Every team gets their best players and coaches of all time for one year. Who wins the Superbowl?

[Floatyworm]

The Detroit Lions.....the amount of talent they could line up....would be down right scary.....

Stafford
Sanders
Calvin Johnson
Suh
Jerry Ball
Pat Swilling
Fairley
Spielman

 

[kskboys]

Patriots

they have the goat coach, qb, te, and wr

Niners have the goat QB, HC, S, WR, LB, and FB of all time.

 

[Northern_Cowboy]

It comes down to either the Cowboys,49''s, Steelers or Pats on any given Sunday

 

[Ring Leader]

Niners have the goat QB, HC, S, WR, LB, and FB of all time.

What are you drinking? I'll give you Rice & Lott but Brady, Belichick, Lawrence Taylor, and a ton of FBs better than Rathman never wore the urine and brick. And what 9er LB are you talking about?

 

[WillieBeamen]

Niners have the goat QB, HC, S, WR, LB, and FB of all time.

Imagine thinking Montana is better than Brady in 2020

 

[Buzzbait]

2007 Belichick/Brady

OR

1972 Shula/Griese

1972 Shula/Griese / Csonka

 

[ottawacowpoke]

Niners and its probably not that close.

Aikman and Staubach were good, but they dont compare to Young and Montana. The rest of the offense probably goes to the Niners save the RB and some Olineman.

Defense might be a little more even. Maybe Cowboys probably have an edge there.

Coaching definitely goes to the Niners.

who gets Charles Haley - Dallas or SF?

 

[INCowboysFan]

Dallas Roster:

QB: Staubach, Aikman
RB: Emmitt, TD
FB: Moose
TE: Witten
OT: Erik Williams, Rayfield Wright
OG: Larry Allen, Zach Martin
C: Fredrick, Stepnoski
WR: Irvin, Pearson, Hayes

DE: Haley, Ware
DT: Lilly, White
LB: Jordan, Howley, prime S. Lee
CB: Deion, Renfro
S: Woodson, Harris

 

[nobody]

It comes down to either the Cowboys,49''s, Steelers or Pats on any given Sunday

I was thinking the same thing..

Cowboys vs 49ers in NFC Championship
Steelers vs Patriots in AFC Championship

Cowboys vs Steelers most likely for SB.

Winner: Cowboys.

 

[CouchCoach]

GB, PIT, SF, DAL, NE, MIA and OAK. Any of those 7 franchises could do it and what you must first consider is not players but teams. To go with players is to commit the Dream Team mistake.

One thing all 7 of those teams had in common, incredible balance from O to D and from run to pass. And I can make a case for each of those 7 being the front runner.

 

[CowboyRoy]

who gets Charles Haley - Dallas or SF?

Dallas had better DE's than Haley. Niners can have him.

 

[ottawacowpoke]

Dallas had better DE's than Haley. Niners can have him.

Not necessarily disagreeing with you but who do you have in mind? Not sure how many HOF DEs have worn the star.

 

[Adreme]

Patriots

they have the goat coach, qb, te, and wr

GOAT WR is Jerry Rice. Every other WR is competing to be the 2nd best WR.

 

[WillieBeamen]

GOAT WR is Jerry Rice. Every other WR is competing to be the 2nd best WR.

The dude that used stickum?



Couldnt be my goat

 

[CowboyRoy]

Not necessarily disagreeing with you but who do you have in mind? Not sure how many HOF DEs have worn the star.

Ware for one, although I probably liked Haley better in big games.

 

[Adreme]

The dude that used stickum?



Couldnt be my goat

The guy who at 38 was still the best WR in football. The guy who shattered receiving records BEFORE the NFL became a passing league. There is just zero debate over the best WR in NFL history. Everyone else fights for second. There is not a gap between him and everyone else, there is chasm. Peak performance, longevity, numbers, titles, Jerry Rice had it all. His records will likely not be broken even when the NFL goes to 18 games and got them before the NFL went pass happy.

 

[GenoT]

Off the top of my head and in no particular order...

Bears
Colts
Cowboys
GB
Niners
Dolphins
Pats
NYG
Browns
Rams
Raiders
Maybe a coupla others...?

A lot of talent has passed through the NFL.

 

[Established1971]

2007 Belichick/Brady

OR

1972 Shula/Griese

that 72 team barely squeaked in that super bowl

 

[Established1971]

Off the top of my head and in no particular order...

Bears
Colts
Cowboys
GB
Niners
Dolphins
Pats
NYG
Browns
Rams
Raiders
Maybe a coupla others...?

A lot of talent has passed through the NFL.

wow not Steelers? imagine adding Polamulu and Greg lloyd and Bettis to those 70s teams

 

[GenoT]

wow not Steelers? imagine adding Polamulu and Greg lloyd and Bettis to those 70s teams

Sorry...I completely forgot them.

As I posted, it was off the top of my head; didn’t really give it a lot of detailed thought.