Where does Dak rank among all time Cowboy great QBs?

[TheMarathonContinues]

Yet another dumb thread about a QB only in his 6th season. How about he win a Super Bowl first before even being considered in the Top group of Dallas QB's.

He doesn't have to win anything. What did Aikman win? Because if I recall correctly he was on a team full of Hall of Famers so let's not act like "he" won a SB by himself.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

to pass romo he needs to get past div round or he is the same as romo.
And I think dak has more talent on this team, this year and better coaches than romo ever had.

Why does he have to get past the DIV round in order to pass someone who never did?

 

[CowboyFrog]

He doesn't have to win anything. What did Aikman win? Because if I recall correctly he was on a team full of Hall of Famers so let's not act like "he" won a SB by himself.

Lol come on now are you trying to get into a logical discussion with him about Dak?

 

[5Stars]

Roger Staubach
Troy Aikman
Tony Romo
Danny White
Jason Garrett (lul)
Cooper Rush (lul)

Is it too early to have this conversation? Did Fanbuzz nail it? I, personally, see Dak finishing his career on the upper half of said list.

Most will know why I included Garrett and Rush on the list... Purely for laughs but there was another reason too.

Well, I have heard from some posters that Dak is better than all of them and can make excuses why, like Aikman is not even better. So, why not just go ahead and say Dak is better than all of them? I mean that is the intention of this post. lol

 

[john van brocklin]

Roger Staubach
Troy Aikman
Tony Romo
Danny White
Jason Garrett (lul)
Cooper Rush (lul)

Is it too early to have this conversation? Did Fanbuzz nail it? I, personally, see Dak finishing his career on the upper half of said list.

Most will know why I included Garrett and Rush on the list... Purely for laughs but there was another reason too.

We won't know as he is still writing his story.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Lol come on now are you trying to get into a logical discussion with him about Dak?

I know man lol...I had a relapse from this offseason lol.

 

[KJJ]

I believe Dak is better than Aikman but can’t rank him ahead of him until he wins a couple of championships.

1. Staubach
2. Aikman
3. Dak
4. Romo
5. White
6. Meredith

 

[Whirlwin]

Roger Staubach
Troy Aikman
Tony Romo
Danny White
Jason Garrett (lul)
Cooper Rush (lul)

Is it too early to have this conversation? Did Fanbuzz nail it? I, personally, see Dak finishing his career on the upper half of said list.

Most will know why I included Garrett and Rush on the list... Purely for laughs but there was another reason too.

I don’t know why this is even a question right now. Can we finish at least halfway through his career. Before we ask a question like this

 

[5Stars]

I believe Dak is better than Aikman but can’t rank him ahead of him until he wins at least a couple of championships.

1. Staubach
2. Aikman
3. Dak
4. Romo
5. White
6. Meredith

"He doesn't have to win anything. What did Aikman win? Because if I recall correctly he was on a team full of Hall of Famers so let's not act like "he" won a SB by himself." @rocyaice

 

[PAPPYDOG]

Roger Staubach
Troy Aikman
Tony Romo
Danny White
Jason Garrett (lul)
Cooper Rush (lul)

Is it too early to have this conversation? Did Fanbuzz nail it? I, personally, see Dak finishing his career on the upper half of said list.

Most will know why I included Garrett and Rush on the list... Purely for laughs but there was another reason too.

1.DAK
2.Carter
3.Roger
4.Troy
5.Meredith
6.White
7.Longley
8.Kosar
9.Romo

The 1st 2 ranked one is headed to the HOF and Quincy was simply undervalued.
Now that between them they have 1 playoff win shouldn't sway the HOF committee of their yellow jackets.
Is everyone a Happy Pappy now?????

 

[ZekeTrain]

Roger/Troy, Troy/Roger. Order matters not.

Everyone else.

Until Dak wins a ring he is no better or worse than Romo or White. He is just a guy who played well but did not get it done.

 

[MWH1967]

Roger
Aikman
Dak

off of pure talent yes. the other group wants meaningful events.

 

[KJJ]

I don’t know why this is even a question right now. Can we finish at least halfway through his career. Before we ask a question like this

You asked a question immediately after Sunday’s game if we found ourselves a gem of a kicker and he’s yet to attempt a single NFL FG. lol

https://cowboyszone.com/threads/extra-points.487786/

 

[MWH1967]

1.DAK
2.Carter
3.Roger
4.Troy
5.Meredith
6.White
7.Longley
8.Kosar
9.Romo

The 1st 2 ranked one is headed to the HOF and Quincy was simply undervalued.
Now that between them they have 1 playoff win shouldn't sway the HOF committee of their yellow jackets.
Is everyone a Happy Pappy now?????

sorry, got to call nuckinfutZ on this one. wow!!

 

[CowboyFrog]

1.DAK
2.Carter
3.Roger
4.Troy
5.Meredith
6.White
7.Longley
8.Kosar
9.Romo

The 1st 2 ranked one is headed to the HOF and Quincy was simply undervalued.
Now that between them they have 1 playoff win shouldn't sway the HOF committee of their yellow jackets.
Is everyone a Happy Pappy now?????

Can you explain ...in detail what makes you feel like Dak and Quincey are the same QB talent wise?

 

[Cowboy4ever]

Way to early. Let him finish his career with Dallas and see where he is at. If should for some reason decide to give it all up today and never play another down of football, I doubt he would make anyone's top ten list of cowboy's QB... If he wins 6 SB then he would be 1 on almost anyone's list... got to let the kid finish playing before he gets slotted.. to date, he hasn't done anyhting that would even put him in the conversation... but he has a lot of football left to be played (we all hope).. but right now he is not worth a discussion,, ok ok.. i would put him above Babe today!

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Aikman and Staubach are at the top of the mountain.

Then everyone else.

You've got to lead this team to a championship before you get mentioned with those two.

 

[Beaker42]

White needs to go above Tony and Dak until Dak can get us to aNFCCG

Meant to redo and add just that but got in a hurry.

 

[PAPPYDOG]

Can you explain ...in detail what makes you feel like Dak and Quincey are the same QB talent wise?

There greatness....Leadership, arm accuracy, great pocket awareness, nice guys, the whole package.
Probably the GREATEST QB to wear a Cowboy uniform.
Wins and Superbowls are secondary when Greatness is on the field baby!!!
Don't you agree .....esp about Dak????

 

[Beaker42]

Aikman and Staubach are at the top of the mountain.

Then everyone else.

You've got to lead this team to a championship before you get mentioned with those two.

Really, more than one.