Dak vs Wentz

CalPolyTechnique · May 11, 2020

jaythecowboy said:
Yes, they would be. I've said for years that had Romo come in for the playoffs after Dak went 13-3 in his rookie season that Romo would get the credit for the playoff run. The difference in your hypothetical scenario is even if Dalton were to do that now Dak has already played in three playoff games, going toe to toe with Aaron Rodgers and Russell Wilson, and outplayed Jared Goff. Wentz has yet to produce anything in the playoffs.

What do you mean “Yes, they would be?”

OmerV · May 11, 2020

Williamsboys said:
Super Bowl rings (whether he played or not)
Wentz-1
Dak-0

By this evaluation a 3rd string OG on the Eagles in 2017 was better than Zach Martin. Simply being on the bench while his team won the Super Bowl doesn't make Wentz a Super Bowl winning QB. That was Foles.

Big_D · May 11, 2020

StuckMojo said:
Just because philly gave a bad contract doesn’t mean Dallas should!

This is the truth. Eagles and Rams overpaid, now the Cowboys have to follow suit. Both teams are stupid, but that sets market value. What a joke!

Kaiser · May 11, 2020

Big_D said:
This is the truth. Eagles and Rams overpaid, now the Cowboys have to follow suit. Both teams are stupid, but that sets market value. What a joke!

No body wants to overpay Dak but he is still a safer bet. Wentz has injury questions and his own locker room calling him out. Goff's stats dropped a lot since the league adjusted to McVay's schemes. Dak isn't a top five player but neither are Wentz or Goff, for sure.

OmerV · May 11, 2020

Williamsboys said:
Super Bowl rings (whether he played or not)
Wentz-1
Dak-0

Super Bowl rings (whether he played or not)
Jason Garrett-1
Dan Marino-0

Nav22 · May 11, 2020

OmerV said:
Super Bowl rings (whether he played or not)
Jason Garrett-1
Dan Marino-0

Actually, Garrett won 2. So he’s also better than Favre and Rodgers and on the same level as Peyton Manning.

jaythecowboy · May 11, 2020

CalPolyTechnique said:
What do you mean “Yes, they would be?”

I was saying those same arguments would be valid if Dak had a great season but didn't play in the playoffs

OmerV · May 11, 2020

Nav22 said:
Actually, Garrett won 2. So he’s also better than Favre and Rodgers and on the same level as Peyton Manning.

You're right. I wasn't thinking.

CalPolyTechnique · May 11, 2020

jaythecowboy said:
I was saying those same arguments would be valid if Dak had a great season but didn't play in the playoffs

I don’t believe it for one second. The same folks hanging their hats on this argument would be vigorously defending Dak’s contribution (and rightfully so) to the season in the hypothetical I posed.

Again, folks are trying to equate Garrett’s spot start against Green Bay in 1994 to what Wentz did in 2017 (13 games).

It’s disingenuous and hypocritical.

jaythecowboy · May 11, 2020

CalPolyTechnique said:
I don’t believe it for one second. The same folks hanging their hats on this argument would be vigorously defending Dak’s contribution (and rightfully so) to the season in the hypothetical I posed.

Again, folks are trying to equate Garrett’s spot start against Green Bay in 1994 to what Wentz did in 2017 (13 games).

It’s disingenuous and hypocritical.

I can't speak for anyone else but I would feel the same way. Wentz had a great regular season but people give him credit like he won the Super Bowl when he didn't play in the playoffs at all that year.

JoeKing · May 11, 2020

StuckMojo said:
Just because philly gave a bad contract doesn’t mean Dallas should!

It's not a bad contract, it's market value. Dak is entitled to market value as well and he's certainly worth more than Wentz.

StuckMojo · May 11, 2020

JoeKing said:
It's not a bad contract, it's market value. Dak is entitled to market value as well and he's certainly worth more than Wentz.

Opinions vary

JoeKing · May 11, 2020

StuckMojo said:
Opinions vary

Market value is opinion-oriented? I guess you say the same thing about the Kelley Bluebook.

StuckMojo · May 11, 2020

JoeKing said:
Market value is opinion-oriented? I guess you say the same thing about the Kelley Bluebook.

My opinion is you don’t overpay for an item just because everyone else is.

JoeKing · May 11, 2020

StuckMojo said:
My opinion is you don’t overpay for an item just because everyone else is.

If "everyone" is paying that price then that is what it's worth. You don't "overpay" if you pay the price "everyone" else is paying.

StuckMojo · May 11, 2020

JoeKing said:
If "everyone" is paying that price then that is what it's worth. You don't "overpay" if you pay the price "everyone" else is paying.

Maybe I should say I’m not paying USDA Prime prices for USDA Select

JoeKing · May 11, 2020

StuckMojo said:
Maybe I should say I’m not paying USDA Prime prices for USDA Select

That's your prerogative. My grandpa use to call that being thrifty. I call it being a cheapskate or a tightwad. JJ is no tightwad.

StuckMojo · May 11, 2020

JoeKing said:
That's your prerogative. My grandpa use to call that being thrifty. I call it being a cheapskate or a tightwad. JJ is no tightwad.

Not being cheap being smart.

JoeKing · May 11, 2020

StuckMojo said:
Not being cheap being smart.

Whatever you need to tell yourself, right?

Redline360 · May 11, 2020

Lol KBB is a laughing stock to car enthusiasts. Kbb is more used for generic cars such as camry or civics.

Dak vs Wentz

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Diehard

Well-Known Member

Diehard

Well-Known Member

Diehard

Well-Known Member

Diehard

Well-Known Member

Diehard

Well-Known Member