It All Leads Back to the Cowboys Philosophy of Acquiring QB Talent

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,515
Reaction score
16,130
My problem with Jerry Jones is that he finds a quarterback with the talent to start and he's done.

Since Jimmy's departure 29 years ago, the Cowboys have drafted 1 quarterback in the top three rounds of the NFL draft. Jerry has been forced to overpay his starting quarterbacks because he chooses to have zero other options at the position.

If the Cowboys had followed a simple process of drafting one quarterback in the top three rounds every three years he wouldn't have been forced to pay Dak a HOF/SB MVP contract. He would have created a level of competition that enhanced the performance at that position and he quite possibly would have had future excellent trade value.

Instead, he finds one potential starter and checks off the position for the next ten seasons. He fills the backup role with some marginal performer with limited skills and no future potential.

Now with a 17 game regular season schedule the need for additional options at QB become even more critical. So long as one quarterback is still in the 4 year rookie contract window, it isn't necessary to push a fifth of the cap in one direction. I can see doing this with a guy that took the team to a championship. Otherwise, Jerry is just paying for unrealized potential.

From 1993 to 2021 there have been 143 quarterbacks drafted in the top three rounds, an average of 4.5 quarterbacks per team and the Cowboys have drafted one..
 

lqmac1

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,557
Reaction score
3,615
My problem with Jerry Jones is that he finds a quarterback with the talent to start and he's done.

Since Jimmy's departure 29 years ago, the Cowboys have drafted 1 quarterback in the top three rounds of the NFL draft. Jerry has been forced to overpay his starting quarterbacks because he chooses to have zero other options at the position.

If the Cowboys had followed a simple process of drafting one quarterback in the top three rounds every three years he wouldn't have been forced to pay Dak a HOF/SB MVP contract. He would have created a level of competition that enhanced the performance at that position and he quite possibly would have had future excellent trade value.

Instead, he finds one potential starter and checks off the position for the next ten seasons. He fills the backup role with some marginal performer with limited skills and no future potential.

Now with a 17 game regular season schedule the need for additional options at QB become even more critical. So long as one quarterback is still in the 4 year rookie contract window, it isn't necessary to push a fifth of the cap in one direction. I can see doing this with a guy that took the team to a championship. Otherwise, Jerry is just paying for unrealized potential.

From 1993 to 2021 there have been 143 quarterbacks drafted in the top three rounds, an average of 4.5 quarterbacks per team and the Cowboys have drafted one..
You’re opening statement is what most teams hope for when searching for a quarterback. You’re talking about a position that only has 32 slots. Roughly half of those slots have players in them that aren’t talented enough to start, but they have no choice.
 

America's Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
33,490
Reaction score
46,917
My problem with Jerry Jones is that he finds a quarterback with the talent to start and he's done.

Since Jimmy's departure 29 years ago, the Cowboys have drafted 1 quarterback in the top three rounds of the NFL draft. Jerry has been forced to overpay his starting quarterbacks because he chooses to have zero other options at the position.

If the Cowboys had followed a simple process of drafting one quarterback in the top three rounds every three years he wouldn't have been forced to pay Dak a HOF/SB MVP contract. He would have created a level of competition that enhanced the performance at that position and he quite possibly would have had future excellent trade value.

Instead, he finds one potential starter and checks off the position for the next ten seasons. He fills the backup role with some marginal performer with limited skills and no future potential.

Now with a 17 game regular season schedule the need for additional options at QB become even more critical. So long as one quarterback is still in the 4 year rookie contract window, it isn't necessary to push a fifth of the cap in one direction. I can see doing this with a guy that took the team to a championship. Otherwise, Jerry is just paying for unrealized potential.

From 1993 to 2021 there have been 143 quarterbacks drafted in the top three rounds, an average of 4.5 quarterbacks per team and the Cowboys have drafted one..
So you don't like Dak? You wish you could trade him?

Sounds like another typical Dak rant thread that has infested this forum.

I will agree with you though that this team needs to draft several QBs every 4-5 years to compete with each other.
 

TRUTH87

Cowboy for Life
Messages
5,612
Reaction score
3,808
they need to start drafting one bc in four years we might need one.
 

plymkr

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,519
Reaction score
14,149
Jerry fears a QB with starting potential challenging his starter. He claims fear of a QB controversy. It's the sad error of a fool. :omg:
Exactly, and that's the problem with our GM and the QB situation. He let's his guys get comfortable. I totally agree with you and the OP. It's foolish and stupid. Jimmy brought in Walsh to compete with Aikman. He didn't give a crap about Aikman's feelings. Aikman won 3 super bowls and is in the HOF. Romo and Dak have been very comfortable and above average, with the rest of the team for 25 years.

You know, being a Cowboys fan is like being in an abusive marriage. Some glimpses of hope but decades of feeling bad.
 

75boyz

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,064
Reaction score
9,726
They acquired an undrafted guy, sat and developed him for 3 yrs.
10 yrs later they managed to squeeze every last bit of ability from a 4th rounder by surrounding him with optimal talent at most positions.
This has been the philosophy for the most important position on the field for close to 20 years.

Thankfully they both provided some varying degrees of success in the regular season.

To imagine how bad things could have been without these 2 incredible strokes of luck occurring would probably be similar to a Browns or Lions tale of futility.
At the very least, some regular season games were won and playoffs were at least achieved every few years or so. Even to include a number one playoff seed under each's guidance.

I think this team philosophy should be altered in the future towards the most important position on a team if their main goal is winning.

Regardless of opinion on the draft being a crap shoot and 1st rd QB picks not panning out.

Hope is not a strategy and luck should not be a philosophy.

I think the current guy's ceiling has been reached.

jmo
 
Last edited:

cffl2323

Well-Known Member
Messages
348
Reaction score
450
And who was that player that finally got us to take the plunge and take a QB early? Who oozed such skills and promise that even Jerry resisted the urge to take a TE in the second round????

Quincy ****** Carter, that's who. One highly drafted QB in the last three decades, and it's him. What a shocker we haven't had any success.
 
Top