I have a lot more issues with the offense than defense.
Danny White is a better QB than Tony Romo.
I would take Dorsett over Elliott.
Terrell Owens over Bryant
Bob Hayes over Tony Hill.
Novacek over Witten
Billy Joe Dupree was so underrated.
I'd take Mark Stepnoski over Travis Frederick.
Kevin Gogan over Andre Gurode
Erik Williams over Neely. Before his injury Williams may have been the best OT the Cowboys have ever had, especially against Reggie White.
What is Dexter Coakley doing as the backup to Demarcus Ware?
Bill Bates as a backup CB? Just no. Bates was a special teams guy and maybe a safety but not CB.
This selection of players seems to be biased towards the guys who played more recently.