The 21 Worst Free Agent Moves in League History

Jerry and Stephen say this is required reading for all of you complaining about a lack of bigger name free agent shopping. Good number of former Cowboys. Any missing off this list they post?


https://www.usatoday.com/story/spor...-moves-history-albert-haynesworth/4720638001/

4 guys the Cowboys let go, with lots of whining from fans.

Emmitt, Murray, Harper, Larry Brown

*I* coulda told those teams that Harper and Brown weren't going to live up to their contracts.

Laurent Robinson would be another, though I wonder how he would have done w/o the concussions.
 
Joey Galloway is not on here...2 1st round picks for him.
A really bad move by the Cowboys but technically not a free agent. That move and the Roy Williams trade did set the franchise back quite a bit. I am surprised at all the former Cowboys on the list. Emmitt, Harper, Larry Brown, etc.
 
A lot of those were obvious has beens or just in poor situations. Murray was still a powerful runner, just used incorrectly on that Chip Kelly offense. It made me wonder why they bothered signing him.

A lot of those examples are exactly how the Cowboys operate. Reminds me of the Poe, McCoy, Griffen signings.
 
Philly really saved our *** swooping in at the last minute to pick up Awsomewa, the Haynesworth saga was really bizarre!
The haynesworth saga was on the Commanders as mich as it was on haynesworth. He told the team before he signed he didnt want to play nose. They signed him then made him play nose. So he was disinterested
 
Uh... giving up two 1st round picks for WR Roy Williams was the worst I've ever seen.
 
Man, that Demarco Murray situation was a long and hotly debated affair.

Uh... giving up two 1st round picks for WR Roy Williams was the worst I've ever seen.

That was a trade, not a free agency move.
 
The haynesworth saga was on the Commanders as mich as it was on haynesworth. He told the team before he signed he didnt want to play nose. They signed him then made him play nose. So he was disinterested

I remember that. I remember thinking, why the hell did they pay him all that money to pay nose? Which at the time is what he said in a round about way.
 
This is a very dumb take on the subject of free agency. It is out of context and in some case, like "he last only 3 years" does not mean the signing was a complete failure. But that is not the argument here.

Let's see the list of 50 or 100 quality free agent signings, like Tom Brady to the Tampa Bay Bucs, for example.

Or let's see the 500 first round draft picks who never lived up to their draft position. The fact is signing players always brings a risk. I will not argue that some teams, there is always one, are willing to overpay for talent. I think the Cowboys did that when they signed Zeke, DLaw, Cooper, Jaylon Smith and now Dak. But who is suggesting the Cowboys throw money at washed up players or misfits? Signing free agents takes the same talent evaluation as drafting college guys, except free agents have a record of playing in the NFL and good evaluators can see where guys are in the wrong system or other problems like that. With free agents you have a better understanding of coachability, work ethic, desire to win, etc.

Signing an all-pro player at a particular position with a proven record doing things you want him to do for your team is a lower risk than drafting a guy who looked good against mediocre talent in college.
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,579
Messages
14,546,625
Members
24,212
Latest member
JerryJonesSupporter
Back
Top