Would you draft Jalen Milroe to sit behind Dak for 2 years? (2nd round )

[atlantacowboy]

We need a back-up QB, but if the idea is just to have someone who can step in and win some games, I don't Milroe is the guy. He's going to struggle in the NFL throwing the ball.

 

[Dalmations202]

I don't think Milroe will fall to the 5th, and I think Dallas has too many holes to draft a developmental guy before the 5th. So YES, only if he falls to the 5th round, not in the 2nd.

 

[gtb1943]

LOL ....every player's tape on U tube is a highlight reel of their best games, nothing new. I'm not saying the kid is the second coming of CJ Stroud but he certainly isn't as bad as some here would lead you to think. That reel clearly shows some potential but as OP ( draft guru ) pointed out, he needs patience and coaching. We have too many holes to draft him but I would def pull the trigger if he's there in the 5th.

Now that I think about it, he doesn't look that much different from Hurts when he lost his college-starting job to Tua. They called him an RB playing QB. How is that working out......lol

Here's Dana's take

As an athlete and person, he belongs in the first round. But can he develop the passing consistency needed to grow into an NFL starter? Milroe will be worth the chance at some point on Day Two, but where is that sweet spot



BTW......I know this doesn't mean a lot but he is smart as heck.........didn't know he was a Rhode scholar

been some very smart guys who were dumb at football. physical ability, character, football smarts
you need all three to be a top QB. Now some of them have failed some at character, but of the three bluntly that is the least important. Milroe has shown very little football smarts.

 

[exciter]

LOL ....every player's tape on U tube is a highlight reel of their best games, nothing new. I'm not saying the kid is the second coming of CJ Stroud but he certainly isn't as bad as some here would lead you to think. That reel clearly shows some potential but as OP ( draft guru ) pointed out, he needs patience and coaching. We have too many holes to draft him but I would def pull the trigger if he's there in the 5th.

Now that I think about it, he doesn't look that much different from Hurts when he lost his college-starting job to Tua. They called him an RB playing QB. How is that working out......lol

Here's Dana's take

As an athlete and person, he belongs in the first round. But can he develop the passing consistency needed to grow into an NFL starter? Milroe will be worth the chance at some point on Day Two, but where is that sweet spot



BTW......I know this doesn't mean a lot but he is smart as heck.........didn't know he was a Rhode scholar

Hurts was way ahead of him as a passer in part thanks to his time in Oklahoma.
Millie has never been able to process beyond his first read and there’s nothing to indicate that he can. He’s an UDFA passer who will be overdrafted based on he can run and the delusion he can be developed!

 

[805BoysInBlue]

We just gave up a 4th for another qb who can't throw, now we're gonna throw another pick away? Smh

 

[beware_d-ware]

I like betting on toolsy athletes at QB, but Milroe looks rawer than Trey Lance.

 

[Hawkeye0202]

Millie has never been able to process beyond his first read and there’s nothing to indicate that he can

LOL.....very few college QBs go through progression reads coz their first read as a rule is always open. It's rare college QBs check down. There is a reason we hear little or nothing college defenses.

Either way, let's move on.........shoot, even Dana is saying he's a 2-day pick but you don't seem to think he belongs in the position at all. That's fine, I disagree .........

 

[gimmesix]

Dak's contract has an out after the 2027 season.........

I think we should take a QB with one of our fifth-round picks. If Milroe is available in the fifth round, then sure. Then, I think we should plan to rinse and repeat the next year and the next year and so on. The only exception to that is if we move on from Dak.

 

[gtb1943]

I said take him in the fourth because we do not have one.
Problem solved

 

[darthseinfeld]

Dak's contract has an out after the 2027 season.........

No. Day 2 guys are not day 1 guys for a reason. Think about this, how many day 2 guys are doing well in NFL. Hurts, and thats probably about it. Other than him, the best success stories I can think of are Dalton and Carr

 

[cowboyec]

ohhhh...it'd be hard not to hand in that card if he's still on the board.
i like milroe better than others do.
i think he'll be a good pro.
i think i would.
jerry won't.

 

[gtb1943]

ohhhh...it'd be hard not to hand in that card if he's still on the board.
i like milroe better than others do.
i think he'll be a good pro.
i think i would.
jerry won't.

I have seen nothing from Milroe that says he will be anything but a bust; maybe a backup at best

 

[Tabascocat]

No, he is a Trey Lance.

 

[RogerDodger12]

Watch the OU game and get back to me. He was tied up in knots.

 

[BrAinPaiNt]

No thank you.