserves.

Nate(your friendly neighborhood weedman)Newton - Nay

Jay Novacek - I'm wishy-washy on this one...when he retired, we all saw what he meant to this team. But I also felt that way about Preston Pearson.

Charles Haley - Nay

Deion Sanders - Nay

 

[jsond]

most of the guys listed were excellent pieces of the puzzle that helped us win superbowls (other than Danny). But none are deserving, esp. considering some of guys who are that are not in their yet.

 

[Badattitude]

I think Haley is a HOF'er as is Deion ....and you know what I think Jay Novacek is a HOF TE....Yep. I think he was the BEST at his position in the game for quite a few years...that to me is a HOF...Now do I think he gets in? NO. But JJ may give him a ROH spot.

 

[ABQCOWBOY]

I think Haley is a HOF'er as is Deion ....and you know what I think Jay Novacek is a HOF TE....Yep. I think he was the BEST at his position in the game for quite a few years...that to me is a HOF...Now do I think he gets in? NO. But JJ may give him a ROH spot.

Brett Jones, Todd Christianson, Mark Bavaro, and Tony Gonzales were all better.

 

[The30YardSlant]

None of the above.

The first three were good players, but not great.

Deion and Haley sort of fall into the same category. There were great players, but didn't spend enough of their careers with the Cowboys.

If you put them in, then you need to go back and put in Dan Reeves (as a coach), Mike Ditka, Lance Alworth, Herb Adderly, etc.

nm :bang2: